Electrospray ionization (ESI) is a technique that transfers substances dissolved in a liquid into gas-phase ions for analysis by mass spectrometry. A strong electric field produces a spray of electrically charged droplets, which lose solvent and ultimately release ions. ESI is considered a soft ionization method because it can generate intact molecular ions with relatively little fragmentation. Its ability to produce multiply charged ions makes it especially useful for analyzing large, nonvolatile molecules, including proteins, peptides, and nucleic acids.
Operating principle
An electrospray source normally consists of a narrow liquid emitter, a high-voltage connection, and an inlet leading to the mass spectrometer. A sample solution flows through the emitter while an electric potential difference—typically a few kilovolts in conventional arrangements—is applied between the liquid and a nearby counterelectrode or instrument inlet.
The resulting electric field causes charge to accumulate at the liquid surface. When electrical stresses overcome the restoring effect of surface tension, the liquid meniscus forms a cone, commonly called a Taylor cone. In a stable cone-jet operating regime, a fine liquid jet emerges from its tip and breaks into charged droplets. Other spray regimes can occur, particularly when flow rate, conductivity, or applied voltage is unsuitable.
The droplets travel through a region usually near atmospheric pressure. Heated gas, a heated inlet, or both assist solvent evaporation. As droplets shrink, their charge becomes increasingly concentrated. They can undergo repeated charge-driven breakup, producing smaller droplets from which gas-phase analyte ions eventually emerge.
The ions enter the mass spectrometer through an atmospheric-pressure interface. Differential pumping and ion optics transfer a fraction of them into the lower-pressure regions used for mass analysis. Droplet formation, ion production, and ion transmission are distinct processes: a strong spray current does not necessarily imply a strong analyte signal.
Positive and negative ion modes
In positive-ion mode, common products include protonated molecules, such as , and ions carrying several additional protons, such as . Sodium, ammonium, and other cations can also form adducts.
In negative-ion mode, common products include deprotonated molecules, such as , multiply deprotonated species, and anion adducts. The preferred mode depends on the analyte’s functional groups, solution conditions, and the desired analytical selectivity.
Electrospray does not simply remove electrons from every analyte molecule. Many detected ions arise from charged species already present in solution or from proton-transfer and adduct-forming processes during droplet evolution. Electrochemical reactions at the liquid–electrode interface help sustain the spray current and can also modify susceptible analytes.
Droplet stability and ion formation
The Rayleigh limit
A charged droplet becomes unstable when electrical repulsion becomes too large relative to surface tension. For an ideal isolated, spherical, conducting droplet, the Rayleigh limiting charge is
where is the limiting charge, is the vacuum permittivity, is surface tension, and is droplet radius.
As evaporation reduces , the limiting charge decreases. A droplet approaching instability can eject smaller, highly charged progeny droplets through Coulomb fission. Such events need not divide the parent droplet into equal portions; relatively little liquid can carry away a substantial fraction of its charge.
The Rayleigh expression provides a useful physical framework, but real electrospray droplets may depart from its assumptions because of deformation, finite conductivity, changing composition, and interactions with their surroundings.
Models of gas-phase ion production
Several mechanisms explain how analytes leave the final droplets. They describe different limiting behaviors rather than a single universally established pathway.
- Charged-residue model. Repeated evaporation and fission produce a small droplet containing an individual analyte molecule. Loss of the remaining solvent leaves the analyte carrying residual charge. This model is particularly important for compact macromolecules and many native protein ions.
- Ion-evaporation model. Very small droplets develop sufficiently strong surface electric fields to emit solvated ions directly. Further desolvation yields gas-phase ions. This mechanism is especially relevant to small ions.
- Chain-ejection model. An extended polymer or unfolded protein can protrude from a droplet and progressively leave it while acquiring charge. This provides a framework for understanding the relatively high charge states of many unfolded proteins.
The dominant pathway depends on analyte size, conformation, surface affinity, solvent properties, and droplet conditions. A single electrospray can contain species that follow different pathways.
Multiple charging and mass spectra
One of ESI’s defining features is its ability to place many charges on a single molecule. Mass spectrometers separate ions by mass-to-charge ratio, conventionally written , rather than by neutral molecular mass alone. Multiple charging therefore allows a large molecule to appear within an instrument’s accessible range.
For a molecule with neutral monoisotopic mass , an ion formed by addition of protons has
when masses are expressed numerically in daltons and is the proton mass in daltons. Here is the positive integer charge number.
For example, a protein of approximately Da carrying 25 additional protons appears near , rather than near . A typical protein spectrum contains a charge-state distribution: several peaks or groups of peaks corresponding to different charge states of the same molecule.
Software can combine these signals to reconstruct a neutral mass distribution, a process known as deconvolution. Reliable interpretation must account for overlapping charge states, adducts, chemical heterogeneity, and resolved or unresolved isotope patterns. For sufficiently resolved isotopic peaks, their spacing is approximately in units, providing a means of identifying charge.
Charge-state distributions also contain information about molecular conformation. Unfolded proteins often acquire more charges than compact proteins of the same mass. However, charge is also affected by solvent composition, pH, additives, and source settings, so a charge-state distribution is not an unambiguous measurement of solution structure.
Instrument configurations and variants
Conventional electrospray
Conventional sources commonly operate at liquid flow rates from a few microliters per minute to hundreds of microliters per minute, with some interfaces accommodating higher flows. Pneumatically assisted sources use a surrounding gas stream to aid droplet formation and desolvation.
The emitter can be a metal capillary or another type of conductive or electrically contacted tip. Instrument designs differ in emitter orientation, inlet geometry, gas delivery, and heating. These details affect spray stability, contamination, and ion transmission.
Nanoelectrospray
Nanoelectrospray ionization uses very low liquid flow rates, often in the tens to hundreds of nanoliters per minute, and small emitter openings. It can produce smaller initial droplets, reduce sample consumption, and improve the fraction of analyte reaching the gas phase under suitable conditions.
Nanoelectrospray is widely used for limited samples, protein analysis, and low-flow separations. Its practical limitations include emitter clogging, variable tip properties, and the difficulty of maintaining reproducible operation.
Coupling to separation methods
ESI is especially well suited to online liquid chromatography because the separation already supplies a continuous liquid stream. Liquid chromatography–electrospray mass spectrometry, often abbreviated LC–ESI–MS, combines separation of mixtures with mass-based detection.
Electrospray can also be coupled to capillary electrophoresis. In both arrangements, the separation conditions and ion source must be compatible: a buffer that provides good separation may produce excessive background or suppress ionization.
Native electrospray
Native mass spectrometry uses electrospray conditions intended to retain aspects of folded structure and noncovalent association. Aqueous, volatile buffer systems and carefully controlled transfer conditions can preserve protein complexes and protein–ligand assemblies long enough for measurement.
“Native” describes the experimental approach, not proof that every gas-phase ion retains an unchanged solution structure. Solvent removal alters the balance of electrostatic, hydrophobic, and other interactions, and activation during transfer can cause rearrangement or dissociation.
Analytical applications
Electrospray is a central technique in analytical chemistry and biomolecular analysis.
- Proteomics. ESI is widely used in proteomics to analyze peptides produced by protein digestion, identify proteins, and characterize modifications. It also supports intact-protein analysis.
- Small-molecule analysis. Pharmaceuticals, metabolites, environmental contaminants, and many other polar or ionizable compounds can be detected and quantified by LC–ESI–MS.
- Nucleic-acid and oligonucleotide analysis. Negative-ion ESI can generate multiply charged ions from DNA, RNA, and synthetic oligonucleotides.
- Macromolecular complexes. Native ESI supports measurements of assembly composition, subunit stoichiometry, and bound molecules.
- Synthetic materials. Suitable polymers and other nonvolatile compounds can be characterized through their molecular-mass distributions and adduct patterns.
ESI is often combined with tandem mass spectrometry, in which selected precursor ions are fragmented and the resulting product ions are analyzed. This provides structural information and greater selectivity than an intact-ion mass measurement alone. The initial soft ionization and subsequent controlled fragmentation perform complementary roles.
Factors controlling response
Electrospray response is not determined solely by the amount of analyte entering the source. Important variables include:
- Solution composition: solvent volatility, conductivity, surface tension, pH, and additives.
- Analyte properties: chargeability, surface affinity, hydrophobicity, and tendency to form aggregates or adducts.
- Source conditions: flow rate, emitter geometry, applied voltage, gas flow, and temperature.
- Instrument transmission: sampling efficiency and the mass- and charge-dependent behavior of ion optics.
Mixtures of water with volatile organic solvents are common, although the composition must match the analyte and separation. Nonvolatile salts can leave deposits, promote adduct formation, and reduce signal quality.
A major limitation is ion suppression, in which other sample components reduce an analyte’s response. Coexisting substances can alter droplet properties, compete for charge or droplet-surface access, and interfere with desolvation or ion transfer. Some mixtures instead produce signal enhancement. These effects are collectively known as matrix effects.
Consequently, equal molar amounts of different compounds need not give equal signal intensities. Quantitative methods commonly use calibration, suitable internal standards, and evaluation of matrix effects. Electrospray intensity alone is not a universal direct measure of concentration.
Limitations and interpretation
ESI works best for compounds that can be brought into a suitable liquid phase and form stable ions. Weakly polar, poorly ionizable molecules may respond poorly, even when present at substantial concentration.
Although considered soft, ESI does not guarantee an absence of fragmentation. Energetic transfer conditions can cause in-source fragmentation, while insufficient desolvation can leave solvent clusters and adducts. Fragile complexes can dissociate, and concentrated droplets can promote associations that were uncommon in the original solution.
Observed spectra may therefore differ from the original solution population. Differential ionization efficiencies, droplet chemistry, electrochemical reactions, and selective transmission can all introduce biases. Detecting an ion establishes that it formed and survived under the measurement conditions; it does not, by itself, establish its abundance or stability in bulk solution.
Historical development
The development of ESI drew on earlier research into electrically driven liquid spraying and the stability of charged droplets. John Zeleny investigated electrical discharge from liquid points in the early twentieth century, and Geoffrey Ingram Taylor later developed the electrohydrodynamic description associated with the conical liquid surface.
In 1968, Malcolm Dole and colleagues proposed the charged-residue mechanism in work aimed at producing gas-phase macromolecular ions. During the 1980s, John B. Fenn and collaborators established electrospray as a practical interface for mass spectrometry. Masamichi Yamashita and Fenn reported electrospray ion-source work in 1984, and a landmark 1989 publication demonstrated its importance for analyzing large biomolecules.
The combination of gentle ion production and multiple charging helped make mass spectrometry a major tool for biological macromolecules. Fenn received a share of the 2002 Nobel Prize in Chemistry for developing soft desorption ionization methods for mass spectrometric analysis of biological macromolecules.