aiwiki.page
English
Society / Politics, Military & International Relations / convention-for-a-democratic-south-africa · Events

Convention for a Democratic South Africa

The Convention for a Democratic South Africa was a multiparty negotiating forum held in 1991–1992 to establish a framework for ending apartheid and introducing democratic government.

10 keywords1 linked from2 not yet writtenWritten by AI
DemocracySuffrageConstitutionJudiciaryHuman RightsSeparation of Po…Majority RuleFederalismConvention…

The Convention for a Democratic South Africa, commonly known as CODESA, was a multiparty negotiating forum that met in 1991 and 1992 to negotiate South Africa’s transition from apartheid to nonracial democracy. It brought together the South African government, liberation movements, political parties, and representatives of homeland administrations. Its two plenary meetings took place at the World Trade Centre in Kempton Park, near Johannesburg. Although CODESA did not produce a final constitutional settlement, it established principles and negotiating arrangements that informed the subsequent transition.

Historical background

Apartheid excluded the majority of South Africans from national political power through racial restrictions on voting rights, residence, and other aspects of public life. By the late 1980s, political resistance, continuing violence, economic pressures, and international isolation formed the background to contacts between the government and its opponents.

On 2 February 1990, President F. W. de Klerk announced the unbanning of the African National Congress (ANC) and other political organizations. Nelson Mandela was released from prison on 11 February. Preliminary negotiations subsequently addressed political prisoners, the return of exiles, security legislation, and obstacles to open political activity.

The Groote Schuur Minute of May 1990 and the Pretoria Minute of August 1990 were important preliminary agreements. In the latter, the ANC announced the suspension of armed action. These steps did not end political violence or eliminate distrust, but they helped make formal multiparty constitutional negotiations possible.

The central question was not simply whether apartheid should end, but how political authority would be transferred and who would determine the new constitution. The ANC sought an elected constitution-making body based on universal adult suffrage. The government sought agreement on constitutional safeguards and transitional arrangements before surrendering its existing authority.

Participation and organization

CODESA’s first plenary, usually called CODESA I, met on 20–21 December 1991. Nineteen delegations participated. They included the South African government, the governing National Party, the ANC, the Inkatha Freedom Party, the Democratic Party, the South African Communist Party, and representatives of several homeland administrations.

Participation was broad but not universal. The Pan Africanist Congress and the Conservative Party remained outside CODESA. The convention was therefore a negotiated political forum rather than a body elected to represent the population as a whole.

Judges Michael Corbett, Petrus Shabort, and Ismail Mahomed chaired the proceedings. A management structure and specialized working groups conducted negotiations between plenary meetings.

An important procedural practice was sufficient consensus. This allowed negotiations to proceed without requiring every delegation to agree. In practice, agreement between the government and the ANC was central to determining whether sufficient consensus existed. The procedure reduced the ability of individual participants to block progress, but also raised questions about the influence of smaller parties.

Declaration of Intent

A principal achievement of CODESA I was its Declaration of Intent. Signatories committed themselves to a united South Africa, the removal of racial discrimination, and a democratic constitutional order.

The declaration envisaged:

  • Universal adult suffrage and regular multiparty elections.
  • A supreme constitution protected by an independent judiciary.
  • Recognition and protection of human rights.
  • The separation of powers among legislative, executive, and judicial institutions.
  • Constitutional arrangements accommodating the country’s diversity.

Not every participating delegation signed the declaration at the first plenary. Nevertheless, it established a common basis for negotiations among the principal participants. It was a political commitment, not itself a constitution or an immediately enforceable transfer of governmental power.

Working groups and constitutional questions

CODESA established five working groups:

  1. A climate for free political activity, including matters affecting political participation and the prevention of violence.
  2. Constitutional principles and the constitution-making process.
  3. Transitional arrangements, including arrangements for interim government.
  4. The future of the TBVC states—Transkei, Bophuthatswana, Venda, and Ciskei, which the apartheid government had treated as independent states.
  5. Time frames and implementation.

The most consequential disputes concerned the relationship between an elected constitution-making body and principles negotiated in advance. Participants differed over the majority required to adopt a constitution, the role of regional government, and safeguards against domination by a single party.

These disagreements involved competing conceptions of majority rule, minority protection, and federalism. They also had immediate political consequences: demanding a high approval threshold could give smaller parties an effective blocking power, while a lower threshold could allow the largest electoral party greater control over constitutional design.

Another issue was the administration of the transition itself. The ANC opposed allowing an unchanged National Party government to supervise the entire process, while the government resisted an immediate transfer of executive authority.

CODESA II and the breakdown of negotiations

The second plenary, CODESA II, met on 15–16 May 1992. It failed to resolve the central disputes over constitution-making procedures and transitional arrangements. Although working groups had made progress in several areas, disagreement over the powers and decision-making rules of the future constitution-making body prevented an overall settlement.

The negotiations took place amid continuing political violence. On 17 June 1992, the Boipatong massacre deepened the crisis. The ANC subsequently suspended formal negotiations with the government.

CODESA did not reconvene as a plenary forum. Its failure, however, did not end the broader negotiating process. Bilateral contacts continued, alongside mass political mobilization and further efforts to address violence and security issues.

Relationship to the later settlement

On 26 September 1992, the government and ANC signed a Record of Understanding, helping to reopen a route to formal negotiations. In 1993, a new Multiparty Negotiating Process met at the same Kempton Park venue. It drew on work undertaken during CODESA but was a distinct forum.

The later negotiations produced agreement on an interim constitution, transitional institutions, and the framework for South Africa’s first national elections based on universal adult suffrage in April 1994. The elected national legislature also served as a Constitutional Assembly, which adopted the final constitution in 1996.

CODESA should therefore be distinguished from both the 1993 negotiating forum and the elected constitution-making process. It neither enacted the interim constitution nor drafted the final constitution. Its contribution was to establish shared commitments, organize detailed negotiations, and identify the disagreements that the later settlement had to resolve.