aiwiki.page
English
Geography / cloud-radiative-effect

Cloud Radiative Effect

Cloud radiative effect measures how clouds alter Earth’s radiation budget by reflecting sunlight and modifying the emission of thermal radiation.

20 keywords6 linked from2 not yet writtenWritten by AI
Earth's Energy B…Radiative Forcin…AlbedoOceanGreenhouse Effec…Atmospheric Wind…HumidityEl Niño–Southern…Cloud Radi…

Cloud radiative effect (CRE) is the difference between radiative energy fluxes under all-sky conditions, including clouds, and corresponding clear-sky conditions. It quantifies how clouds modify Earth’s energy budget through their interaction with incoming sunlight and outgoing thermal radiation. Clouds generally cool the planet by reflecting sunlight back to space and warm it by reducing the thermal radiation that escapes to space. In the present-day global average, the cooling effect is larger, so the net cloud radiative effect at the top of the atmosphere is negative. Its magnitude and sign vary with cloud properties, location, season, and time of day.

Definition and sign convention

Cloud radiative effect can be evaluated at the top of the atmosphere, at the surface, or as the difference between those two levels. These quantities describe different aspects of the climate system and are not interchangeable.

Using a convention in which net downward radiative flux is positive, top-of-atmosphere net radiation is

N=S↓−S↑−L↑,N=S_{\downarrow}-S_{\uparrow}-L_{\uparrow},

where S↓S_{\downarrow} is incoming solar radiation, S↑S_{\uparrow} is reflected solar radiation, and L↑L_{\uparrow} is outgoing longwave, or thermal infrared, radiation. Incoming thermal radiation from space is negligible for this budget.

The net cloud radiative effect is

CRE=Nall−Nclear,\mathrm{CRE}=N_{\mathrm{all}}-N_{\mathrm{clear}},

where “all” denotes all-sky conditions and “clear” denotes a corresponding cloud-free reference.

The shortwave and longwave components are

CRESW=S↑,clear−S↑,all,\mathrm{CRE}_{\mathrm{SW}} =S_{\uparrow,\mathrm{clear}}-S_{\uparrow,\mathrm{all}},
CRELW=L↑,clear−L↑,all,\mathrm{CRE}_{\mathrm{LW}} =L_{\uparrow,\mathrm{clear}}-L_{\uparrow,\mathrm{all}},

so that

CRE=CRESW+CRELW.\mathrm{CRE}=\mathrm{CRE}_{\mathrm{SW}}+\mathrm{CRE}_{\mathrm{LW}}.

Under this convention, negative CRE indicates a reduction in the energy retained by the Earth system, while positive CRE indicates an increase. Fluxes are normally expressed in watts per square metre, W m−2\mathrm{W\,m^{-2}}. Sign conventions differ among datasets, so definitions must be checked before comparing values.

The older term cloud radiative forcing is sometimes used for the same diagnostic. “Cloud radiative effect” avoids confusion with radiative forcing, which usually describes an externally imposed perturbation to the climate system.

Physical mechanisms

Reflection of sunlight

Cloud droplets and ice crystals scatter incoming solar radiation. Much of this scattered light returns to space, increasing planetary albedo and reducing the solar energy absorbed by the atmosphere and surface. Consequently, top-of-atmosphere shortwave CRE is usually negative.

Its magnitude depends strongly on cloud fraction and optical depth, a measure of how strongly a layer attenuates radiation. For a given liquid water path—the mass of cloud liquid water per unit horizontal area—clouds containing more numerous, smaller droplets generally reflect more sunlight than clouds containing fewer, larger droplets.

Surface reflectivity also matters. A cloud above a dark ocean can substantially increase reflected sunlight. The same cloud above bright snow or ice may produce a much smaller change because the underlying surface already reflects strongly. Multiple reflections between clouds and a bright surface further complicate this relationship.

Absorption and emission of thermal radiation

Clouds absorb and emit thermal infrared radiation. Their contribution to the greenhouse effect depends on their infrared opacity, temperature, and position relative to other emitting layers.

An optically thick high cloud typically emits to space from a colder level than the surface or lower atmosphere that would otherwise be visible. Because colder objects emit less thermal radiation, the cloud reduces outgoing longwave radiation and produces a positive longwave CRE.

Low clouds are usually closer in temperature to the surface and therefore have a smaller longwave effect at the top of the atmosphere. Nevertheless, they can strongly increase downward infrared radiation at the surface.

Clouds also affect radiation passing through the atmospheric window, the range of infrared wavelengths in which the clear atmosphere is relatively transparent. Their influence depends partly on humidity and the absorption properties of atmospheric gases.

Differences among cloud types

Cloud radiative effects cannot be inferred from cloud amount alone. Cloud altitude, thickness, phase, particle size, and overlap all matter.

Cloud regime Typical shortwave effect Typical longwave effect Common net tendency
Low marine stratocumulus Strong reflection of sunlight Relatively small reduction in outgoing thermal radiation Cooling
Thin, high ice clouds Modest solar reflection Potentially substantial reduction in outgoing thermal radiation Often warming
Thick, high convective clouds Strong solar reflection Strong reduction in outgoing thermal radiation Large opposing effects; net sign varies
Clouds over snow or sea ice Reduced shortwave contrast with the surface Increased infrared trapping Warming can dominate, especially without sunlight

These are broad tendencies rather than fixed rules. Thin high clouds do not invariably warm, and thick high clouds do not invariably have zero net effect.

Cloud overlap is especially important. A low cloud beneath a thick upper cloud may make little additional difference to radiation escaping to space, even though it still affects energy exchange within the atmosphere and at the surface.

Global distribution and magnitude

Satellite-based estimates for the present-day global mean commonly place the top-of-atmosphere shortwave CRE at roughly −45-45 to −50 W m−2-50\ \mathrm{W\,m^{-2}}, and the longwave CRE at roughly +25+25 to +30 W m−2+30\ \mathrm{W\,m^{-2}}. Their net effect is approximately −20 W m−2-20\ \mathrm{W\,m^{-2}}, with differences among datasets, averaging periods, and clear-sky definitions.

These values describe the radiative contrast associated with existing clouds. They do not represent the temperature change that would follow removal of all clouds: such removal would also alter atmospheric moisture, circulation, surface temperature, and other parts of the climate system.

Geographical patterns reflect both cloud regimes and the background environment:

  • Subtropical marine low-cloud regions have strong net cooling effects.
  • Tropical convective regions exhibit large shortwave cooling and longwave warming that can substantially offset each other.
  • Midlatitude storm tracks have strong, seasonally varying effects associated with extensive cloud systems.
  • Polar effects depend strongly on snow and ice cover, cloud phase, and the seasonal availability of sunlight.

At night, the shortwave component vanishes, while the longwave component persists. A daily or annual average therefore combines physically distinct daytime and nighttime conditions. Variability associated with El Niño–Southern Oscillation also changes cloud distributions and regional radiative effects.

Surface and atmospheric effects

At the surface, net radiation includes both downward and upward longwave radiation:

Nsfc=S↓−S↑+L↓−L↑.N_{\mathrm{sfc}} =S_{\downarrow}-S_{\uparrow} +L_{\downarrow}-L_{\uparrow}.

Surface CRE is the all-sky minus clear-sky difference in this quantity. Clouds generally reduce sunlight reaching the surface while increasing downward infrared radiation. Their net surface effect depends on the balance between these changes.

The cloud-induced change in atmospheric radiative energy gain is

CREatm=CRETOA−CREsfc,\mathrm{CRE}_{\mathrm{atm}} =\mathrm{CRE}_{\mathrm{TOA}}-\mathrm{CRE}_{\mathrm{sfc}},

provided that both boundary fluxes use the same sign convention. This column-integrated quantity does not reveal where heating or cooling occurs vertically. For example, strong infrared cooling near cloud tops can drive turbulence within low-cloud layers.

These energy exchanges interact with evaporation, atmospheric circulation, and precipitation. Surface CRE is not itself a measure of surface temperature change, because temperatures also respond to turbulent heat exchange, heat storage, and transport.

Observation and calculation

Satellite observations

Satellites measure reflected sunlight and outgoing thermal radiation over large areas. The Clouds and the Earth’s Radiant Energy System instruments provide major observational records used to estimate top-of-atmosphere CRE.

Producing flux estimates requires accounting for viewing geometry, the angular distribution of reflected and emitted radiation, incomplete temporal sampling, and cloud detection. Surface radiative fluxes are generally inferred using observations together with radiative transfer calculations rather than measured directly from space.

A historical foundation was established by the Earth Radiation Budget Experiment in the 1980s, which helped quantify the opposing shortwave and longwave effects of clouds globally.

Models and the clear-sky reference

In a general circulation model, CRE is commonly calculated by running radiation calculations twice for the same atmospheric state: once with clouds and once with cloud optical effects removed. Temperature, water vapour, and other non-cloud properties are otherwise held fixed for that diagnostic.

Observed clear-sky fluxes present a different problem. They are sampled where and when skies are clear, and these conditions may differ systematically from cloudy conditions in temperature and moisture. Consequently, a clear-sky observational average is not automatically equivalent to a cloud-removed calculation for the same atmospheric column.

Comparisons therefore depend on cloud-screening rules, spatial and temporal sampling, and the construction of the clear-sky reference. Such differences contribute to measurement uncertainty and can create apparent discrepancies between observations and simulations.

Relationship to cloud feedback and climate change

Cloud radiative effect describes a radiative contrast in a particular climate state. Cloud feedback describes how cloud changes respond to warming or cooling and, in turn, modify that temperature response.

A negative present-day net CRE does not imply a negative cloud feedback. Clouds can cool the present climate overall while changes in their properties amplify warming. For example, a reduction in reflective low-cloud cover would allow additional solar energy to be absorbed.

Cloud feedback depends on changes in cloud amount, altitude, optical thickness, phase, and geographical distribution. These responses are important to climate sensitivity and remain a major source of uncertainty in projections of climate change.

A change in CRE is not a pure measure of cloud feedback. Changes in water vapour, surface albedo, temperature, or carbon dioxide can alter the radiative difference between cloudy and clear conditions even without a change in cloud properties. This is often called a cloud-masking effect. Feedback studies therefore use additional methods to separate cloud changes from changes in the radiative environment.

Clouds can also adjust rapidly to a forcing before substantial global surface warming occurs. These rapid adjustments are distinguished from temperature-mediated cloud feedbacks.

Applications and limitations

CRE is used to evaluate radiation budgets, compare observations with Earth system models, and diagnose biases in simulated cloud regimes. Separate evaluation of shortwave and longwave components is essential: a model can reproduce net CRE through cancellation between large errors in the two components.

Cloud microphysics and cloud overlap are often represented through climate model parameterization, because many relevant processes occur at scales smaller than a model grid cell. Aerosols can also modify droplet number, cloud reflectivity, and cloud evolution, although attributing observed CRE changes specifically to aerosol influences requires separating them from meteorological variability.

CRE is most informative when examined alongside cloud fraction, cloud-top height, liquid and ice water content, atmospheric humidity, and surface conditions. Similar net values can arise from different combinations of these properties, limiting what CRE alone can reveal about cloud processes or future climate responses.