Certiorari is a procedure by which a higher court reviews a decision or proceeding of a lower court, tribunal, or other public decision-maker. Originating in English common law, it traditionally involved an order requiring the record of proceedings to be brought before a superior court so that their legality could be examined. Its modern meaning varies by legal system. In many Commonwealth jurisdictions, certiorari is a remedy in judicial review through which an unlawful decision may be quashed. In the United States, it is best known as the discretionary procedure by which the Supreme Court of the United States selects most of the cases it hears.
Origins and development
The name derives from Latin and is conventionally translated as “to be informed” or “to be made certain.” It comes from the language of the original writ, which expressed the superior authority’s wish to be informed about specified proceedings.
Certiorari developed within the English royal courts as a means of bringing proceedings and records before them. It became closely associated with the supervisory authority of the Court of King’s Bench over inferior courts and other bodies exercising legally conferred powers. Its historical uses included both removing proceedings into a superior court and examining decisions for legal defects.
As administrative law developed, certiorari became an important means of controlling the exercise of public power. Its availability was no longer confined to bodies formally classified as courts. Depending on the jurisdiction, administrative tribunals, public officials, and other bodies performing public functions could also be subject to review.
This history produced two distinct modern uses: supervision of the legality of public decision-making, and discretionary selection of cases for appellate review. Although both descend from the same writ, their purposes and procedures differ substantially.
Supervisory review
In its traditional supervisory form, certiorari is a legal remedy directed at a decision or proceeding affected by a legally significant defect. A reviewing court does not simply decide whether it would have reached a better result. It asks whether the decision-maker acted within the limits imposed by law.
Grounds of review
The precise grounds vary across jurisdictions, but commonly include:
- Lack or excess of jurisdiction: the decision-maker had no authority to decide the matter or exceeded the limits of that authority.
- Error of law: the decision rests on a legal mistake that the applicable system recognizes as reviewable.
- Procedural unfairness: the process failed to provide legally required fairness, such as an adequate opportunity to be heard or an impartial decision-maker.
- Misuse of statutory powers: a power was exercised for an improper purpose or through consideration of legally irrelevant matters.
- Other recognized grounds of unlawfulness: these may include irrationality or, where applicable, disproportionality.
Historically, courts sometimes distinguished between errors affecting jurisdiction and errors apparent on the face of the record. The importance and meaning of those distinctions have changed over time and remain jurisdiction-specific. Some systems have substantially broadened review for legal error; others continue to attach particular significance to whether an error is jurisdictional.
Procedural fairness overlaps with due process, although the terminology and constitutional foundations are not identical across legal systems.
Effect of the remedy
A successful application commonly results in the challenged decision being quashed, meaning that it is set aside. The matter may then be returned to the original decision-maker for lawful reconsideration.
Quashing does not necessarily establish what the ultimate substantive outcome must be. For example, a licensing decision set aside because an applicant was denied a fair hearing may be made again after a lawful hearing, potentially with the same result.
Certiorari does not ordinarily award damages. Monetary relief, where available, generally depends on a separate legal basis. Relief may also be discretionary: establishing unlawfulness does not invariably require a court to grant every remedy sought. Delay, an adequate alternative remedy, or other legally recognized considerations may affect the outcome.
Certiorari in the United States Supreme Court
In the United States, a petition for a writ of certiorari asks the Supreme Court to exercise discretionary review. This differs from an appeal that a court is legally obliged to entertain when applicable requirements are met.
The Supreme Court’s authority remains bounded by the United States Constitution and federal statutes. A petition cannot create jurisdiction where none exists. Within those limits, however, the Court has broad discretion to select cases.
Cases eligible for review
Certiorari is the principal route by which the Court reviews decisions of federal courts of appeals. It can also review qualifying judgments from state courts when a federal question is properly presented. State-court review is generally subject to finality requirements and ordinarily concerns a judgment from the highest state court in which a decision could be obtained.
The Supreme Court does not use certiorari to provide general supervision over state law. An adequate and independent state-law ground supporting a judgment ordinarily prevents review of a federal issue when resolving that issue would not affect the judgment.
In exceptional circumstances, the Court may grant certiorari before judgment, reviewing a case pending in a federal court of appeals before that court has decided it. The Court’s rules reserve this procedure for matters of such imperative public importance that departure from ordinary appellate practice is justified.
Selection criteria and the Rule of Four
Supreme Court Rule 10 explains that review on certiorari is not a matter of right but of judicial discretion, and is granted only for compelling reasons. Important considerations include:
- Conflicting decisions among federal courts of appeals.
- Conflicts involving state courts of last resort on important federal questions.
- Important questions of federal law that warrant authoritative resolution.
- Decisions that conflict with relevant Supreme Court precedent.
- Serious departures from the accepted and usual course of judicial proceedings.
The Court ordinarily does not grant review merely to correct an erroneous factual finding or the misapplication of a properly stated legal rule. Its case-selection function emphasizes questions extending beyond the immediate parties.
Under the Court’s established Rule of Four, four justices can vote to grant certiorari. This is distinct from the voting ordinarily required to decide a case on its merits.
Granting and denying certiorari
Granting certiorari means that the Court has agreed to review a case; it does not mean that the judgment below is incorrect. Review is normally confined to the questions accepted by the Court or fairly included within them.
A denial of certiorari does not express approval of the lower court’s reasoning and does not constitute a Supreme Court decision on the merits. It creates no Supreme Court precedent resolving the issues presented. The lower court’s judgment remains in place, with whatever binding effect it otherwise has.
The Court may also dispose of a petition by granting review, vacating the judgment, and remanding the case for further consideration—a procedure commonly called a GVR. Such an order often allows the lower court to reconsider its decision in light of an intervening development without a full Supreme Court merits decision.
Expansion of discretionary review
The Judiciary Act of 1891 introduced an important statutory role for Supreme Court certiorari in the reorganized federal appellate system. The Judiciary Act of 1925 substantially expanded the Court’s control over its docket. Legislation in 1988 removed most of the remaining categories of mandatory appellate review.
These changes helped establish the modern Court’s predominantly discretionary docket, although limited forms of direct appeal remain.
Other jurisdictions
England and Wales
In England and Wales, the remedy historically called certiorari is now generally termed a quashing order. Modern procedural terminology replaced the older name in 2004.
Quashing orders form part of judicial review of public decision-making. Their principal function is to set aside unlawful decisions, not to provide a general rehearing of the merits. The change in terminology did not erase the remedy’s historical relationship with the supervisory jurisdiction of the High Court.
India
In India, certiorari is among the writs expressly identified in the Constitution. Article 32 empowers the Supreme Court to issue appropriate directions, orders, or writs for the enforcement of fundamental rights. Article 226 empowers High Courts to issue such remedies both for the enforcement of fundamental rights and “for any other purpose.”
Certiorari is therefore an important instrument of constitutional and administrative review. It may address jurisdictional defects, legally reviewable errors, and failures of procedural fairness. It is not equivalent to a general appeal permitting a reviewing court to reassess every factual or legal conclusion.
Australia
Australian law retains certiorari as a supervisory remedy, with jurisdictional error occupying a central position in its operation.
Section 75(v) of the Australian Constitution expressly refers to mandamus, prohibition, and injunctions against officers of the Commonwealth, but does not name certiorari. The High Court may nevertheless grant certiorari as ancillary relief where appropriate in the exercise of that jurisdiction. State supreme courts also exercise supervisory jurisdiction in which certiorari has an important role.
These constitutional arrangements illustrate why the availability and scope of the remedy cannot be inferred from its name alone.
Distinction from related procedures
| Procedure | Principal function |
|---|---|
| Certiorari in traditional supervisory review | Examines the legality of a decision or proceeding and may quash it. |
| Certiorari in the U.S. Supreme Court | Provides a discretionary route for selecting cases for review. |
| Appeal | Reviews a decision under powers defined by law, potentially including broader reconsideration of legal or factual issues. |
| **[[mandamus | Mandamus]]** |
| **[[writ-of-prohibition | Prohibition]]** |
| **[[habeas-corpus | Habeas corpus]]** |
| Injunction | Requires or restrains specified conduct. |
The traditional distinction between prohibition and certiorari is often expressed in temporal terms: prohibition prevents unlawful proceedings from continuing, while certiorari sets aside an unlawful decision already made. Actual proceedings may involve overlapping grounds and multiple remedies.
Scope and institutional limits
Certiorari serves both the correction of unlawful exercises of power and the maintenance of a coherent legal system. Supervisory certiorari supports the rule of law by keeping decision-makers within their legal authority. Discretionary appellate certiorari allows a highest court to concentrate on conflicts and questions of wider significance.
Those functions also impose limits. Supervisory review is not ordinarily a substitute for a statutory merits appeal, and discretionary Supreme Court review does not guarantee correction of every erroneous judgment. Questions of standing, timeliness, finality, available alternative remedies, and statutory restrictions can all affect review, but their operation depends on the particular jurisdiction and procedural route.