The Basel problem is the problem of finding the exact value of the infinite series
Its solution is
where is the circle constant. First posed by Pietro Mengoli in 1650 and solved by Leonhard Euler in 1735, the problem became a landmark in the study of infinite processes. It connects elementary summation with analysis, number theory, and the Riemann zeta function.
Statement and convergence
The problem asks for an exact evaluation, not merely a proof that the sum exists or a decimal approximation. Its value is approximately
Convergence follows from a simple comparison with an integral. Since is positive and decreasing for , the remainder after terms satisfies
Consequently,
These bounds prove convergence and give an explicit estimate of the truncation error. They do not, however, identify the sum as . That exact identification was the central difficulty.
The series is a special case of
which converges for real and diverges for . In particular, the corresponding series with , the harmonic series, diverges.
Historical development
Mengoli posed the reciprocal-square summation problem in 1650. It subsequently attracted several leading mathematicians, including members of the Bernoulli family. The conventional name refers to Basel, the Swiss city associated with the Bernoullis and with Euler, who was born there.
Euler obtained the exact value in 1735. His decisive idea was to treat the sine function in a way analogous to a polynomial: express it through its zeros, then compare coefficients with its known power series.
This approach was remarkably productive, but it required care. An infinite product cannot automatically be manipulated as though it were a finite polynomial, and the zeros of a function alone do not determine the function. Modern treatments justify Euler’s product identity and the coefficient comparison using convergence results from analysis.
Euler’s work also extended beyond the original problem to sums of reciprocal even powers, revealing a systematic relationship between these series and powers of .
Euler’s sine-product method
The nonzero zeros of occur at
Pairing the positive and negative zeros suggests the product
with the left-hand side interpreted as at .
The Taylor series gives
For a finite product,
the coefficient of is
Passing to the infinite product and comparing with the coefficient therefore yields
which proves the result.
Why the infinite-product step needs justification
Knowing a function’s zeros is not sufficient to establish its product representation: multiplying by a nonvanishing analytic function preserves the zeros. Thus the displayed sine product requires an independent proof.
Once that identity is established, its locally uniform convergence in the complex plane permits coefficient comparison. Here, “locally uniform” means uniform convergence on each compact subset. This distinction illustrates an important principle of complex analysis: intuitive algebra with infinite expressions becomes rigorous only after appropriate convergence and normalization conditions are supplied.
A Fourier-series proof
A different proof uses the Fourier series of on , extended periodically.
Because is even, all sine coefficients vanish. Its constant coefficient is
For , two applications of integration by parts give
Hence
The periodic extension is continuous and piecewise smooth, so the Fourier series converges to the function, including at . Substituting that value gives
and therefore
This proof connects the original summation problem to harmonic analysis rather than to an infinite product.
Connection with the zeta function
For a complex number with , the Riemann zeta function is defined by
The Basel problem is precisely the evaluation
More generally, Euler’s formula for positive integers is
where are Bernoulli numbers. For example,
Thus every positive even zeta value is a rational multiple of the corresponding even power of . No comparable general evaluation is known for the positive odd values . The irrationality of is known, but an analogous formula in powers of is not.
Consequences and applications
Coprime integer pairs
The unique factorization of integers gives the Euler product
Taking reciprocals yields
This constant is the limiting proportion of pairs of positive integers that are coprime:
Here denotes the greatest common divisor. The finite sampling and limiting formulation matters: there is no uniform probability distribution on all positive integers.
Related reciprocal-square sums
Separating the even and odd terms immediately gives
and
Subtracting the even terms from the odd terms also gives
Numerical computation
Direct summation is simple but relatively slow: its error is of order . More precisely, the asymptotic expansion of the remainder begins
Adding these correction terms to a finite sum greatly improves accuracy. The example distinguishes two questions in numerical analysis: whether an approximation converges, and how quickly it approaches its limit.