A primordial black hole is a hypothetical black hole formed through processes in the early universe rather than through the death of a star. Proposed formation mechanisms include the gravitational collapse of unusually dense regions, collisions of expanding vacuum bubbles, and the collapse of certain topological defects. Depending on the mechanism and formation epoch, primordial black holes could have initial masses far below those of stars or comparable to the masses of supermassive black holes.
Primordial black holes connect cosmology, general relativity, and particle physics. They could preserve information about conditions on scales inaccessible to observations of the cosmic microwave background, contribute to dark matter, or provide seeds for larger black holes. Very small examples would lose mass through Hawking radiation, making them possible probes of quantum effects in strong gravitational fields.
No observation has established that a black hole is primordial. Searches therefore combine theoretical predictions with constraints from gravitational lensing, radiation backgrounds, cosmic expansion and structure, and black-hole mergers. The resulting limits depend on mass, spatial distribution, formation history, and the assumptions used to model each observable.
Historical development and the meaning of “primordial”
The possibility of black-hole formation before stars developed emerged from studies of the early universe in the 1960s. Yakov Zel’dovich and Igor Novikov discussed such objects in 1966, and Stephen Hawking examined gravitationally collapsed objects of very small mass in 1971. The central insight was that stellar evolution does not set a universal lower limit on black-hole mass: sufficiently compressed matter or radiation can form a black hole regardless of whether it has ever belonged to a star.
Bernard Carr and Hawking developed an influential treatment of early-universe collapse in 1974. Their work related black-hole formation to cosmological density perturbations and showed why pressure and expansion must be included in the calculation. A dense region does not collapse merely because it contains more matter than its surroundings. It must become sufficiently compact for self-gravity to overcome pressure gradients before the perturbation disperses. This distinction remains central to modern numerical studies.
Hawking’s prediction of black-hole radiation, announced in 1974 and developed in detail in 1975, gave primordial black holes a second major role. Ordinary stellar black holes are extremely cold, but sufficiently small primordial black holes could radiate energetic particles at observable rates. Searches for cosmic gamma rays and other evaporation products consequently became a way to constrain early-universe fluctuations, even when the black holes themselves had disappeared.
The suggestion that primordial black holes might provide the Galaxy’s missing mass was explored by George Chapline in 1975. Interest later expanded through gravitational microlensing surveys and through the first direct detection of a binary black-hole merger, GW150914, in 2015, announced in 2016. Several studies in 2016 proposed that some merging black holes could be primordial. These proposals did not establish a primordial origin; they showed that merger observations could test a previously difficult mass range.
“Primordial” identifies an origin, not a distinct exterior geometry. In classical general relativity, an isolated black hole is characterized principally by its mass, angular momentum, and electric charge. Two black holes with the same properties need not reveal whether one formed from a star and the other from an early density fluctuation. Their environments, population statistics, or associated radiation may carry the distinguishing evidence.
The term also covers more than one theoretical scenario. Collapse during the usual radiation-dominated era is the standard example, but proposals include formation during an earlier matter-dominated stage or around a cosmological phase transition. Consequently, there is no single primordial-black-hole mass, abundance, or merger rate predicted by the hypothesis as a whole.
Collapse physics and the primordial mass scale
In the simplest formation picture, an overdense region enters the cosmological horizon during radiation domination and collapses if its density contrast is sufficiently large. Before horizon entry, causal forces cannot coordinate the evolution of the entire perturbation. After entry, pressure can oppose contraction. For an ideal relativistic fluid with equation of state , the sound speed is , so pressure support is substantial. Here denotes mass-equivalent density and the speed of light.
A useful mass scale is the mass within a Hubble-radius sphere:
where is the expansion rate. During radiation domination in a spatially flat universe, , giving
Here is Newton’s gravitational constant and is the solar mass. This relation illustrates why earlier formation usually corresponds to smaller black holes. A horizon mass of approximately one solar mass corresponds to a cosmic age of several microseconds. The black hole generally contains only a fraction of the horizon mass, so this is an order-of-magnitude association rather than an exact mass–time conversion.
Collapse calculations require a precisely defined perturbation variable and smoothing scale. For a commonly used volume-averaged density contrast at horizon entry, representative radiation-era thresholds are roughly –. The threshold is not universal: the radial profile, pressure gradients, and definition of the perturbation matter. Modern work often uses the compaction function, which measures excess enclosed mass relative to areal radius and characterizes how strongly a region is gravitationally concentrated.
Near the collapse threshold, simulations exhibit critical collapse. Instead of always forming a fixed fraction of the horizon mass, the black-hole mass approximately follows
where is the threshold, depends on the perturbation family and conventions, and is approximately for a radiation fluid. Perturbations barely above threshold can therefore produce black holes substantially lighter than the horizon mass. Even fluctuations concentrated around one cosmological scale generate a spread of black-hole masses.
Departure from radiation domination changes the calculation. In a pressureless medium, small overdensities can grow more readily, but nonspherical collapse and angular momentum can prevent black-hole formation. A finite matter-dominated interval also imposes a deadline: collapse must occur before the universe returns to radiation domination. Applying radiation-era thresholds or abundance formulas to such a scenario would therefore give misleading results.
Sources of the required early-universe fluctuations
The simplest explanation for primordial density fluctuations is cosmic inflation, a proposed period of accelerated expansion in the very early universe. Quantum fluctuations generated during inflation can become classical curvature perturbations. On scales measured by the cosmic microwave background, the dimensionless curvature power is approximately , far too small to yield an appreciable primordial-black-hole abundance through ordinary Gaussian fluctuations.
Many inflationary production models therefore enhance the power on much smaller scales. In representative models with nearly Gaussian perturbations, a localized curvature power of order can produce an interesting abundance, although the required value depends on the enhancement’s shape and the collapse prescription. Such a large increase is not a small extrapolation of the observed large-scale spectrum. It requires additional inflationary dynamics, such as a feature in the inflaton potential, a temporary ultra-slow-roll stage, or fluctuations generated by another field.
The statistical distribution matters as much as its typical amplitude. Black-hole formation samples the rare, high-density tail of a probability distribution. Two models with the same variance can produce radically different numbers of black holes if their tails differ. Primordial non-Gaussianity may enhance or suppress this tail, and nonlinear conversion between curvature and density perturbations also affects the calculation. A low-order expansion of a non-Gaussian distribution can become unreliable precisely where the collapse probability is determined.
Changes in the cosmic equation of state offer another route to preferred mass scales. During the quantum-chromodynamic crossover, at temperatures of roughly – megaelectronvolts, the relation between pressure and energy density changes as the primordial quark–gluon plasma evolves into hadronic matter. The reduced resistance to compression can lower the collapse threshold. Since the associated horizon masses are around stellar scales, an otherwise broad fluctuation spectrum can acquire an enhanced black-hole population there. The crossover assists collapse; it does not by itself guarantee a sufficient supply of overdensities.
Other proposals do not begin with ordinary density peaks. A strongly first-order phase transition could create expanding bubbles whose collisions or surviving false-vacuum regions collapse. Closed domain walls and loops of cosmic strings may also concentrate sufficient energy to form black holes under suitable conditions. These mechanisms depend on particle physics beyond the established Standard Model or on cosmological histories not yet demonstrated observationally.
Each production mechanism predicts more than an abundance. It can determine the mass spectrum, initial clustering, spin distribution, and accompanying gravitational radiation. Those correlations are important because an isolated mass measurement cannot normally identify a black hole’s origin.
Abundance, mass functions, and dark matter
Two abundance measures are commonly used. The formation fraction, usually written , describes the fraction of the universe’s energy density initially converted into primordial black holes. The present dark-matter fraction is
where each is a present density divided by the cosmological critical density. For black holes that have evaporated completely, remains meaningful but a present surviving-object fraction does not.
A very small formation fraction can become cosmologically important. During radiation domination, nonrelativistic black-hole density decreases approximately as , while radiation density decreases as , where is the cosmic scale factor. Their density ratio therefore grows approximately in proportion to , provided accretion, evaporation, and mergers are negligible. This explains why stringent limits on present abundances translate into extremely small allowed formation fractions.
Primordial black holes can behave as cold dark matter because their motions can become nonrelativistic and their large-scale gravitational effects need not rely on electromagnetic interactions. Their formation from early radiation also means that they are not counted in the same way as ordinary baryonic matter constrained by primordial nucleosynthesis. The black-hole hypothesis nevertheless does not eliminate the need for a detailed cosmological model: a population must satisfy observational bounds at its particular masses and reproduce an acceptable structure-formation history.
A narrow mass distribution is often idealized as monochromatic. More realistic populations are described by an extended mass function, for example
The convention must be specified because distributions per unit mass and per logarithmic mass interval differ by a factor of . Critical collapse, a broad primordial spectrum, and subsequent mergers can all broaden an initially concentrated distribution.
Constraints derived for monochromatic populations cannot generally be applied to an extended distribution merely by checking its peak. A low-mass tail may violate evaporation limits even if the peak lies elsewhere; a high-mass tail may violate lensing, accretion, or dynamical limits. For observables linear in abundance, an approximate integrated treatment is often possible. Binary formation and clustering-dependent effects may require a full population calculation.
An often-discussed region in which primordial black holes might still account for all dark matter lies at asteroid-like masses, broadly around – grams. This is an approximate research window, not a universal allowed interval: its boundaries depend on evaporation calculations, source sizes in lensing searches, and other astrophysical assumptions. Across many other mass ranges, observations restrict primordial black holes to a subdominant fraction, while still allowing populations with potentially observable effects.
Hawking evaporation and particle emission
Hawking radiation follows from quantum field theory in a black-hole spacetime. For a nonrotating, electrically neutral black hole, the temperature is
where is the reduced Planck constant and the Boltzmann constant. Numerically,
A black hole of grams has a characteristic thermal energy of about megaelectronvolts. Smaller holes are hotter, reversing the familiar association between large astronomical objects and high total radiative output.
The emitted spectrum is approximately thermal but is modified by frequency- and spin-dependent transmission probabilities called greybody factors. A black hole can radiate species whose rest energies are accessible at its temperature. As its mass decreases, additional particle channels become important. When quarks and gluons are emitted, they fragment and decay, producing secondary photons, electrons, neutrinos, and other particles. Observable spectra therefore require particle-production calculations rather than a simple blackbody approximation.
For a fixed set of emitted species, the mass-loss rate scales approximately as
and the lifetime scales as . The coefficient changes as new particle species become accessible. Under conventional assumptions, a nonrotating black hole with initial mass of roughly grams has a lifetime comparable to the present age of the universe, about billion years. Smaller primordial black holes would already have evaporated; somewhat larger ones could still be emitting energetic radiation.
Evaporation produces several distinct observational tests. Surviving populations contribute to diffuse gamma-ray backgrounds and possibly to charged-particle fluxes. Earlier evaporation can change light-element abundances, inject energy into the cosmic plasma, or modify the ionization history. These effects constrain different initial masses because the lifetime determines the epoch at which energy is released. Searches also look for brief high-energy transients from black holes approaching the end of evaporation, although no such event has been established.
The semiclassical treatment is reliable only while the black hole remains much larger than the quantum-gravity scale. Its final stage is unresolved. Complete disappearance, a remnant, and other outcomes have been proposed, but none is established by a tested theory of quantum gravity. Remnant dark-matter scenarios therefore add an assumption beyond standard evaporation.
Hawking radiation has not been directly detected from an astrophysical black hole. Radiation searches constrain primordial populations conditional on the semiclassical prediction, while proposed analogue experiments investigate related mathematical phenomena rather than directly observing the evaporation of a gravitational black hole.
Gravitational lensing and dynamical searches
Gravitational lensing tests primordial black holes through gravity rather than through accretion or evaporation. A compact object passing near the line of sight to a background star can temporarily magnify it. When the separate images cannot be resolved, the effect is called gravitational microlensing. Its duration depends on the lens mass, relative transverse speed, and source–lens geometry.
For a point lens, the angular Einstein radius is
where , , and are observer–lens, observer–source, and lens–source angular-diameter distances. The characteristic duration scales approximately as when the geometry and transverse speed are fixed. Low-mass lenses require rapid observations, while very massive lenses produce events that may last longer than a survey’s observing baseline.
The MACHO, EROS, and OGLE projects monitored large stellar samples, notably toward the Magellanic Clouds and the Galactic bulge. Their event statistics constrain compact dark objects over substantial mass intervals. The Subaru Hyper Suprime-Cam search toward the Andromeda galaxy extended sensitivity toward shorter events and smaller masses through high-cadence imaging. These results are not direct demonstrations that every possible compact object is absent: converting a detected event count into an abundance requires a model of the foreground populations, dark halo, velocities, and survey efficiency.
At sufficiently low lens masses, two effects weaken the usual point-source, geometric-optics calculation. A star’s finite angular size can smooth the magnification, and wave effects become important when the radiation wavelength is not small relative to the lens’s gravitational scale. These considerations are particularly important when assessing claims that very low-mass compact objects have been excluded by optical or high-energy lensing. Source dimensions and the appropriate wave-optics treatment must be included.
Other lensing methods use different sources. Compact lenses can create delayed or interfering copies of a transient signal, affect strongly lensed quasars, or perturb the magnification of stars near a galaxy-cluster critical curve. Each method probes a different combination of mass, source structure, and abundance. Astrometric lensing, which measures a source’s apparent positional shift, can also constrain dark lenses even when the brightness variation is limited.
Dynamical tests instead ask whether massive compact objects would gravitationally disturb fragile systems. Encounters may heat a star cluster, widen or disrupt stellar binaries, or alter the internal structure of dwarf galaxies. Such arguments are particularly relevant to relatively massive primordial black holes. Their strength depends on the age and initial state of the system, its dark-matter density, and the treatment of repeated encounters. They complement lensing but generally involve greater uncertainty about long-term astrophysical evolution.
Accretion, cosmic structure, and black-hole seeds
Primordial black holes moving through gas can accrete matter and release radiation. A basic spherical estimate has the scaling
where is gas density, the sound speed, and the black hole’s velocity relative to the gas. This Bondi–Hoyle-type scaling shows why gas temperature and relative motion matter strongly. It is not a complete model: angular momentum, cooling, magnetic fields, radiation pressure, and time-dependent gas supply can change the flow.
Accretion before and after cosmological recombination can inject ionizing radiation into the surrounding medium. Altered ionization changes how microwave-background photons scatter, modifying their temperature and polarization patterns. Precision observations, including those from Planck, consequently constrain accreting primordial-black-hole populations. The numerical limits depend on the assumed accretion geometry, radiative efficiency, black-hole velocities, and feedback. A population of isolated, weakly accreting objects does not necessarily have the same signature as a strongly clustered population embedded in dense gas.
Energy injection can also affect the thermal and ionization history tested by the hydrogen 21-centimetre line. This signal depends on the spin-state populations of neutral hydrogen, the gas temperature, and the radiation environment. Primordial black-hole heating may alter its absorption or emission. However, ordinary astrophysical sources—including early stars and accreting stellar remnants—also influence the signal, so interpreting it requires a model of early galaxy formation.
Even without luminous accretion, discrete black holes modify the matter distribution. Random variations in their number introduce a component of density fluctuations often described as Poisson fluctuations. These can enhance structure on small scales and alter the formation of early halos. Initial clustering or correlations generated by the formation mechanism may change this simple picture. The resulting effects are tested through observations of small-scale cosmic structure, including absorption by intergalactic gas.
A separate proposal is that rare, relatively massive primordial black holes seeded the supermassive black holes found in galactic centres. Very distant quasars demonstrate that black holes with masses approaching or exceeding a billion solar masses existed within the universe’s first billion years. Starting with a more massive seed can reduce the growth required compared with a typical stellar remnant. Primordial seeds are not the only possibility: massive stellar remnants, dense star clusters, and direct gas collapse provide alternative channels.
A viable seed population must satisfy abundance limits while matching the number and environments of observed massive black holes. It must also have a plausible growth history, because radiative feedback can restrict accretion. Neither an unusually early quasar nor a large black-hole mass alone identifies a primordial origin; the explanatory burden includes the population’s formation, survival, and subsequent assembly.
Gravitational waves and tests of primordial origin
Binary primordial black holes could emit detectable gravitational waves when they merge. One proposed channel begins in the early universe, when nearby black holes decouple from the expansion. Gravitational torques from other black holes and surrounding density perturbations give the pair angular momentum, preventing immediate head-on collapse and setting its orbital eccentricity. Gravitational radiation then gradually shrinks the orbit.
Another channel operates later inside dark-matter halos. Two initially unbound black holes can lose enough energy during a close encounter to become bound, or interactions in a dense environment can create and harden binaries. These mechanisms have different dependencies on abundance, clustering, velocities, and halo structure. Consequently, a merger-rate prediction cannot be converted into a unique primordial-black-hole fraction without specifying a formation and evolution model.
The LIGO and Virgo detections established populations of merging black holes in the stellar-mass range, stimulating detailed comparisons between primordial and stellar-origin scenarios. Masses of several tens of solar masses are not themselves decisive: stars with suitable metallicities and evolutionary histories can produce black holes in that range. Similarly, low measured spin is compatible with some primordial models but can also arise from stellar channels. Formation from rare, nearly spherical radiation-era peaks often predicts small initial spins, whereas other primordial mechanisms need not.
A securely identified black-hole merger involving a component substantially below one solar mass would be especially informative because established stellar-evolution channels do not ordinarily produce black holes at such masses. Identification would still require distinguishing a black hole from a material compact object through waveform information and population evidence. Nonstandard alternatives would also have to be considered, so “subsolar” would be strong evidence for an unusual origin rather than an automatic proof of primordial formation.
Merger redshifts offer a complementary test. Black holes cannot originate from stars before the first stars exist, whereas primordial black holes could merge much earlier. Future detectors capable of observing distant mergers may therefore probe an epoch with little or no stellar contamination. Inference must account for uncertainties in source distance, gravitational lensing, and the model used to convert the measured waveform into source-frame masses.
Primordial production can also generate gravitational waves without any black-hole merger. Large scalar perturbations can induce tensor perturbations at second order when they re-enter the horizon, producing a stochastic background. Pulsar timing arrays probe nanohertz frequencies relevant to some models that enhance fluctuations on stellar-mass primordial-black-hole scales. The signal is model-dependent, and a nanohertz background also has astrophysical explanations involving supermassive black-hole binaries.
Distinguishing these possibilities requires the background’s spectral shape, spatial correlations, and consistency with other observations. A proposed primordial model must simultaneously reproduce its black-hole abundance, obey lensing and radiation constraints, and predict compatible merger and induced-wave signals. These linked tests provide a more discriminating route than any single unusual merger or isolated spectral feature.