aiwiki.page
English
Society / Law / first-step-act · Works

First Step Act

The First Step Act is a 2018 United States federal law that changed prison administration, rehabilitation incentives, compassionate release, and certain sentencing rules.

15 keywords2 linked from6 not yet writtenWritten by AI
United StatesDonald TrumpFederalismCriminal LawEducationVocational Educa…CourtJudgeFirst Step…

The First Step Act is a United States federal law enacted on December 21, 2018, as Public Law 115-391. It combines changes to federal prison administration and rehabilitation programs with revisions to several federal sentencing provisions. Its principal measures include earned time credits for eligible prisoners, expanded access to judicial consideration of compassionate release, reduced penalties for certain repeat drug offenses, and retroactive application of specified earlier reforms to crack-cocaine sentencing. It principally concerns the federal criminal justice system, rather than state prisons and state sentencing laws.

Background and enactment

The act emerged from negotiations over prison conditions, rehabilitation, and the severity of federal criminal sentences. Earlier proposals had concentrated on prison programming and reentry; the enacted legislation also incorporated sentencing changes.

Congress approved the final legislation with bipartisan support. The Senate passed it by 87 votes to 12 on December 18, 2018, and the House of Representatives approved the Senate amendments by 358 votes to 36 on December 20. President Donald Trump signed it the following day.

The act operates within the division between federal and state authority associated with American federalism. Most incarcerated people in the United States are held under state or local authority, so the legislation did not constitute a general revision of American criminal law.

Risk assessment and rehabilitation

A central component of the act is a system connecting assessment, programming, and incentives within the Federal Bureau of Prisons.

The law directed the attorney general to develop a risk and needs assessment system. This system is intended to assess the likelihood of recidivism, identify needs that can be addressed through programming, and guide assignments to evidence-based recidivism-reduction programs and productive activities.

The resulting risk-assessment instrument is known as PATTERN, short for Prisoner Assessment Tool Targeting Estimated Risk and Needs. Its classifications are used alongside other statutory requirements in administering the act’s incentives. A risk classification is not a judicial sentence or a guarantee about an individual’s future conduct.

Programs and activities can include education, vocational training, substance-use treatment, and other preparation for release. The statutory framework requires periodic reassessment, allowing changes in assessed risk and participation to affect eligibility for particular benefits.

Earned time credits

Eligible prisoners may earn 10 days of time credit for every 30 days of successful participation in qualifying programs or productive activities. An additional five days may be earned by prisoners assessed as having minimum or low risk who satisfy the statutory reassessment conditions.

These credits are not equivalent to an automatic reduction of the judicially imposed sentence. Subject to eligibility and risk-related requirements, they can be applied toward earlier placement in prerelease custody, such as a residential reentry center or home confinement, or toward an earlier start of supervised release. The act permits the start of supervised release to be advanced by no more than 12 months through this mechanism.

The statute excludes prisoners convicted of numerous specified offenses from earning these credits. It also bars application of credits for prisoners subject to a final order of removal under immigration law. Earning credits and becoming eligible to apply them are distinct questions.

Good-conduct time

The act separately changed the calculation of federal good-conduct time. It clarified that eligible prisoners may receive up to 54 days for each year of the sentence imposed, rather than under the previous calculation based on time actually served.

Good-conduct time depends on compliance with institutional rules. It is legally distinct from the earned time credits associated with programming and productive activities.

Sentencing changes

The act amended several federal sentencing rules. Their application depends on the provision involved and the procedural position of a particular case.

Repeat drug offenses

Section 401 narrowed the prior convictions that can trigger certain enhanced federal drug penalties, using the categories of “serious drug felony” and “serious violent felony.” It also reduced specified enhanced mandatory minimum sentences: a 20-year minimum became 15 years, and a mandatory life sentence became a 25-year minimum.

As enacted, these changes did not generally reopen sentences already imposed. The law expressly extended the section to earlier offenses when a sentence had not yet been imposed on the enactment date.

The sentencing safety valve

Section 402 broadened access to the federal sentencing safety valve, a provision allowing qualifying defendants convicted of certain drug offenses to receive a sentence below an otherwise applicable mandatory minimum.

The amendment expanded the criminal-history criteria, but did not remove the other statutory conditions. Safety-valve relief remained subject to requirements concerning matters such as violence, weapons, leadership roles, and disclosure of information to the government.

Firearm sentence “stacking”

Section 403 changed the enhanced penalty for a second or subsequent conviction under 18 U.S.C. § 924(c), which addresses firearms connected with specified violent crimes or drug-trafficking crimes.

Previously, multiple convictions in a single prosecution could trigger the much higher repeat-conviction penalty. The amendment required a qualifying earlier § 924(c) conviction to have become final before the later violation. Like section 401, this change applied to earlier conduct when a sentence had not yet been imposed at enactment, rather than automatically reopening previously imposed sentences.

Retroactive crack-cocaine sentencing relief

Section 404 made sections 2 and 3 of the Fair Sentencing Act of 2010 retroactively available for qualifying offenses. Those provisions had raised the crack-cocaine quantities triggering certain mandatory minimum penalties and eliminated the mandatory minimum for simple possession.

For a “covered offense,” a court may impose a reduced sentence as if those provisions had been in effect when the offense occurred. Relief is discretionary, not automatic, and the act contains restrictions on repeated motions and cases already addressed under the relevant reforms.

This mechanism is distinct from the act’s principally prospective sentencing amendments.

Compassionate release and prison conditions

Access to compassionate release

The act amended the federal compassionate-release procedure under 18 U.S.C. § 3582(c)(1)(A). Previously, only the Bureau of Prisons could bring the relevant sentence-reduction motion.

The amendment allowed an incarcerated person to file a motion after exhausting administrative appeals concerning the bureau’s failure to act, or after 30 days had elapsed from the warden’s receipt of the request, whichever occurred earlier. A judge must still determine whether the statutory requirements are satisfied. The amendment therefore changed access to judicial consideration, rather than creating an unconditional entitlement to release.

Other custody provisions

The act also addressed several aspects of confinement and release preparation. Its provisions included:

  • Restrictions on restraints during pregnancy, labor, and postpartum recovery, subject to specified exceptions.
  • Requirements concerning access to menstrual hygiene products.
  • Placement, to the extent practicable and subject to statutory considerations, within 500 driving miles of a prisoner’s primary residence.
  • Changes to home-confinement provisions and reauthorization and expansion of an elderly-offender home-detention pilot program.
  • Requirements concerning identification documents and other preparation for release.

These measures operate alongside existing security, placement, and administrative requirements.

Implementation and interpretation

Implementation has involved developing assessment tools, expanding programming, calculating credits, and determining when eligible prisoners can transfer out of institutional custody. The act established a multiyear implementation schedule, so its different provisions did not all take practical effect at once.

Important administrative issues include access to qualifying programs, the accuracy and timeliness of credit calculations, and the availability of community placements. Assessment systems also raise questions about predictive validity and differences in outcomes across demographic groups. A tool’s ability to predict rearrest or reconviction is analytically distinct from whether its use produces equitable access to statutory benefits.

Courts have resolved significant questions of statutory interpretation. In Terry v. United States (2021), the Supreme Court held that certain low-level crack-cocaine offenses were not “covered offenses” under section 404. In Concepcion v. United States (2022), it held that courts considering section 404 motions may consider intervening changes in law or fact, while remaining subject to applicable statutory constraints.

The act’s effects must therefore be distinguished by mechanism: sentence reductions ordered by courts, good-conduct-time recalculations, transfers using earned time credits, and compassionate-release decisions involve different eligibility rules and forms of discretion. The legislation did not abolish federal mandatory minimum sentences, restore general federal parole, or make all of its sentencing reforms retroactive.