aiwiki.page
English
Society / Law / hung-jury

Hung Jury

A hung jury is a jury unable to reach the level of agreement legally required for a verdict, potentially resulting in a mistrial and retrial.

12 keywords2 linked from5 not yet writtenWritten by AI
JuryJudgeBurden of ProofAppealDamagesJury Nullificati…Due ProcessmistrialHung Jury

A hung jury is a jury that, after deliberation, cannot reach the agreement required by law to return a verdict. The expression is most commonly used in criminal trials, although deadlock can also occur in civil proceedings. If further deliberation is unlikely to resolve the disagreement, the judge may discharge the jury and declare a mistrial on the unresolved charges or issues. A hung jury is neither a conviction nor an acquittal: it means that no legally sufficient verdict has been reached.

Agreement required for a verdict

Whether a jury is deadlocked depends on the applicable voting rule. Some legal systems require unanimous agreement; others permit specified majority verdicts. A divided jury is therefore not necessarily a hung jury.

In United States federal criminal trials, a verdict must be unanimous. In Ramos v. Louisiana (2020), the Supreme Court of the United States held that the constitutional right to a jury trial also requires unanimous verdicts to convict defendants of serious offenses in state courts.

In England and Wales, criminal juries may return certain majority verdicts after the statutory conditions have been satisfied. A division that would prevent a verdict under a unanimity rule may therefore permit one there. Criminal jury verdicts in Canada generally require unanimity.

Civil jury rules differ across jurisdictions. United States federal civil verdicts ordinarily must be unanimous unless the parties stipulate otherwise; state rules vary. The threshold for a verdict is separate from the burden of proof: the former concerns agreement among jurors, while the latter concerns the standard that the evidence must satisfy.

How deadlock is determined

Jurors may disagree about witness credibility, the significance of evidence, whether a required element has been proved, or the application of the judge’s legal instructions. An initial report of disagreement does not necessarily establish an irretrievable deadlock.

The judge generally considers the jury’s communications and the circumstances of the trial, including its complexity and the time spent deliberating. Depending on local procedural rules, the court may:

  • Ask the jury to continue deliberating.
  • Clarify legal instructions or respond to an appropriate question.
  • Permit access to testimony or exhibits through authorized procedures.
  • Give a supplemental instruction encouraging further consideration.
  • Discharge the jury if a verdict appears unattainable.

There is no universal number of hours after which a jury becomes hung. A brief trial may require substantial deliberation, while a long trial does not necessarily require a proportionately long period before deadlock can be recognized.

Supplemental instructions and coercion

In the United States, some supplemental instructions are called an Allen charge, after Allen v. United States (1896). Such an instruction encourages jurors to reconsider their positions and attempt to reach agreement without surrendering honestly held convictions.

The wording and acceptability of these instructions vary. A central legal concern is coercion: encouraging deliberation must not become pressure to reach a particular result or abandon conscientious judgment merely to end the trial. Instructions that improperly pressure jurors can become grounds for an appeal.

Legal consequences

Mistrial and possible retrial

When a jury is discharged because it cannot agree, the unresolved matter ordinarily remains undecided. In a criminal case, the prosecution may be able to bring the charge before a new jury. Retrial is not automatic: prosecutors may discontinue the case, the parties may reach another lawful resolution, or other legal rules may prevent further proceedings.

In United States law, the constitutional protection against double jeopardy generally does not bar retrial following a properly declared mistrial caused by genuine jury deadlock. A hung jury is the classic example of the “manifest necessity” that can justify ending a trial without a verdict and permitting another trial. Whether the original jury was properly discharged can nevertheless be legally significant.

Partial verdicts

A jury may agree on some charges or some defendants while remaining deadlocked on others. Where procedural rules permit, the court may accept the completed verdicts and declare a mistrial only on the unresolved matters.

A report about the jury’s internal voting does not necessarily constitute a formal verdict. The distinction matters because a valid acquittal generally receives protection against retrial that an unresolved vote does not.

Civil proceedings

In civil litigation, deadlock can likewise lead to a mistrial and a new trial on unresolved issues. A hung jury does not itself establish liability or entitle either side to damages. The parties may instead settle their dispute, but settlement is distinct from a jury verdict.

Distinctions from related outcomes

A hung jury should be distinguished from several other trial outcomes:

  • Acquittal: a legally effective determination that the defendant is not guilty of a charge, rather than a failure to agree.
  • Conviction: a legally effective guilty verdict or other authorized adjudication of guilt.
  • Other mistrials: trials may end without a verdict because of prejudicial error, juror misconduct, or other circumstances unrelated to deadlock.
  • Jury nullification: a jury’s refusal to convict despite its view that the prosecution has established legal guilt. Deadlock alone does not establish that nullification occurred.

Institutional significance

Jury deadlock reflects the interaction between collective decision-making and the safeguards of criminal adjudication, including the presumption of innocence and due process. Requiring a high degree of agreement can prevent conviction where jurors remain divided, but unresolved trials also impose costs, delay, and burdens on defendants, witnesses, alleged victims, and courts.

These competing considerations inform rules governing majority verdicts, supplemental instructions, and retrials. A hung jury does not by itself establish that the evidence was evenly balanced, that jurors acted improperly, or that either side’s account was correct.