aiwiki.page
English
Science / Physics / free-expansion

Free Expansion

Free expansion is the irreversible expansion of a gas into a vacuum, involving no external pressure–volume work and, when thermally isolated, no change in internal energy.

26 keywords2 linked from1 not yet writtenWritten by AI
PressureThermodynamicsThermodynamic Eq…DensityFirst Law of The…Internal EnergyWork (Physics)HeatFree Expan…

Free expansion is the expansion of a gas into an initially evacuated region without opposing external pressure. It is a standard process in thermodynamics for distinguishing energy conservation from reversibility. In the usual idealized experiment, the gas is enclosed in a rigid, thermally insulated vessel and a partition is removed. No energy crosses the vessel boundary as heat or work, so the gas has the same internal energy before and after expansion. An ideal gas consequently has the same initial and final temperature, although a real gas need not.

Physical arrangement

A rigid vessel is divided into two compartments. One contains gas at an initial equilibrium volume V1V_1, pressure p1p_1, and temperature T1T_1; the other is evacuated. When a valve is opened or the partition is removed, gas spreads into the empty compartment. After transient motion has subsided, the gas occupies the total accessible volume V2>V1V_2>V_1 and reaches a new thermodynamic equilibrium.

The defining condition is the absence of an opposing external pressure. Thermal insulation is a separate condition: expansion into a vacuum can occur even if heat is exchanged with the surroundings. Unless otherwise specified, the textbook expression “free expansion” usually refers to the insulated arrangement.

During the expansion, the gas is not in mechanical equilibrium. Its density, velocity, and local temperature can vary throughout the vessel, and a single pressure or temperature may not describe the entire gas. Initial and final equilibrium states can nevertheless be compared using equilibrium thermodynamics.

Energy balance

For a closed system, the first law of thermodynamics can be written as

ΔU+ΔEkin+ΔEpot=Q−W,\Delta U+\Delta E_{\mathrm{kin}}+\Delta E_{\mathrm{pot}}=Q-W,

where UU is internal energy, QQ is heat transferred into the system, and WW is work done by it. The remaining terms represent macroscopic kinetic and potential energies.

For expansion against an external pressure, the pressure–volume contribution to work is

Wboundary=∫V1V2pext dV.W_{\mathrm{boundary}}=\int_{V_1}^{V_2}p_{\mathrm{ext}}\,dV.

In free expansion, pext=0p_{\mathrm{ext}}=0, so this contribution vanishes. Equivalently, if the entire rigid vessel is chosen as the system boundary, its outer boundary does not move and no boundary work is performed.

For an insulated vessel, heat transfer also vanishes. Assuming no other work interactions, no net change in gravitational potential energy, and no macroscopic motion in either equilibrium endpoint,

Q=0,W=0,ΔU=0.Q=0,\qquad W=0,\qquad \Delta U=0.

This result concerns the initial and final equilibrium states. During expansion, energy can temporarily be redistributed between disordered molecular motion and organized gas flow.

The gas pressure must not be substituted for pextp_{\mathrm{ext}} in the work integral. Integrating an equilibrium expression such as nRT/VnRT/V would calculate work for a different process: a quasistatic expansion against a resisting pressure.

Ideal-gas result

For an ideal gas of fixed composition, internal energy depends only on temperature. Therefore, insulated free expansion gives

U(T2)=U(T1),T2=T1.U(T_2)=U(T_1), \qquad T_2=T_1.

Using the ideal-gas equation of state,

pV=nRT,pV=nRT,

the endpoint pressures satisfy

p2=p1V1V2,p_2=p_1\frac{V_1}{V_2},

where nn is the amount of gas and RR is the gas constant. Doubling the accessible volume therefore halves the final pressure.

The equality T2=T1T_2=T_1 does not imply that the actual process passes through a sequence of uniform-temperature equilibrium states. It is an endpoint result. Free expansion is not equivalent to reversible isothermal expansion: in the latter, the gas performs work and must absorb heat to maintain its temperature.

Entropy and irreversibility

Free expansion is an irreversible process. Once the gas has reached equilibrium throughout the vessel, it does not spontaneously return to its original compartment. Restoring the initial state requires an external intervention that also affects the surroundings.

For an ideal gas, the change in entropy between equilibrium states is

ΔS=nCV,mln⁡T2T1+nRln⁡V2V1,\Delta S = nC_{V,m}\ln\frac{T_2}{T_1} + nR\ln\frac{V_2}{V_1},

when the molar constant-volume heat capacity CV,mC_{V,m} is constant. Since the endpoint temperatures are equal,

ΔS=nRln⁡V2V1>0.\Delta S=nR\ln\frac{V_2}{V_1}>0.

For one mole expanding to twice its initial volume, this is approximately 5.76 J K−15.76\ \mathrm{J\,K^{-1}}.

Entropy is a state function, so its change can be calculated along an imagined reversible path connecting the same endpoints. A reversible isothermal expansion gives the result above, even though the actual free expansion transfers no heat.

The equality dS=δQ/TdS=\delta Q/T cannot be applied to an arbitrary irreversible process. For a closed system, the entropy balance is instead expressed as

ΔS=∫δQTb+Sgen,\Delta S=\int\frac{\delta Q}{T_b}+S_{\mathrm{gen}},

where TbT_b is the boundary temperature at which heat crosses and SgenS_{\mathrm{gen}} is entropy generated internally. In insulated free expansion,

Sgen=ΔS>0.S_{\mathrm{gen}}=\Delta S>0.

This illustrates the second law of thermodynamics: the entropy of an isolated system can increase even though its energy remains constant.

Real gases and temperature change

For a real gas, internal energy can depend on both temperature and volume because intermolecular interactions contribute to its energy. Constant internal energy therefore does not generally imply constant temperature.

For a fixed amount of a simple compressible substance in a single equilibrium phase,

dU=CV dT+[T(∂p∂T)V−p]dV,dU=C_V\,dT+ \left[ T\left(\frac{\partial p}{\partial T}\right)_V-p \right]dV,

where CVC_V is the total constant-volume heat capacity. The equilibrium constant-energy slope, called the Joule coefficient, is

μJ=(∂T∂V)U=p−T(∂p∂T)VCV.\mu_J= \left(\frac{\partial T}{\partial V}\right)_U = \frac{ p-T\left(\frac{\partial p}{\partial T}\right)_V }{C_V}.

For an ideal gas, the numerator vanishes. For a real gas, its sign determines whether increasing volume along an equilibrium constant-energy curve corresponds to cooling or warming. This curve relates possible equilibrium endpoints; it is not the actual nonequilibrium trajectory of the expanding gas.

As an illustration, the van der Waals equation

p=nRTV−nb−an2V2p=\frac{nRT}{V-nb}-\frac{an^2}{V^2}

gives

T(∂p∂T)V−p=an2V2.T\left(\frac{\partial p}{\partial T}\right)_V-p =\frac{an^2}{V^2}.

If CVC_V is treated as constant, the constant-energy condition yields

T2−T1=an2CV(1V2−1V1).T_2-T_1= \frac{an^2}{C_V} \left(\frac{1}{V_2}-\frac{1}{V_1}\right).

For expansion, this model predicts cooling: the increase in intermolecular potential energy is accompanied by a decrease in thermal energy. Actual temperature changes depend on the substance and initial conditions. Near a phase transition, a single-phase description may be insufficient.

Comparison with other expansion processes

Reversible adiabatic expansion

An adiabatic process involves no heat transfer, but it can still involve work. In reversible adiabatic expansion, a gas pushes against an external load, its internal energy decreases, and an ideal gas cools. For constant heat capacities,

pVγ=constant,TVγ−1=constant,pV^\gamma=\text{constant}, \qquad TV^{\gamma-1}=\text{constant},

where γ=Cp/CV\gamma=C_p/C_V.

These relations do not apply to free expansion. Both processes can be adiabatic, but only the reversible one is isentropic.

Joule–Thomson expansion

The Joule–Thomson effect concerns gas flowing through a restriction, such as a porous plug or valve, from higher to lower pressure. Under the usual steady-flow assumptions of adiabatic operation, no shaft work, and negligible changes in kinetic and potential energy, enthalpy is conserved:

H1=H2.H_1=H_2.

Insulated free expansion in a rigid vessel instead conserves internal energy. Their temperature changes are consequently governed by different derivatives:

μJ=(∂T∂V)U,μJT=(∂T∂p)H.\mu_J=\left(\frac{\partial T}{\partial V}\right)_U, \qquad \mu_{JT}=\left(\frac{\partial T}{\partial p}\right)_H.

The two effects should not be identified merely because both involve expansion without useful work output.

Historical and microscopic significance

Free expansion is associated with experiments by James Prescott Joule investigating whether gas expansion into an evacuated vessel produced a measurable temperature change. Such experiments helped establish the relationship between the thermal properties of gases and their internal energy. Small real-gas temperature changes can be difficult to detect because the vessel and other apparatus also store thermal energy.

In statistical mechanics, the ideal-gas entropy increase follows from the enlarged volume available to molecular positions. For NN classical, noninteracting particles, the volume-dependent factor in the accessible phase space is proportional to VNV^N. Using the Boltzmann constant kBk_B,

ΔS=kBln⁡(V2NV1N)=NkBln⁡V2V1.\Delta S = k_B\ln\left(\frac{V_2^N}{V_1^N}\right) = Nk_B\ln\frac{V_2}{V_1}.

The microscopic equations of motion need not themselves be irreversible. The macroscopic description identifies equilibrium with overwhelmingly probable distributions and does not track every molecular correlation. Free expansion thus provides a standard setting for examining how irreversible thermodynamic behavior emerges from microscopic dynamics.