Underemployment is a condition in which people who are employed do not have enough work, or their jobs do not adequately use their skills, qualifications, or productive capacity. It describes forms of incomplete employment that are not captured by unemployment alone. In official statistics, the most clearly standardized form is time-related underemployment: employed people want additional working hours, work below a specified hours threshold, and are available to work more. Broader uses include employment below a worker’s qualification level and work that generates inadequate income, although these conditions require different measures.
Definitions and boundaries
Underemployment concerns the extent and quality of employment rather than simply whether a person has a job. A person can therefore be classified as employed while still facing a substantial shortage of work.
The distinction matters because employment statistics generally use a relatively low activity threshold. Under international statistical standards, someone who performs at least one hour of work for pay or profit during a short reference period can normally qualify as employed; certain people temporarily absent from their jobs are also included. Employment status consequently does not establish that a worker has sufficient hours, adequate earnings, or a suitable occupational match.
The International Labour Organization distinguishes time-related underemployment from other dimensions of inadequate employment. Its international standards adopted in 1998 formalized this distinction, while the 2013 framework for work and employment statistics placed time-related underemployment within a broader set of measures of labour underutilization.
Several boundaries are important:
- Voluntary part-time work is not necessarily underemployment. A person satisfied with a shorter schedule does not meet the desire-for-more-hours criterion.
- Low pay alone does not establish time-related underemployment. A full-time worker may have inadequate earnings without having insufficient hours.
- Qualification mismatch is not identical to an hours shortage. A graduate working full time in a job requiring fewer qualifications may be underemployed in a broader sense but not underemployed under the time-related statistical definition.
- People without employment are classified separately. Whether they count as unemployed or outside the labour force depends on job-search and availability criteria.
Main forms
Time-related underemployment
Time-related underemployment identifies employed people who, during the relevant reference periods:
- Want to work additional hours.
- Have worked fewer hours than a specified threshold.
- Are available to work additional hours.
Additional hours may come from a second job, longer hours in an existing job, or a replacement job with longer hours. Hours across all jobs are relevant, rather than those in the main job alone.
The hours threshold is set through national statistical practice, taking account of circumstances such as the boundary between full-time and part-time work. It is not a universal number. Availability is also assessed over a specified period.
A restaurant employee receiving only a few shifts despite wanting and being available for more work is a typical example. The same issue can affect self-employed people whose businesses provide too little work. Underemployment is therefore not limited to wage employees or formal employment.
Skills-related underemployment
In broader usage, underemployment includes jobs that make insufficient use of a worker’s human capital. This is part of skills mismatch and may involve:
- Overqualification: the worker’s formal qualification exceeds the level associated with the job.
- Overskilling: the worker possesses skills that the job does not substantially use.
- Occupational mismatch: the job lies outside the worker’s field of preparation, sometimes with limited use of relevant expertise.
These conditions overlap but are not interchangeable. A qualification does not directly measure all skills, and working outside a field of study does not necessarily imply that a person’s abilities are underused. Some workers deliberately accept a different occupation for flexibility, location, career transition, or other benefits.
Income-related and low-productivity employment
Some analyses use underemployment to describe work that yields insufficient earnings or contributes little additional output. Such situations are particularly relevant where people cannot afford to remain openly unemployed and instead undertake intermittent or low-return activities in the informal economy.
However, low earnings can arise from short hours, low hourly remuneration, weak business returns, or a combination of factors. These are analytically different problems.
The related idea of disguised unemployment concerns workers whose removal from an activity would cause little or no reduction in output. It has often been discussed in relation to family farming and surplus labour. It is not equivalent to the statistical definition of time-related underemployment: people can work long hours in a low-productivity activity.
Measurement
Survey information
Time-related underemployment is usually measured through household labour-force surveys. Relevant questions cover actual working hours, the desire for additional hours, and availability to work more.
Results depend on survey design. Differences in hours thresholds, reference periods, question wording, treatment of temporary absences, and seasonal timing can affect comparisons. A person’s usual schedule and the hours actually worked during a particular week may also differ considerably.
The number of underemployed people does not measure the total shortage of hours. Two workers may both qualify as underemployed even though one wants two additional hours per week and the other wants twenty. Supplementary measures of desired additional hours can therefore provide useful information.
Rates and denominators
A time-related underemployment rate may be expressed as a share of employed people:
where is the number in time-related underemployment and is total employment. Published indicators must be checked for their denominator, since some instead express underemployment relative to the labour force.
The ILO’s combined rate of time-related underemployment and unemployment, designated LU2, is:
where is unemployment and is the labour force.
Broader indicators also include the potential labour force: people outside the labour force who either sought employment but were not currently available, or wanted and were available for employment but had not actively sought it. The broadest of the ILO’s four headline underutilization measures, LU4, is:
where denotes the potential labour force.
These measures complement the unemployment rate rather than replace it. They distinguish different ways in which the supply of labour exceeds its utilization.
In the United States, the official U-6 measure combines unemployment, people marginally attached to the labour force, and people working part time for economic reasons. It is a broader indicator of labour underutilization, but its component definitions are not identical to those of LU4.
Causes and economic mechanisms
Insufficient demand
During a recession, employers may reduce hours before dismissing workers. Businesses can retain experienced staff while adjusting labour input to weaker sales. This allows employment headcounts to decline less than total hours worked, but increases underemployment among workers who want their previous schedules.
Weak aggregate demand can also reduce customer demand for self-employed workers. Underemployment may persist during an economic recovery if existing employees receive additional hours only gradually or if new jobs offer shorter schedules.
Structural and matching problems
Underemployment can reflect a mismatch between available workers and available jobs. Relevant factors include changes in occupational demand, geographical barriers, difficulties recognizing qualifications, and limited information about vacancies. These mechanisms overlap with those associated with structural unemployment.
For example, a technically qualified worker may accept a less specialized job when suitable positions are unavailable locally. The immediate result is employment, but potentially incomplete use of specialized knowledge.
Work organization and institutional conditions
Seasonal demand, variable scheduling, casual contracts, and project-based work can produce large fluctuations in hours. Workers may remain attached to employers or platforms without receiving enough paid work.
The ability to obtain additional hours also depends on scheduling compatibility, transport, care responsibilities, and the availability of alternative employers. Employer market power and the institutions governing collective bargaining can influence workers’ bargaining position over hours and job conditions.
Consequences
Insufficient hours can reduce earnings and make household income less predictable. Persistent skills-related underemployment may limit opportunities to apply specialized knowledge, accumulate relevant experience, and progress into better-matched occupations. The effects vary with the duration of the mismatch and whether the job serves as a temporary stepping stone.
At the aggregate level, underemployment indicates that employment headcounts alone may overstate the utilization of labour. It can coexist with slow wage growth, weak household spending, and poverty among employed households. Unequal exposure to short hours or poor occupational matches can also contribute to income inequality.
The relationship with labour productivity is not straightforward. Time-related underemployment measures a shortage of hours, not output per hour. Skills underuse may reduce potential productivity, but the size of that loss cannot be inferred from qualifications alone.
Interpretation and policy relevance
Underemployment is useful for assessing labour-market conditions when the unemployment rate gives an incomplete picture. A fall in unemployment accompanied by rising involuntary short hours differs from a fall accompanied by expanding hours and stronger occupational matching. Conversely, a decline in the underemployment rate may reflect either improved access to work or changes in workers’ stated willingness and availability.
Policy analysis therefore separates demand-related hours shortages from structural mismatches and problems of job quality. Fiscal policy and monetary policy address aggregate economic conditions, while education, qualification recognition, job matching, childcare provision, and employment regulation concern other mechanisms. Their relevance depends on the source of underemployment rather than on the label alone.
No single indicator captures all these dimensions. Hours-based measures provide a relatively standardized account of insufficient work, while skills, earnings, and job-quality measures describe distinct aspects of inadequate employment.