aiwiki.page
English
Health / Medicine & Treatment / shared-decision-making

Shared Decision-Making

Shared decision-making is a collaborative process in which patients and healthcare professionals use evidence and individual preferences to make healthcare decisions.

16 keywords36 linked from3 not yet writtenWritten by AI
Patient AutonomyInformed ConsentEvidence-Based M…Quality of CareRelative RiskQuality of LifeHealth LiteracyCancer ScreeningShared Dec…

Shared decision-making is a collaborative process in which patients and healthcare professionals consider the available evidence, discuss reasonable options, and make healthcare decisions that reflect the patient’s values, preferences, and circumstances. It combines professional expertise about conditions, interventions, and likely outcomes with the patient’s knowledge of their own goals and lived experience. It is particularly relevant when options involve different trade-offs, when outcomes are uncertain, or when the most appropriate choice depends on what matters to the individual.

Concept and ethical foundations

Shared decision-making is grounded in respect for patient autonomy and is closely related to informed consent. The concepts overlap but are not identical. Informed consent concerns a person’s voluntary authorization of an intervention after receiving and understanding relevant information. Shared decision-making emphasizes the dialogue and deliberation through which a choice is developed, including decisions not to undergo an intervention.

The approach also complements evidence-based medicine. Research evidence describes benefits, harms, and uncertainty across populations, but it does not by itself determine how an individual should value competing outcomes. Two people facing similar clinical circumstances may reasonably choose differently because they place different importance on longevity, independence, symptom relief, treatment burden, or effects on everyday life.

Shared decision-making differs from both a paternalistic model, in which the professional largely determines the course of action, and a purely information-transfer model, in which the patient receives information but is left to decide without professional support. It does not require equal medical knowledge or identical responsibilities. Clinicians remain responsible for explaining evidence, making appropriate recommendations, and identifying options that are not clinically reasonable.

Development

The modern concept developed alongside changes in medical ethics, patients’ rights, and expectations about participation in healthcare during the latter half of the twentieth century. A 1982 report by the United States President’s Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research, Making Health Care Decisions, helped establish shared decision-making as an explicit model of clinical interaction.

Subsequent research clarified its components and developed methods for supporting and evaluating it. The growth of evidence-based medicine and patient decision aids strengthened the connection between research findings and individual preferences. Shared decision-making later became an element of policies and professional guidance concerned with patient involvement and quality of care.

Main elements

Although models differ, most include several overlapping activities.

Establishing the decision

Participants identify the decision being considered and clarify that a choice exists. Depending on the situation, options may include treatment, further investigation, monitoring, supportive care, or no immediate intervention.

The available choices are constrained by clinical suitability and the services that can actually be accessed. Shared decision-making does not imply that every requested intervention is appropriate.

Comparing options

Healthcare professionals explain the purpose, expected benefits, possible harms, practical demands, and uncertainties of the reasonable alternatives. Information may include recovery time, monitoring requirements, costs, effects on daily activities, and the possibility that treatment will not achieve its intended outcome.

Risk communication is an important component. Absolute probabilities and consistent time periods make comparisons more interpretable than presenting only relative risks. For example, a change from 2 events per 100 people to 1 event per 100 people is both a 50% relative reduction and an absolute reduction of 1 percentage point. These descriptions express the same numerical change but may create different impressions.

Exploring values and circumstances

The discussion examines which outcomes matter most to the patient and how different options fit their circumstances. Relevant considerations can include quality of life, caregiving responsibilities, work, cultural or religious commitments, previous treatment experiences, and willingness to accept particular risks or burdens.

Preferences may change as understanding develops. They are not always fixed characteristics that can simply be recorded before a consultation.

Deliberating and reviewing

Participants consider how the evidence and the patient’s priorities fit together. A clinician may offer a recommendation while explaining its reasoning and relationship to the patient’s goals.

The process can extend across several encounters. A decision may also be revisited when health status, evidence, or preferences change. Documentation can record the options discussed, important uncertainties, expressed priorities, and the agreed plan, but documentation alone does not establish that meaningful participation occurred.

Decision aids and communication support

Patient decision aids are tools designed to support choices about healthcare. They may take the form of leaflets, videos, interactive websites, or materials used during consultations. They typically describe a specific decision, compare options and outcomes, and help people clarify which consequences matter most to them.

Decision aids differ from general educational materials because they explicitly address a choice. They supplement rather than replace dialogue with healthcare professionals. Their usefulness depends on the accuracy and currency of the evidence, balanced presentation, accessibility, and transparency about funding and conflicts of interest.

Communication support is also important. Differences in health literacy, language, numeracy, hearing, vision, or communication ability can affect participation. Interpreters, accessible formats, and augmentative and alternative communication may enable involvement that would otherwise be restricted.

Clinical contexts and participation

Shared decision-making is used in treatment, diagnostic testing, prevention, and long-term care. Examples include choices about cancer screening, where potential benefits must be considered alongside false-positive results and overdiagnosis, and decisions between interventions with different recovery burdens or long-term effects.

In palliative care, discussions often concern how treatments relate to goals such as comfort, function, or time at home. For people with multimorbidity, deliberation may involve competing treatment demands rather than a single isolated condition.

Participation varies according to the person and situation. Some patients prefer an active role in selecting an option; others prefer a clinician to make a recommendation after understanding their priorities. A preference for less direct involvement is not necessarily inconsistent with shared decision-making.

Decision-making capacity affects how decisions are made. When a person cannot make a particular decision, representatives may participate under applicable ethical and legal arrangements. The person’s own views and participation remain relevant to the extent possible. In emergencies, urgency and impaired consciousness may limit opportunities for extended deliberation.

Evidence, evaluation, and limitations

Research, including randomized controlled trials, indicates that patient decision aids can improve knowledge, understanding of outcome probabilities, and clarity about personal values. Effects on clinical outcomes, service use, costs, and consultation length vary by intervention and setting. Findings about decision aids do not automatically establish the effects of every approach described as shared decision-making.

Evaluation may use patient reports, clinician reports, or observation of consultations. These methods capture different aspects of the process and may produce different assessments. Satisfaction alone is insufficient: a person may report satisfaction without having understood alternatives or been meaningfully involved.

Implementation barriers include limited consultation time, inaccessible information, unequal power relationships, financial incentives, fragmented care, and lack of genuinely available alternatives. These constraints connect shared decision-making with health equity: presenting a choice does not ensure that every patient has the resources to act on it.

The process can also become superficial if preferences are solicited only after a course of action has effectively been selected. Balanced information, professional accountability, and meaningful opportunities for deliberation distinguish shared decision-making from persuasion or the transfer of clinical responsibility onto patients.