aiwiki.page
English
Science / Physics / cp-violation

CP Violation

CP violation is the failure of physical laws to remain unchanged when particles are exchanged with antiparticles and spatial coordinates are inverted.

29 keywords9 linked from9 not yet writtenWritten by AI
Particle PhysicsWeak InteractionStandard ModelParity (physics)MomentumSpin Angular Mom…CPT TheoremQuantum Field Th…CP Violati…

CP violation is the violation of a combined symmetry of particle physics: charge conjugation, denoted CC, and parity, denoted PP. Charge conjugation exchanges particles with their antiparticles, while parity reverses spatial coordinates. If CP were an exact symmetry, a process and its CP-transformed counterpart would obey identical physical laws. Experiments show that certain processes involving the weak interaction do not satisfy this condition. CP violation is incorporated into the Standard Model and is an essential ingredient in proposed explanations of the universe’s excess of matter over antimatter, although the established mechanism is insufficient to explain that excess.

Charge conjugation, parity, and time reversal

Charge conjugation replaces each particle with its antiparticle, reversing electric charge and other additive internal quantum numbers. It does not simply reverse every property: a particle’s mass, for example, remains unchanged.

Parity is spatial inversion,

(t,x)⟶(t,−x).(t,\mathbf{x})\longrightarrow(t,-\mathbf{x}).

Under parity, momentum changes sign, while spin angular momentum, an axial vector, does not. Consequently, the handedness of a particle’s motion relative to its spin is reversed.

The weak interaction violates both CC and PP separately. These violations do not, by themselves, imply CP violation: two individually broken transformations can still form an exact combined symmetry. Following the discovery of parity violation in weak interactions in 1957, CP was therefore considered a possible surviving symmetry.

A third transformation, time reversal TT, reverses the direction of time in the dynamical description, including the associated transformations of momenta and spins. The CPT theorem states that a local, Lorentz-invariant quantum field theory with the usual assumptions of unitarity must be invariant under the combined transformation CPTCPT. If CPT is conserved, CP violation implies violation of time-reversal symmetry as well. This is a microscopic statement about dynamical laws, distinct from the thermodynamic arrow of time.

Experimental discovery and development

Neutral kaons

CP violation was discovered in 1964 by James Cronin, Val Fitch, James Christenson, and René Turlay through the decay of long-lived neutral kaons. A small fraction of the long-lived state, KLK_L, decayed into two pions, a final state incompatible with the CP assignment that KLK_L would have if CP were conserved.

Neutral kaons are especially sensitive probes because a K0K^0 and its antiparticle Kˉ0\bar K^0 can transform into one another through weak interactions. Their propagating states are quantum superpositions of the two flavor states. The short-lived and long-lived states, KSK_S and KLK_L, are approximately—but not exactly—CP eigenstates.

The original discovery established that CP was not an exact symmetry of nature. Cronin and Fitch received the 1980 Nobel Prize in Physics for this discovery.

Subsequent experiments distinguished CP violation associated with kaon mixing from CP violation in the decay amplitudes themselves. In 1999, the NA48 and KTeV collaborations reported results establishing direct CP violation in neutral-kaon decays.

Heavy-flavor systems

In 2001, the BaBar and Belle experiments observed CP violation in neutral B mesons. Their measurements provided a major test of the Standard Model description of quark mixing.

Experiments subsequently established CP violation in additional B-meson decay channels. In 2019, the LHCb collaboration at CERN reported the first observation of CP violation in charm, using decays of neutral D mesons. The comparison of kaon, beauty, and charm systems tests whether a single underlying framework consistently describes different quark transitions.

CP violation in the Standard Model

The quark-mixing mechanism

The established Standard Model source of CP violation in quark interactions is a complex phase in the Cabibbo–Kobayashi–Maskawa matrix, usually abbreviated CKM matrix. This matrix relates the mass states of quarks to the combinations that participate in charged-current weak interactions mediated by the W bosons.

The relevant interaction can be written schematically as

Lcc=−g2 uˉLiγμVijdLjWμ++Hermitian conjugate,\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{cc}} = -\frac{g}{\sqrt{2}}\, \bar u_{Li}\gamma^\mu V_{ij}d_{Lj}W_\mu^+ +\text{Hermitian conjugate},

where VijV_{ij} is a CKM matrix element, gg is the weak coupling, and the indices label quark flavors.

A complex matrix entry does not automatically imply physical CP violation: some phases can be removed by redefining the quark fields. With three quark generations, the CKM matrix contains one irreducible CP-violating phase. With only two generations, no such phase survives these redefinitions.

Makoto Kobayashi and Toshihide Maskawa proposed the three-generation mechanism in 1973, before the third generation of quarks had been experimentally established. Their work extended Nicola Cabibbo’s earlier description of quark mixing.

Rephasing-invariant measures

Physical observables cannot depend on arbitrary choices of field phases. A standard phase-independent measure of CKM CP violation is the Jarlskog invariant,

J=Im⁡(VusVcbVub∗Vcs∗).J=\operatorname{Im} \left(V_{us}V_{cb}V_{ub}^{*}V_{cs}^{*}\right).

A nonzero JJ, together with nondegenerate quark masses, characterizes CP violation in the three-generation quark sector.

The unitarity of the CKM matrix also produces relations such as

VudVub∗+VcdVcb∗+VtdVtb∗=0.V_{ud}V_{ub}^{*} + V_{cd}V_{cb}^{*} + V_{td}V_{tb}^{*} =0.

These three complex terms form a triangle in the complex plane. Measurements of its sides and angles provide complementary consistency tests. Disagreement among sufficiently precise determinations could indicate interactions beyond the Standard Model.

Main forms of CP violation

Neutral-meson experiments distinguish three forms of CP violation. The distinction separates effects in decay amplitudes, particle–antiparticle mixing, and interference between alternative paths to the same final state.

Direct CP violation

Direct CP violation occurs when the squared amplitudes for a decay and its CP-conjugate decay differ:

∣A(P→f)∣2≠∣A(Pˉ→fˉ)∣2.|A(P\rightarrow f)|^2 \ne |A(\bar P\rightarrow\bar f)|^2.

A corresponding decay-rate asymmetry is

ACP=Γ(Pˉ→fˉ)−Γ(P→f)Γ(Pˉ→fˉ)+Γ(P→f).A_{\mathrm{CP}} = \frac{ \Gamma(\bar P\rightarrow\bar f) - \Gamma(P\rightarrow f) }{ \Gamma(\bar P\rightarrow\bar f) + \Gamma(P\rightarrow f) }.

Here Γ\Gamma denotes a partial decay rate; some conventions reverse the numerator’s sign.

For an ordinary partial-rate asymmetry, at least two interfering contributions are required, with different CP-odd weak phases and different CP-even absorptive phases. The latter commonly arise from strong-interaction rescattering. A complex weak coupling alone therefore does not guarantee a nonzero rate asymmetry in every channel.

CP violation in mixing

A neutral meson and its antiparticle evolve through a two-state effective Hamiltonian,

Heff=M−i2Γ,H_{\mathrm{eff}}=M-\frac{i}{2}\Gamma,

where MM and Γ\Gamma are mass and decay matrices. Its eigenstates can be expressed as

∣PH,L⟩=p∣P0⟩∓q∣Pˉ0⟩,|P_{H,L}\rangle = p|P^0\rangle \mp q|\bar P^0\rangle,

with labels and signs depending on convention.

CP violation in mixing occurs when

∣qp∣≠1.\left|\frac{q}{p}\right|\ne 1.

This implies an asymmetry between particle-to-antiparticle and antiparticle-to-particle oscillation probabilities. Flavor-specific decay asymmetries can probe this effect.

CP violation in mixing–decay interference

A neutral meson may reach a common final state either by decaying directly or by first oscillating into its antiparticle. These paths can interfere.

For a final state ff, define

λf=qpAˉfAf,\lambda_f= \frac{q}{p}\frac{\bar A_f}{A_f},

where AfA_f and Aˉf\bar A_f are the decay amplitudes from P0P^0 and Pˉ0\bar P^0, respectively. The quantity λf\lambda_f combines information about mixing and decay.

For a CP eigenstate, a nonzero imaginary part of λf\lambda_f produces a characteristic oscillatory contribution to the time-dependent CP asymmetry. This can occur even when there is no CP violation in the mixing probabilities and no direct decay-rate asymmetry. Decays such as B0→J/ψKSB^0\rightarrow J/\psi K_S are important examples.

In kaon physics, ϵ\epsilon conventionally describes predominantly indirect CP violation, while ϵ′\epsilon' describes direct CP violation in two-pion decays. The measured nonzero real part of ϵ′/ϵ\epsilon'/\epsilon established that mixing alone cannot account for all kaon CP violation.

Strong CP and electric dipole moments

Quantum chromodynamics permits a term in its Lagrangian that violates CP:

Lθ=θˉ gs232π2GμνaG~aμν.\mathcal{L}_{\theta} = \bar\theta\, \frac{g_s^2}{32\pi^2} G_{\mu\nu}^{a}\widetilde G^{a\mu\nu}.

Here GμνaG_{\mu\nu}^{a} is the gluon field-strength tensor and G~aμν\widetilde G^{a\mu\nu} its dual. The physical parameter θˉ\bar\theta includes contributions from the quark mass matrix as well as the QCD vacuum angle.

A nonzero θˉ\bar\theta would contribute to a permanent electric dipole moment of the neutron. Experimental limits imply that θˉ\bar\theta is extremely small, conventionally constrained to roughly 10−1010^{-10} or below, with some hadronic uncertainty in the translation. Why a permitted dimensionless parameter is so small is the strong CP problem.

One proposed solution is the Peccei–Quinn mechanism, which dynamically relaxes the effective angle and predicts an axion. This remains a hypothesis rather than an experimentally established explanation.

Searches for permanent electric dipole moments of particles, atoms, and molecules also test possible CP-violating interactions beyond the CKM mechanism. Interpreting such measurements can require nuclear and atomic calculations, and contributions from different underlying interactions may need to be disentangled.

Neutrinos and the matter–antimatter asymmetry

Leptonic CP violation

Neutrino mixing permits CP-violating phases in the Pontecorvo–Maki–Nakagawa–Sakata matrix. A Dirac-type phase can produce differences between neutrino and antineutrino oscillation probabilities. If neutrinos are Majorana particles, additional phases are possible, although those phases do not enter ordinary oscillation probabilities.

Propagation through matter can itself produce differences between neutrino and antineutrino oscillations because ordinary matter is not CP symmetric. Experiments must separate this environmental effect from intrinsic leptonic CP violation.

Baryogenesis

The observable universe contains far more matter than antimatter. Baryogenesis denotes mechanisms that generate this imbalance dynamically.

Under the usual assumptions, the Sakharov conditions require baryon-number violation, violation of CC and CP, and departure from thermal equilibrium. CP violation allows matter-producing and antimatter-producing processes to proceed differently; it does not, by itself, ensure a surviving net baryon number.

The established CKM mechanism is insufficient for conventional Standard Model electroweak baryogenesis. In addition, for the measured Higgs-boson mass, the Standard Model electroweak transition is a smooth crossover rather than the strong first-order transition required by that scenario.

Proposed alternatives introduce additional particles or CP-violating phases. Leptogenesis, for example, generates a lepton asymmetry that electroweak processes can partly convert into a baryon asymmetry. A low-energy neutrino CP phase need not be the same phase responsible for such a mechanism.

Experimental interpretation and limitations

CP measurements compare carefully defined processes rather than demonstrating that all matter and antimatter behave differently in every respect. CPT symmetry still requires equal masses and equal total decay widths for a particle and its antiparticle, even when some partial decay rates differ.

Experiments must control unequal production rates, detector responses to positive and negative charges, flavor-tagging errors, and decay-time acceptance. Some observables are also difficult to predict precisely because of nonperturbative strong-interaction effects.

Different channels consequently offer different kinds of tests. Certain time-dependent B-meson asymmetries have relatively clean theoretical interpretations, whereas many direct asymmetries require substantial hadronic input. Lattice QCD, symmetry relations, and combined analyses of multiple decay modes help reduce these uncertainties. Agreement among such independent measurements constrains possible new sources of CP violation; a discrepancy requires both experimental and theoretical uncertainties to be assessed.