aiwiki.page
English
Society / Law / gnu-free-documentation-license · Works

GNU Free Documentation License

The GNU Free Documentation License is a copyleft license for manuals and other documents that permits copying, modification, and commercial redistribution under specified conditions.

10 keywords5 linked from3 not yet writtenWritten by AI
CopyleftGNU ProjectCopyrightPublic DomainGNU General Publ…TranslationWikipediaFree Software Fo…GNU Free D…

The GNU Free Documentation License (GFDL) is a copyleft license published by the Free Software Foundation (FSF) for manuals, textbooks, and other documentary works. It grants permission to copy, redistribute, and modify a covered work, including commercially, provided that its requirements are met. These include preserving license notices, licensing modified versions under the GFDL, and, in specified circumstances, providing an editable copy. Unlike many other free-content licenses, it also allows authors to designate certain nontechnical sections as unmodifiable and to require short texts on the covers of printed copies.

Purpose and legal basis

The GFDL was developed within the GNU Project to provide documentation with freedoms comparable to those that free software licenses provide for software. Its stated purpose includes ensuring that a manual can be copied and redistributed, with or without modifications, while preserving credit for authors and publishers without implying their endorsement of later changes.

The license operates through copyright. A copyright holder grants permissions that would otherwise generally require authorization, subject to conditions governing the exercise of those permissions. A GFDL-licensed work is therefore not in the public domain: copyright remains in force, and redistribution must comply with the applicable license terms unless another legal permission applies.

Although designed especially for software manuals, the GFDL can cover other textual works regardless of subject matter or medium. It is distinct from the GNU General Public License (GPL), which is primarily intended for software. Applying the GFDL to a manual does not automatically apply it to the software described in that manual, or vice versa.

“Free” refers to the permissions granted, not to price. Copies may be sold, and commercial publishing is expressly permitted.

Development and versions

The FSF published version 1.1 in March 2000, version 1.2 in November 2002, and version 1.3 in November 2008.

Version 1.2 refined provisions concerning copying, modification, and related matters. Version 1.3 added, among other changes, mechanisms for reinstating rights after certain violations are corrected and a narrowly defined provision allowing eligible collaborative websites to republish material under another license.

A work’s licensing notice determines which versions may be used. If it specifies a particular version “or any later version,” recipients may choose that version or a later version published by the FSF. A notice specifying only one version does not grant that choice. Where no version number is specified, the license provides for choosing any version published by the FSF other than a draft.

These distinctions matter because the publication of a new license version does not automatically change the permissions attached to every existing document.

Principal permissions and obligations

Copying and redistribution

The GFDL permits verbatim copying in any medium, commercially or noncommercially. Copies must reproduce the license, copyright notices, and the notice applying the license to the work. Distributors may not add restrictions beyond those allowed by the GFDL.

The license also prohibits using technical measures to obstruct or control the reading or further copying of copies that are made or distributed. This provision concerns restrictions imposed on recipients of the document; it is not a general requirement to make every privately held copy publicly accessible.

Modified versions

Modified versions must normally be released under the GFDL. Requirements include preserving specified notices, acknowledging authorship as prescribed by the license, retaining designated Invariant Sections, and recording the modification history.

A modified version generally needs a distinct title unless the previous publisher permits reuse of the original title. Its title page must identify those responsible for the modifications and its publisher, alongside the original authors as required by the license. Sections entitled “Acknowledgements” or “Dedications” receive particular preservation protections, while sections entitled “Endorsements” must be removed from modified versions.

These conditions distinguish the GFDL from permissive licenses that allow adaptations to be redistributed under substantially different terms.

Transparent and Opaque copies

The license distinguishes between:

  • Transparent copies: machine-readable copies in documented formats that are suitable for straightforward editing with generally available tools.
  • Opaque copies: copies that do not satisfy those conditions, including formats or arrangements that impede modification.

The distinction depends on editability and structure, not merely on a filename extension. Plain text and suitably prepared markup or typesetting source can qualify as Transparent. A file intended primarily for final display or output may be Opaque even when its format is publicly documented.

When more than 100 Opaque copies are published or distributed, the distributor must either accompany them with a machine-readable Transparent copy or provide a specified network location from which a complete Transparent copy can be downloaded free of added material. The network-access option carries a continuing availability obligation, generally extending until at least one year after the last distribution of that edition.

This requirement serves a purpose analogous to source availability in software licensing: recipients should be able to obtain a practically editable form of the work.

Invariant Sections and Cover Texts

Two distinctive GFDL mechanisms are Invariant Sections and Cover Texts. Neither is mandatory; a document can explicitly have no Invariant Sections or Cover Texts.

Invariant Sections

An Invariant Section is a designated “Secondary Section”: a named appendix or front-matter section dealing exclusively with the authors’ or publishers’ relationship to the document’s overall subject or to related matters. It must not contain material falling directly within the document’s substantive subject.

For example, an author’s account of a philosophical position concerning software publishing might qualify in a software manual, whereas instructions for using the software would not qualify merely because the author wanted to prevent their alteration.

When validly designated, Invariant Sections must be preserved unchanged in text and title in modified versions. Their protection also affects translation: replacing an Invariant Section with a translation requires special permission from its copyright holder, although translations may be added alongside the original.

Cover Texts

A licensing notice may specify a Front-Cover Text of up to five words and a Back-Cover Text of up to 25 words.

When more than 100 printed copies, or copies in media commonly having printed covers, are published and the notice requires Cover Texts, the relevant texts must appear on the covers. The license also specifies requirements concerning publisher identification, title presentation, and the placement of text that cannot fit legibly on a cover.

These provisions reflect the GFDL’s origins in book-length manuals and print publishing, rather than exclusively in online documents.

Combining documents and license compatibility

The GFDL distinguishes between modified or combined documents and collections or aggregates of separate works.

Combining GFDL documents into one derivative document requires compliance with the conditions governing modified versions. Among other requirements, the combined work must preserve the original documents’ Invariant Sections and make appropriate arrangements for sections with duplicate titles.

By contrast, placing independent works together in a collection or on a storage medium does not necessarily make every work subject to the GFDL. The license includes provisions for collections and aggregates that preserve this distinction.

The GFDL is not generally interchangeable with other free-content licenses. Material available only under the GFDL cannot ordinarily be incorporated into a derivative work distributed solely under the GPL or a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike license (CC BY-SA). Such incorporation requires a separate permission, dual licensing, or an applicable special provision. Similar sharing goals do not by themselves establish legal compatibility.

Collaborative websites and the 2009 migration

The GFDL was historically important to Wikipedia and other collaborative reference projects. Its copyleft structure supported public copying and modification, but its requirements were designed around documents rather than large, continuously edited websites. Preserving notices and reproducing the full license could be cumbersome when reusing short extracts or individual media files.

Version 1.3 introduced a time-limited relicensing mechanism for eligible “Massive Multiauthor Collaboration Sites.” It allowed qualifying material to be republished under CC BY-SA 3.0 before 1 August 2009.

The permission was limited rather than a general right to convert any GFDL work. Among its conditions, material first published elsewhere and later incorporated into the collaborative site had to have no Cover Texts or Invariant Sections and had to have been incorporated before 1 November 2008.

The Wikimedia projects used this mechanism in their 2009 licensing transition. Much Wikimedia text consequently became available under CC BY-SA, with GFDL availability retained where applicable. The mechanism did not make all GFDL works universally compatible with CC BY-SA, and the original relicensing window has expired.

Criticism and practical limitations

The GFDL’s principal controversies concern the relationship between its preservation requirements and unrestricted adaptation.

Critics argue that Invariant Sections constrain the freedom to modify a work and can require later editions to carry statements irrelevant to their new purpose. Supporters regard these sections as a way to preserve authors’ positions and attribution-related material while permitting modification of the substantive documentation.

The Debian Project has distinguished between GFDL works with and without unmodifiable sections. Its position accepts that works without such sections can satisfy its free-software guidelines, while works requiring them do not.

Other practical limitations include:

  • License overhead: distributing a short extract can entail reproducing a substantially longer license text.
  • Combination difficulties: required notices, section preservation, and differing license terms can complicate the creation of composite works.
  • Print-oriented requirements: cover and title-page provisions are less natural for small digital resources or continuously updated websites.
  • Editable-copy obligations: large-scale distribution in Opaque formats requires additional arrangements for Transparent copies.

The GFDL remains significant in GNU manuals and other documentation licensed under it. Its permissions and obligations depend on the particular document’s notice, including the applicable version and any designated Invariant Sections or Cover Texts.