The Tissot indicatrix is a geometric representation of the local distortion produced by a map projection. It describes how an infinitesimally small circle on the Earth's reference surface becomes an ellipse on a map. The ellipse's size, shape, and orientation reveal changes in scale, area, and angles at that point. Named after the French mathematician Nicolas Auguste Tissot, the construction is a fundamental tool in cartography for comparing projections and understanding their spatially varying distortion.
Geometric principle
A map projection transforms positions on a curved surface, usually a sphere or reference ellipsoid, into positions on a plane. Because these surfaces have different intrinsic geometries, no smooth projection can flatten an extended region of the Earth's surface while preserving all distances, areas, and angles.
At a sufficiently small scale, a smooth projection can be approximated by a linear transformation between the tangent plane of the reference surface and the map plane. A linear transformation maps a circle to an ellipse, provided it is nonsingular. This ellipse is the Tissot indicatrix.
Its two perpendicular principal axes represent:
- Maximum local scale, along the major axis.
- Minimum local scale, along the minor axis.
- Principal directions, the corresponding directions of stretching on the reference surface and on the map.
The principal directions on the surface are perpendicular, and their images are also perpendicular. Other pairs of perpendicular directions generally do not remain perpendicular. When both principal scales are equal, the indicatrix is a circle, and there is no local angular distortion.
The construction is infinitesimal: it describes the projection's derivative at a point, not the exact transformation of a finite circular region.
Mathematical formulation
Let and , with , denote the maximum and minimum local scale factors. These factors are conventionally normalized against the map's nominal scale, so that a value of means no local length distortion.
If a direction on the reference surface makes an angle with the maximum-scale principal direction, its scale factor is
Thus, the ellipse encodes scale in every direction, rather than merely along a meridian and a parallel.
Differential and principal scales
Choose orthonormal coordinates in the tangent plane of the reference surface and Cartesian coordinates in the map plane, with their units normalized consistently. Let be the Jacobian matrix of the projection in these coordinates. Then
where is a surface displacement and its mapped displacement.
The squared principal scales are the eigenvalues of
Equivalently, and are the singular values of . The singular value decomposition separates the transformation into rotations or reflections and stretching along perpendicular axes.
Geographic coordinates require special care because angular increments are not physical distances. On a sphere of radius , with longitude and latitude measured in radians, the local eastward and northward distances are
For a projection , the appropriate local matrix is therefore
away from the coordinate singularities at the poles. On an ellipsoid, the corresponding meridional and prime-vertical radii of curvature replace the spherical distance factors.
Area and angular distortion
The local area scale factor is
An indicatrix with preserves infinitesimal area, even if it is strongly elongated.
The maximum absolute change in the angle between two intersecting directions, conventionally denoted by , satisfies
or
Consequently, equal axes imply zero angular distortion. Increasing inequality between the axes indicates increasing angular distortion.
The ellipse alone does not identify an orientation reversal: the sign of , which distinguishes orientation preservation from reversal, is lost when only the ellipse's shape and size are shown.
Interpretation for projection classes
Conformal projections
A conformal projection preserves local angles. Its principal scales satisfy
so every indicatrix is a circle. The circles may nevertheless differ greatly in size across the map. Conformality therefore does not imply preservation of area or uniform scale.
For the spherical Mercator projection, normalized to true scale at the equator,
At latitude , both linear scale factors equal , and the area scale factor is . Indicatrices remain circular while growing toward the poles, where the projection is singular.
Equal-area projections
An equal-area projection satisfies
at regular points, after normalization to the nominal map scale. Its indicatrices have equal areas but usually different shapes and orientations. Stretching in one principal direction is compensated by compression in the other.
The Mollweide projection and Albers equal-area conic projection illustrate how area preservation can coexist with substantial angular and directional scale distortion.
Equidistant and compromise projections
An equidistant projection preserves distances along specified lines or from specified points, not between every pair of positions. Where a local direction has true scale, the mapped image of a unit vector in that direction has unit length; that direction need not coincide with a principal axis.
Compromise projections, such as the Winkel Tripel projection, balance several kinds of distortion without preserving either area or angles everywhere. Their indicatrices generally vary in both area and eccentricity.
History
Tissot developed his theory of projection distortion in the nineteenth century. His 1881 treatise, Mémoire sur la représentation des surfaces et les projections des cartes géographiques, presented a systematic treatment of local distortion through differential geometry.
The central contribution was to express distortion through perpendicular principal directions and their scale factors. This provided a general framework applicable to smooth projections, rather than relying only on measurements along meridians and parallels. The indicatrix subsequently became a standard device in cartographic teaching and projection analysis.
Construction and uses
Indicatrix diagrams commonly place ellipses at selected intersections of a geographic grid. All represent source circles of the same infinitesimal radius, enlarged by a common display factor so that they are visible. Comparison is meaningful only if this normalization is retained.
In a geographic information system or projection-analysis program, indicatrices can be calculated from analytical projection derivatives or numerical approximations. The results can help to:
- Compare candidate projections for a region.
- Locate areas of large scale or angular distortion.
- Check whether a projection behaves as conformal or equal-area.
- Explain why shapes and apparent sizes change across a world map.
- Evaluate distortion within a chosen coordinate reference system.
The indicatrix represents distortion relative to the chosen reference surface. It does not by itself include errors from surveying, positional data, terrain relief, or cartographic generalization.
Limitations
A visible ellipse is an enlarged symbol for an infinitesimal result. Projecting the boundary of a finite circle on the Earth generally produces a curve that is not exactly an ellipse, because distortion varies across the enclosed region.
Indicatrices also provide local rather than complete regional information. They do not directly show the error in a long route, whether a straight map line follows a shortest path on the Earth, or how an interrupted projection divides geographic features. A sparse grid may miss narrow zones of severe distortion.
At projection singularities, discontinuities, or points where the differential is degenerate, an ordinary finite, nondegenerate indicatrix is not available. Such locations require separate treatment rather than interpretation as conventional distortion ellipses.