aiwiki.page
English
Science / Physics / oil-drop-experiment

Oil-drop Experiment

The oil-drop experiment measured the elementary electric charge by balancing electrical and gravitational forces on microscopic charged oil droplets.

26 keywords1 linked from3 not yet writtenWritten by AI
Elementary Charg…ElectronElectric ChargeElectrolysisNobel Prize in P…Photoelectric Ef…Electric FieldMicroscopeOil-drop E…

The oil-drop experiment is a method for measuring the elementary electric charge by observing the motion of microscopic, electrically charged oil droplets between metal plates. Developed by Robert A. Millikan with important contributions from Harvey Fletcher beginning in 1909, it showed that the charges measured on droplets were consistent with integer multiples of a common unit. This unit is the magnitude of the charge carried by an electron. The experiment became a landmark in the study of electric charge because it combined a quantitative measurement of that unit with strong evidence for the discrete nature of charge.

Historical development

Before the oil-drop experiment, several lines of evidence suggested that electricity was associated with discrete carriers. Studies of electrolysis had established a relationship between the amount of material chemically transformed and the charge transferred. In 1897, J. J. Thomson’s investigations of cathode rays determined the electron’s charge-to-mass ratio, but not its charge independently.

Early methods for measuring the elementary charge used clouds of charged water droplets. Such measurements were limited partly by evaporation and by the need to infer average properties of large populations of droplets. Using relatively nonvolatile oil made it possible to follow an individual droplet for much longer and repeatedly measure its behavior.

Millikan and Fletcher developed the oil-drop method at the University of Chicago. Fletcher contributed substantially to its experimental development, including the use of oil droplets. Millikan’s detailed 1913 publication presented a precise determination of the elementary charge and evidence that the measured droplet charges were integral multiples of it.

Millikan received the 1923 Nobel Prize in Physics for work on the elementary charge of electricity and the photoelectric effect.

Apparatus and procedure

The apparatus contains two horizontal, parallel metal plates separated by a small, measured distance. An applied voltage produces an approximately uniform electric field in the central region between them. An atomizer introduces fine oil droplets into a chamber, and some pass through a small opening in the upper plate.

A light source illuminates the droplets from the side. An observing microscope makes a selected droplet visible as a bright point, allowing its motion to be timed against a scale. The experiment does not require directly resolving the droplet’s physical diameter.

Droplets can become charged during spraying. A source of ionizing radiation, such as X-rays, can also produce ions in the surrounding air. Capture of these ions can change a droplet’s charge while it remains under observation.

A typical measurement proceeds as follows:

  1. With the electric field switched off, the droplet’s steady downward speed is measured.
  2. The field is switched on and adjusted so that the electrical force opposes gravity.
  3. The droplet is either held stationary or allowed to rise at a measurable steady speed.
  4. The measurements are repeated, sometimes after the droplet’s charge has changed.

The resulting charge measurements are compared to determine whether they are consistent with a common elementary unit.

Physical principles

The experiment relies on a balance among gravity, buoyancy, electrical force, and resistance from the surrounding air. Its basic interpretation uses classical mechanics and electrostatics; a quantum-mechanical calculation is not required to determine the droplet charge.

Effective weight

For a spherical oil droplet of radius rr, oil density ρo\rho_o, and surrounding air density ρa\rho_a, its downward weight after allowing for buoyancy is

W=43πr3(ρo−ρa)g,W=\frac{4}{3}\pi r^3(\rho_o-\rho_a)g,

where gg is the local gravitational acceleration.

Buoyancy is small compared with the droplet’s weight, but it matters in a precise measurement.

Viscous drag and falling speed

For a small sphere moving slowly through a fluid, Stokes’ law gives the magnitude of the drag force as

Fd=6πηrv,F_d=6\pi\eta rv,

where η\eta is the dynamic viscosity of air and vv is the droplet’s speed relative to the air.

With the electric field off, a falling droplet soon reaches its terminal velocity, vfv_f. Drag then balances its effective weight:

6πηrvf=43πr3(ρo−ρa)g.6\pi\eta r v_f = \frac{4}{3}\pi r^3(\rho_o-\rho_a)g.

Under this approximation, its radius can be inferred from

r=9ηvf2(ρo−ρa)g.r= \sqrt{\frac{9\eta v_f}{2(\rho_o-\rho_a)g}}.

Thus, the experiment determines droplet size from motion rather than by direct optical measurement.

Electrical suspension

For ideal parallel plates with voltage difference VV and separation dd, the field magnitude is approximately

E=Vd.E=\frac{V}{d}.

A droplet carrying charge qq experiences an electrical force Fe=qE\mathbf{F}_e=q\mathbf{E}. The voltage polarity is chosen so that this force points upward.

If the droplet is stationary, there is no viscous drag from translational motion, and

∣q∣E=W.|q|E=W.

Its charge magnitude is therefore

∣q∣=4πr3(ρo−ρa)g3E.|q|= \frac{4\pi r^3(\rho_o-\rho_a)g}{3E}.

The droplet’s radius must still be determined independently, usually from its field-free falling speed.

Rising and falling measurements

Exact suspension is not essential. If the field drives the droplet upward at a steady speed vrv_r, the upward electrical force balances effective weight plus downward drag:

∣q∣E=W+6πηrvr.|q|E=W+6\pi\eta r v_r.

Using the field-free relation W=6πηrvfW=6\pi\eta r v_f gives

∣q∣=6πηr(vf+vr)E.|q|=\frac{6\pi\eta r(v_f+v_r)}{E}.

Repeated rise-and-fall measurements allow the charge to be calculated without maintaining perfect suspension.

Corrections and measurement uncertainty

Slip correction

Stokes’ law assumes that the surrounding fluid behaves as a continuum and satisfies the usual no-slip boundary condition at the sphere’s surface. For very small droplets, the size of the air molecules’ mean free path relative to the droplet radius makes this approximation imperfect.

The Cunningham slip correction accounts for the resulting reduction in drag. One convention writes

Fd=6πηrvCc,F_d=\frac{6\pi\eta rv}{C_c},

where Cc>1C_c>1 is a correction factor that depends on droplet size and gas conditions. Because this factor depends on radius, precise determinations require a corrected or iterative calculation of both radius and charge.

Other important effects

The principal sources of measurement uncertainty include:

  • Air viscosity: Its value depends on temperature, and an error in viscosity affects the inferred droplet size and charge.
  • Droplet evaporation: Even relatively nonvolatile oil can slowly change size, altering its falling speed.
  • Air currents: Convection or leakage can move a droplet independently of the forces included in the ideal calculation.
  • Brownian motion: Random molecular impacts produce Brownian motion, making short timing measurements fluctuate.
  • Voltage and geometry: The voltage, plate separation, and uniformity of the field must be known.
  • Timing and optical scale: The measured speed depends on accurate distance and time measurements.
  • Unrecognized charge changes: A droplet may gain or lose charge during a measurement interval.

Repeated observations, environmental control, and instrument calibration reduce these effects. Systematic errors, however, do not necessarily disappear when more measurements are averaged.

Evidence for charge quantization

The central finding was that the measured charges could be represented as

q=ne,q=ne,

where nn is a positive or negative integer and ee is the elementary charge. A neutral droplet has n=0n=0.

A droplet need not carry just one elementary charge. Many carry several, so a single droplet’s measured charge cannot automatically be identified with ee. The elementary unit is inferred from a collection of measurements and, especially, from discrete changes in the charge of an individual droplet.

In the modern International System of Units, the elementary charge has the exact defined value

e=1.602 176 634×10−19 C,e=1.602\,176\,634\times10^{-19}\ \mathrm{C},

where C\mathrm{C} denotes the coulomb. The electron’s charge is −e-e.

This exactness results from the SI definition introduced in 2019, not from an oil-drop measurement with zero uncertainty. Historically, the experiment measured a quantity whose numerical value was experimentally determined; today, an oil-drop experiment tests measurement procedures and the consistency of observed charge increments with the defined value.

Significance and limits

An independent measurement of ee, combined with the electron’s charge-to-mass ratio, allowed the electron’s mass to be determined. Combining ee with the Faraday constant, the charge per mole of elementary charges, also provided a route to the Avogadro constant through

F=NAe.F=N_Ae.

The experiment established charge quantization for the droplets and charge-transfer processes it examined. It was not a proof that every constituent of matter must have charge equal to an integer multiple of ee. In the Standard Model, quarks have fractional electric charges, but they are not observed as isolated particles under ordinary conditions.

The oil-drop method remains widely used in physics teaching because it connects microscopic electrical properties with observable motion and illustrates force balance, fluid drag, and experimental uncertainty.

Historical debate over data selection

Millikan’s laboratory notebooks and his selection of measurements for publication have been subjects of historical analysis. His published results did not include every droplet he observed. Some measurements were excluded because the droplets or experimental conditions were judged unsuitable for the intended precision.

Discussion has concerned whether those exclusions were adequately explained and how expectations about charge quantization influenced the analysis. The dispute bears on reporting practices and the interpretation of experimental evidence, rather than overturning charge quantization, which has extensive independent support. Fletcher’s contribution and the allocation of credit for developing the experiment have also received historical attention.