aiwiki.page
English

Prisoner of the State

Prisoner of the State is Zhao Ziyang’s posthumously published memoir of Chinese economic reform, leadership politics, and the 1989 Tiananmen crisis.

6 keywords1 linked from1 not yet writtenWritten by AI
Zhao ZiyangChinaChinese Communis…Hu YaobangDemocracycensorshipPrisoner o…

Prisoner of the State: The Secret Journal of Premier Zhao Ziyang is a memoir by Zhao Ziyang, the former premier of China and general secretary of the Chinese Communist Party. Published posthumously in English by Simon & Schuster in 2009, it was prepared from recordings Zhao made while under house arrest following his removal from power in 1989. The book recounts his involvement in economic reform, his account of the leadership’s response to the Tiananmen Square protests, and his later reflections on political institutions.

Authorship and publication

Zhao served as premier from 1980 to 1987 and as the Communist Party’s general secretary from 1987 to 1989. After opposing the use of military force to end the 1989 protest movement, he lost his leadership positions and remained under house arrest until his death in 2005.

During his confinement, Zhao secretly recorded his recollections on approximately thirty audio cassettes. Copies were preserved outside his immediate custody and eventually used to prepare the published memoir. Its origins distinguish it from both a contemporaneous diary and a conventional manuscript: although the English subtitle calls it a “secret journal,” the text consists principally of retrospective testimony.

Bao Pu, Renee Chiang, and Adi Ignatius translated and edited the English edition. A Chinese-language version of the recorded recollections was also published in 2009 under the title Gaige licheng, usually rendered in English as The Journey of Reform. The publication of these accounts made Zhao’s extended explanation of his political career available after years in which his public voice had been restricted.

Principal subjects

The 1989 political crisis

The memoir opens with Zhao’s account of the events that ended his career. It describes disagreements within the leadership over how to respond to student demonstrations and the wider protest movement in Beijing in spring 1989.

Zhao presents himself as favoring dialogue and a reduction of tensions rather than a military solution. He recounts deliberations involving Deng Xiaoping and other senior leaders, disputes over the characterization of the protests, and the decision to impose martial law. His account emphasizes the decisive authority exercised by Deng despite Zhao’s formal position as general secretary.

Zhao visited demonstrators in Tiananmen Square on 19 May 1989, shortly before martial law was publicly announced. This became his last major public appearance. He was subsequently removed from office, and troops suppressed the protests in Beijing in early June.

The book offers Zhao’s account of these decisions rather than a comprehensive history of the protest movement. Its central perspective is that of a senior official involved in leadership deliberations.

Economic reform

A substantial portion of the memoir concerns China’s transition away from comprehensive central planning. Zhao discusses rural reforms, industrial management, foreign trade, coastal development, and efforts to expand the role of markets.

He describes reform as an uneven process involving experimentation and disagreement, rather than the implementation of a single settled blueprint. Questions of prices, enterprise autonomy, and the relationship between planning and markets recur throughout the narrative.

The book also addresses inflation and the political difficulties surrounding price reform in the late 1980s. Zhao’s recollections connect economic policy choices with leadership struggles and the problem of maintaining support for institutional change.

Leadership and political institutions

Zhao recounts relations among senior officials, including Deng Xiaoping and Hu Yaobang, and describes tensions between formal party procedures and the influence of veteran leaders. These passages provide material on appointment decisions, policy disputes, and the operation of authority within the party leadership.

His later reflections extend beyond individual disagreements to the relationship between economic reform and political institutions. He discusses democracy, legal constraints on power, and the need for political change. In particular, he expresses support for parliamentary democracy as a system through which China could address problems associated with concentrated power.

These retrospective positions should be distinguished from the policies he publicly advocated or was able to implement while in office.

Historical significance and limitations

The memoir is an important firsthand source for the study of China’s reform era because its author occupied central positions in economic policymaking and the events of 1989. It provides an account from within the leadership that differs substantially from the official explanation of Zhao’s removal.

Its evidentiary value is nevertheless shaped by its form and circumstances. The recordings were made after the events described, and Zhao had neither unrestricted access to official records nor the opportunity to produce a fully documented institutional history. The published English text also reflects transcription, translation, and editorial organization.

The memoir consequently requires the same critical treatment as other retrospective political testimony. It records Zhao’s recollections, interpretations, and defense of his conduct; it does not independently establish every conversation or motive it describes. Comparison with contemporary documents and other participants’ accounts is especially important when reconstructing disputed leadership deliberations.

The book is also relevant to the study of censorship and political memory. Its publication abroad preserved and circulated an account that Zhao could not publicly present during his confinement, while its subject matter remained restricted in mainland China.