The Universal Periodic Review (UPR) is a mechanism of the United Nations Human Rights Council for periodically examining the human rights record of every United Nations member state. Conducted through an intergovernmental dialogue, it gives other states an opportunity to ask questions, assess developments, and recommend action. The state under review reports on its record and indicates which recommendations it supports. The UPR is a cooperative review mechanism, not a court or an individual complaints procedure.
Establishment and principles
The United Nations General Assembly established the UPR in Resolution 60/251 of 15 March 2006, which also created the Human Rights Council. The Council set out the mechanism’s procedures in Resolution 5/1 of 18 June 2007. Reviews began in 2008. A subsequent institutional review, reflected in Council Resolution 16/21 of 2011, adjusted the process for later cycles.
The mechanism’s defining feature is universal coverage: every UN member state undergoes review, regardless of its size, political system, or membership of particular human rights treaties. Its founding principles include equal treatment, dialogue, cooperation, and reliance on objective and reliable information. It is intended to complement, rather than duplicate, other UN human rights mechanisms.
The UPR combines scrutiny of a state’s record with discussion of technical assistance and capacity-building. Its stated objectives include improving conditions on the ground, assessing progress and challenges, sharing practices, and supporting the fulfilment of human rights obligations and commitments.
Basis and scope of review
The review is based on:
- The United Nations Charter.
- The Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
- Human rights instruments to which the state is a party.
- Voluntary pledges and commitments made by the state, including those associated with its candidacy for the Human Rights Council.
- Applicable international humanitarian law.
This framework allows the UPR to address a broad range of issues. Recommendations may concern civil and political rights, economic, social and cultural rights, discrimination, access to public services, the administration of justice, and protection of particular groups.
A review may also recommend ratification of a treaty or withdrawal of reservations. Such a recommendation does not itself make the state a party to that treaty or change its existing legal obligations.
Review cycle and documentation
After an initial four-year cycle, the process moved to cycles of approximately four and a half years. Under this arrangement, 42 states are normally reviewed each year, across three sessions of the UPR Working Group.
The first cycle took place from 2008 to 2011, the second from 2012 to 2016, and the third from 2017 to 2022. The fourth cycle began in November 2022.
Each review is informed by three principal documents:
- The national report, prepared by the state under review, normally limited to 20 pages. States are encouraged to prepare it through broad national consultation.
- A compilation of United Nations information, prepared by the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR), normally limited to 10 pages. It draws on treaty bodies, special procedures, and other relevant UN documentation.
- A summary of stakeholders’ submissions, also prepared by OHCHR and normally limited to 10 pages. It draws on contributions from organizations and institutions outside the national government, including civil society organizations and national human rights institutions.
The stakeholder summary is a synthesis rather than a reproduction of all submissions. The three documents provide distinct sources of information; they are not a single agreed account of the country’s situation.
Later cycles place particular emphasis on implementation of earlier recommendations and on developments since the preceding review.
Conduct of the review
Working Group dialogue
The UPR Working Group consists of the Human Rights Council’s 47 member states. Other UN member states may also participate in the dialogue and make recommendations.
Each country review is assisted by a troika of three Council member states selected by lot from different regional groups. The troika helps facilitate the process and prepare its report; it does not act as a panel of judges.
The interactive dialogue normally lasts three and a half hours. The state under review presents its record and responds to questions. Other delegations make statements and recommendations. Recommendations may address legislative change, institutional reform, implementation of existing protections, cooperation with UN mechanisms, or collection of information needed to assess progress.
Civil society organizations and national human rights institutions can attend the Working Group proceedings but do not take the floor during this intergovernmental dialogue.
Recommendations and the outcome
The Working Group adopts a report containing a summary of the proceedings and the recommendations made by participating states. Recommendations are attributed to the states that proposed them; their inclusion does not mean that every participating delegation endorses them.
The state under review indicates which recommendations it supports and which it notes. It can provide explanations, including through a written addendum. The distinction records the state’s position rather than a judicial determination about the validity of a recommendation.
The Human Rights Council subsequently considers and adopts the review outcome in a plenary meeting. At this stage, the state under review, other states, and eligible stakeholders have opportunities to comment under the applicable participation rules.
Implementation and follow-up
Implementation is primarily the responsibility of the state concerned. Depending on the recommendation, it may involve the legislature, ministries, the judiciary, local authorities, or other public institutions.
States may organize implementation through national action plans, interministerial coordination mechanisms, public reporting, and consultations with stakeholders. Some submit voluntary midterm reports between reviews. The following cycle provides an opportunity to examine progress, outstanding difficulties, and recommendations that have not been implemented.
OHCHR and other UN bodies can provide technical assistance. Dedicated voluntary funds support participation in the review and assistance with implementation.
A supported UPR recommendation is generally a political commitment rather than an independently enforceable legal obligation. However, its substance may restate an obligation already binding under international law. Conversely, noting a recommendation does not remove an underlying legal obligation.
Relationship to other human rights mechanisms
The UPR differs from UN human rights treaty bodies, which are committees of independent experts monitoring particular treaties. Treaty-body scrutiny depends on the state’s participation in the relevant treaty framework, whereas the UPR covers all UN member states. For example, the Human Rights Committee monitors the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights; it is distinct from both the Human Rights Council and the UPR Working Group.
The UPR also differs from the Council’s special procedures, whose independent experts address particular themes or country situations. Findings from treaty bodies and special procedures can inform a UPR review, while UPR recommendations can encourage cooperation with those mechanisms.
The UPR does not determine individual complaints, award compensation, or issue binding judgments.
Institutional limits
Universal coverage provides a recurring forum for examining every member state, but the process has important limitations. Recommendations are made by governments rather than independent adjudicators, and they differ in specificity, scope, and measurability. The volume of recommendations does not by itself indicate how much implementation has occurred.
The review also has limited speaking time and relies substantially on written information. Assessing progress requires distinguishing between commitments, formal changes such as adopting legislation, and their practical effects.
There is no automatic UPR sanction for failing to implement a recommendation. The Council’s procedural framework provides for addressing persistent non-cooperation after efforts to encourage participation, but this is distinct from enforcing each recommendation. Follow-up therefore depends substantially on subsequent scrutiny, domestic institutions, public participation, international cooperation, and the state’s own implementation measures.