Energy-level degeneracy is the occurrence of two or more linearly independent states with the same energy in a quantum system. In quantum mechanics, these states are eigenstates of the system’s Hamiltonian operator with a common eigenvalue. The number of independent states sharing that eigenvalue is its degeneracy, usually denoted . Degeneracy frequently reflects a symmetry of the system, although equality of energies can also occur without an obvious geometrical symmetry. It is important in atomic spectra, molecular structure, solid-state physics, and statistical mechanics.
Mathematical definition
For a time-independent Hamiltonian , an energy eigenstate satisfies
If there are linearly independent solutions for the same energy , then is a -fold degenerate energy level. The index distinguishes an orthonormal basis of states within that level.
The states belonging to , together with the zero vector, form an eigenspace—a vector subspace of dimension . Any normalized linear combination
is also an eigenstate with energy . Consequently, a measurement of energy alone cannot distinguish all states within a degenerate level. Additional observables, such as a component of angular momentum, may distinguish a chosen basis.
A nondegenerate level has . Multiplying a state by an overall phase does not create an independent state and therefore does not constitute degeneracy. Degeneracy is also distinct from energy quantization: quantization concerns the allowed energy values, whereas degeneracy concerns how many independent states correspond to each value.
This definition applies most directly to discrete energy levels. Continuous spectra can also have multiplicities, but their treatment requires generalized eigenstates rather than ordinary normalizable eigenvectors.
Symmetry and its consequences
Symmetry-enforced degeneracy
A symmetry represented by a unitary operator leaves the Hamiltonian unchanged when
If has energy , then has the same energy. This produces degeneracy when the transformed state is linearly independent of the original one.
The existence of a commuting symmetry operator does not, by itself, guarantee degeneracy. A nondegenerate state can transform into a multiple of itself. More generally, multidimensional irreducible representations of a symmetry group enforce corresponding multiplets of equal-energy states.
For example, a rotationally invariant Hamiltonian gives equal energies to the different magnetic substates of a fixed angular-momentum multiplet. For angular-momentum quantum number ,
so the multiplet contains states. Additional quantum numbers may distinguish different multiplets with different energies.
Accidental and hidden-symmetry degeneracy
A degeneracy not required by the explicitly considered symmetries is often called accidental degeneracy. The term does not necessarily mean that the equality is unexplained: a deeper or hidden symmetry may account for it.
The nonrelativistic Coulomb problem is an important example. In the idealized hydrogen atom, with relativistic, radiative, spin-dependent, and external-field effects omitted, the bound-state energy depends only on the principal quantum number :
States with different orbital angular-momentum quantum numbers can therefore share the same energy. Ordinary rotational symmetry explains equality among magnetic substates, but not the entire degeneracy across different orbital angular momenta. The larger degeneracy is associated with an additional conserved quantity, the Runge–Lenz vector, and a hidden symmetry of the Coulomb Hamiltonian.
For a fixed , counting spatial states gives
Including two independent electron-spin states gives states in this approximation, before including nuclear spin. More complete descriptions split some of these equal energies.
Kramers degeneracy
Kramers’ theorem gives a distinct symmetry-based guarantee. If a Hamiltonian is invariant under the antiunitary time-reversal operator , and
every energy eigenstate has an orthogonal partner at the same energy. All discrete levels are therefore at least doubly degenerate.
This condition applies to many systems with half-integer total angular momentum, including appropriate systems containing an odd number of electrons. Time-reversal invariance is essential: a magnetic field generally breaks it and can split a Kramers pair. Time-reversal symmetry alone does not imply Kramers degeneracy when .
Representative examples
Rotational and spin multiplets
For a particle in a spherically symmetric, spin-independent potential, the energy does not depend on the magnetic orbital quantum number . Each fixed orbital-angular-momentum multiplet consequently has degeneracy .
If spin is completely uncoupled from the remaining dynamics, a particle of spin contributes a further factor . Spin–orbit coupling changes how the states are grouped: orbital and spin angular momentum combine into total angular momentum, and levels with different total-angular-momentum quantum numbers can acquire different energies while retaining rotational multiplets.
Isotropic harmonic oscillator
For the three-dimensional isotropic quantum harmonic oscillator,
Here is the reduced Planck constant, and is the common angular frequency in all three directions. Different triples of nonnegative integers can have the same sum . Without spin, the degeneracy is
Making the oscillator frequencies unequal generally removes this pattern, although special frequency ratios can preserve some equalities.
Electronic states in solids
In electronic band structure, crystal symmetries can require equal energies at particular wave vectors or along certain regions of reciprocal space. Time-reversal and spatial symmetries determine which degeneracies are protected and which can be removed.
Time reversal maps a wave vector to . It therefore does not, by itself, guarantee a twofold degeneracy at every individual ; Kramers degeneracy applies directly at time-reversal-invariant momenta, and additional spatial symmetries can enforce pairing more broadly.
A different example is Landau-level degeneracy. For ideal two-dimensional orbital motion in a uniform perpendicular magnetic field, many states with different guiding-center positions have the same cyclotron energy. Ignoring spin, the number of states per Landau level per unit area is
where is the particle’s charge and is the field magnitude. This degeneracy is central to the quantum Hall effect.
Lifting degeneracy
A change to the Hamiltonian can separate previously equal energies. This is called lifting or splitting the degeneracy. Common causes include external fields, lattice distortions, anisotropic interactions, and couplings omitted from an approximate model.
A magnetic field can produce Zeeman splitting. An electric field can produce Stark splitting. In molecules and crystals, changes in the local electrostatic environment can split initially degenerate atomic orbitals. Whether splitting occurs, and how much degeneracy remains, depends on the perturbation and the surviving symmetries.
Degenerate perturbation theory
Suppose
where is a small perturbation. Within a degenerate eigenspace of , form the matrix
The first-order energy corrections are times the eigenvalues of this matrix. Its eigenvectors identify the appropriate combinations of unperturbed states.
This is the basis of degenerate perturbation theory. Applying nondegenerate formulas directly can fail because those formulas contain energy differences in denominators, which vanish between degenerate states.
A perturbation need not remove all degeneracy. If its matrix is proportional to the identity within the subspace, there is no first-order splitting. Higher-order terms may split the level, unless a surviving symmetry protects the equality.
Statistical and spectroscopic significance
In statistical mechanics, degeneracy counts the states available at a given energy. For a system in canonical equilibrium, the partition function can be grouped by distinct energy levels:
where is the Boltzmann constant and is absolute temperature. The probability of occupying any state in level is
Each individual state has the same Boltzmann weight as any other state of equal energy. A more highly degenerate level nevertheless has a larger total equilibrium population than a less degenerate level at the same energy.
For an equal statistical mixture over states, the entropy is . This does not mean that every pure state within a degenerate eigenspace has that entropy: a pure quantum state has zero von Neumann entropy, regardless of the eigenspace’s dimension.
In spectroscopy, degeneracy and its lifting affect line positions, multiplicities, and populations. Degeneracy alone does not determine line intensity, which also depends on transition matrix elements, selection rules, and the experimental conditions.
Exact, approximate, and apparent degeneracy
Exact degeneracy means equality of energy eigenvalues for the specified Hamiltonian. Approximate degeneracy means that a small splitting is neglected relative to the relevant physical scale. Experimentally unresolved levels may appear degenerate even when their energies differ, because of linewidths or limited instrumental resolution.
Degeneracy must also be distinguished from particle occupancy. A degenerate level can contain several distinct one-particle states, but the Pauli exclusion principle still prevents identical fermions from occupying the same complete one-particle state. Multiple electrons may occupy different states of a degenerate level without violating that principle.