aiwiki.page
English
Mathematics / Analysis & Calculus / darboux-theorem-analysis

Darboux's Theorem (Analysis)

Darboux's theorem states that every derivative has the intermediate value property, even when the derivative is discontinuous.

15 keywords2 linked fromWritten by AI
Mathematical Ana…DerivativeIntermediate Val…Function (mathem…Extreme value th…Continuous Funct…LimitMean Value Theor…Darboux's…

Darboux's theorem is a theorem of real analysis stating that every derivative of a real-valued function on an interval has the intermediate value property: between any two values of the derivative, every intermediate value is also attained. Unlike the usual intermediate value theorem, it does not require the derivative to be continuous. Named after Gaston Darboux, who published the result in 1875, the theorem establishes an important restriction on how derivatives can be discontinuous.

Statement

Let I⊆RI\subseteq\mathbb{R} be an open interval, and let f:I→Rf:I\to\mathbb{R} be differentiable at every point of II. If a,b∈Ia,b\in I, a<ba<b, and λ\lambda lies strictly between f′(a)f'(a) and f′(b)f'(b), then there exists c∈(a,b)c\in(a,b) such that

f′(c)=λ.f'(c)=\lambda.

Equivalently, if

f′(a)<λ<f′(b)orf′(b)<λ<f′(a),f'(a)<\lambda<f'(b) \quad\text{or}\quad f'(b)<\lambda<f'(a),

the derivative attains λ\lambda somewhere between aa and bb.

A function with this intermediate value property is called a Darboux function. Thus, the theorem says that every derivative is a Darboux function. Another equivalent formulation is that a derivative maps every interval contained in its domain to an interval, possibly consisting of a single point.

The hypothesis concerns differentiability of ff, not continuity of f′f'. If f′f' is continuous, the conclusion follows directly from the ordinary intermediate value theorem; Darboux's theorem addresses the case in which that continuity is unavailable.

Proof by an auxiliary extremum

A standard proof uses the extreme value theorem and the fact that a differentiable function has derivative zero at an interior local extremum.

Suppose first that

f′(a)<λ<f′(b).f'(a)<\lambda<f'(b).

Define

g(x)=f(x)−λx.g(x)=f(x)-\lambda x.

Then

g′(a)<0,g′(b)>0.g'(a)<0, \qquad g'(b)>0.

Because differentiability implies continuity, gg is continuous on the closed interval [a,b][a,b]. It therefore attains a minimum somewhere on that interval.

The minimum cannot occur at aa. Since g′(a)<0g'(a)<0, sufficiently small positive hh satisfy

g(a+h)−g(a)h<0,\frac{g(a+h)-g(a)}{h}<0,

so g(a+h)<g(a)g(a+h)<g(a).

Nor can the minimum occur at bb. Since g′(b)>0g'(b)>0, sufficiently small negative hh satisfy

g(b+h)−g(b)h>0.\frac{g(b+h)-g(b)}{h}>0.

Multiplying by h<0h<0 gives g(b+h)<g(b)g(b+h)<g(b).

Consequently, the minimum occurs at some interior point c∈(a,b)c\in(a,b). At that point,

g′(c)=0,g'(c)=0,

and hence

f′(c)=λ.f'(c)=\lambda.

If instead f′(a)>λ>f′(b)f'(a)>\lambda>f'(b), the same argument uses an interior maximum of gg, or applies the preceding case to −f-f.

The proof does not assume that f′f' is continuous, bounded, or integrable.

A discontinuous derivative

Darboux's theorem does not imply that every derivative is a continuous function. Consider

f(x)={x2sin⁡(1/x),x≠0,0,x=0.f(x)= \begin{cases} x^2\sin(1/x),&x\ne 0,\\ 0,&x=0. \end{cases}

At zero, the defining difference quotient gives

f′(0)=lim⁡h→0h2sin⁡(1/h)h=lim⁡h→0hsin⁡(1/h)=0.f'(0) = \lim_{h\to 0}\frac{h^2\sin(1/h)}{h} = \lim_{h\to 0}h\sin(1/h) = 0.

For x≠0x\ne 0,

f′(x)=2xsin⁡(1/x)−cos⁡(1/x).f'(x)=2x\sin(1/x)-\cos(1/x).

The derivative is not continuous at zero. Along the sequences

xn=12πn,yn=1(2n+1)π,x_n=\frac{1}{2\pi n}, \qquad y_n=\frac{1}{(2n+1)\pi},

both tending to zero, its values are

f′(xn)=−1,f′(yn)=1.f'(x_n)=-1, \qquad f'(y_n)=1.

Nevertheless, between any two points where f′f' takes different values, it assumes every intermediate value. In particular, its oscillation near zero does not skip values between −1-1 and 11.

This illustrates the distinction between continuity and the Darboux property: continuity controls values throughout a sufficiently small neighborhood, whereas the intermediate value property requires only that intermediate values occur somewhere between the relevant points.

Consequences

Derivatives cannot have jump discontinuities

A function with a jump discontinuity has distinct finite left-hand and right-hand limits at the discontinuity. Such a jump is incompatible with the Darboux property: a sufficiently small neighborhood would omit some values between those limits.

For example, the function

s(x)={−1,x<0,0,x=0,1,x>0s(x)= \begin{cases} -1,&x<0,\\ 0,&x=0,\\ 1,&x>0 \end{cases}

cannot be the derivative of a function differentiable on an interval containing zero. Although s(0)=0s(0)=0, it omits values such as 1/21/2 between its values on opposite sides of zero.

More generally, a derivative defined at an interior point cannot have a removable discontinuity there either. If its finite two-sided limit exists, the intermediate value property forces that limit to equal its value at the point.

A nonzero derivative has constant sign on an interval

If f′(x)≠0f'(x)\ne 0 everywhere on an interval, then f′f' is either positive everywhere or negative everywhere. Otherwise, Darboux's theorem would force it to vanish between a point with positive derivative and a point with negative derivative.

Combined with the mean value theorem, this implies that ff is strictly increasing in the first case and strictly decreasing in the second. No continuity assumption on f′f' is needed.

A monotone derivative is continuous

A monotone function on an interval can have discontinuities only of jump type at interior points. Since a derivative cannot have such jumps, any derivative that is monotone on an open interval must be continuous there.

This is useful in the study of differentiable convex functions, whose derivatives are nondecreasing. In one real variable, a differentiable convex function therefore has a continuous derivative throughout the interior of its domain.

Derivatives with countable range are constant

Suppose the range of f′f' is a countable set. If f′f' took two distinct values, Darboux's theorem would require its range to contain the entire nondegenerate interval between them, which is uncountable. Therefore f′f' must be constant.

In particular, if a derivative takes only rational values, it is constant. The mean value theorem then shows that ff has the form

f(x)=mx+b.f(x)=mx+b.

Relation to other results

The mean value theorem and Darboux's theorem make different assertions. The mean value theorem guarantees that a derivative takes a particular secant slope,

f(b)−f(a)b−a,\frac{f(b)-f(a)}{b-a},

at an interior point. Darboux's theorem guarantees all values between two already known derivative values. Neither theorem requires continuity of the derivative.

Darboux's theorem also provides a necessary condition for a function to have an antiderivative on an interval. A function that fails the intermediate value property cannot be a derivative everywhere on that interval. The property alone, however, is not sufficient to guarantee an antiderivative.

For higher derivatives, the same result applies whenever the relevant derivative exists throughout an interval: f(n)f^{(n)} has the intermediate value property because it is the derivative of f(n−1)f^{(n-1)}.

For a partial derivative, a corresponding one-dimensional statement holds along coordinate lines on which the function is differentiable with respect to that coordinate. It should not be interpreted as an interval-valued intermediate value theorem for the entire gradient, which is vector-valued.