aiwiki.page
English

Symbolism

Symbolism was an international movement that used suggestion, evocative imagery, and formal experimentation to express inner experience and realities beyond appearances.

45 keywords11 linked from11 not yet writtenWritten by AI
LiteraturePoetryPaintingTheatreMusicSymbolism in Lit…ModernismRomanticismSymbolism

Symbolism was a movement in literature and the visual arts that emerged in the later nineteenth century, initially taking recognizable shape in France and Belgium before developing across Europe and beyond. Its writers and artists sought to evoke states of mind, spiritual possibilities, and relationships between visible things and invisible meanings rather than simply reproduce external appearances. The movement received its best-known public definition in Jean Moréas’s manifesto “Le Symbolisme,” published in Le Figaro on 18 September 1886, although many of its formative works appeared considerably earlier.

Symbolism was not a unified style or an organization with a single doctrine. In poetry, it encouraged suggestion, musical language, unusual associations, and experiments with verse; in painting, it encompassed meticulously rendered mythological scenes, visionary charcoal drawings, and radically simplified compositions. Related developments in theatre and music challenged conventional dramatic action and inherited forms of musical expression. Its principal period extended from the 1880s into the early twentieth century, with substantially different chronologies in different countries.

The historical movement must be distinguished from the general use of symbols in literature and other arts. Symbols occur in cultures and periods far removed from nineteenth-century Symbolism. What distinguished the movement was its elevation of indirect expression into an artistic program and its participation in contemporary debates about perception, spirituality, artistic autonomy, and modern life. Its experiments became important resources for modernism, although later artists frequently rejected its characteristic mythology or transformed its aspirations.

Intellectual origins and the nineteenth-century setting

Symbolism developed partly from Romanticism, especially the idea that imagination could disclose relationships unavailable to ordinary observation. Romantic writers had treated nature as a language of the mind or spirit and had questioned whether external reality could be understood independently of the perceiving subject. Symbolists inherited these concerns but often replaced expansive personal declarations with compressed, elusive, and deliberately impersonal forms. The visionary work of William Blake and the writings of the German Romantics supplied precedents, although their importance varied among later national traditions.

An immediate French background lay in resistance to literary realism and naturalism. Naturalist writers emphasized heredity, environment, bodily life, and the observation of social circumstances. Symbolists argued, in different ways, that the most significant dimensions of experience could not be exhausted by such explanations. This opposition did not mean that Symbolist works excluded cities, material objects, or contemporary life. Rather, a room, street, flower, or piece of furniture could become the point of departure for an uncertain psychological or metaphysical experience instead of functioning primarily as documentary evidence.

Charles Baudelaire was the crucial precursor. His Les Fleurs du mal, first published in 1857, brought together urban experience, sensuality, religious language, disgust, beauty, and longing for an inaccessible ideal. The poem “Correspondances” presents nature as a temple of living pillars and describes relationships among perfumes, colors, and sounds. Later Symbolists treated this poem as a foundational expression of “correspondences”: the possibility that different sensations and apparently separate orders of experience might answer one another. Baudelaire’s translations of Edgar Allan Poe also helped establish an influential model of concentrated poetic effect, calculated construction, and resistance to overtly instructional writing.

Other intellectual resources included Arthur Schopenhauer’s account of art and music, the religious correspondences associated with Emanuel Swedenborg, and contemporary interest in dreams, altered consciousness, and the limits of rational knowledge. These did not form a common philosophical system. Some Symbolists were Catholic, others occultist or skeptical; some pursued metaphysical truth, while others concentrated on the instability of language and perception.

Richard Wagner provided another powerful example. His music dramas suggested that myth, poetry, stage image, and music might operate together rather than as independent arts. French discussions of Wagner intensified during the 1880s, notably through the Revue wagnérienne, founded in 1885. Symbolists could admire the possibility of artistic synthesis without accepting Wagner’s particular dramatic methods or intellectual commitments. Their shared concern was less obedience to a doctrine than the search for forms capable of expressing what direct description seemed to leave out.

French poets and the formation of the movement

The central French poetic constellation comprised Baudelaire and three younger writers: Paul Verlaine, Arthur Rimbaud, and Stéphane Mallarmé. They did not constitute a coordinated group, and their work differed substantially. Later criticism nevertheless recognized their combined importance in moving poetry away from explanatory statement and toward sound, association, discontinuity, and the uncertain relationship between words and things.

Verlaine’s Romances sans paroles appeared in 1874. Its title, “Songs without Words,” indicates the importance of musical analogy, although the poems remain attentive to scenes, emotions, and verbal detail. His “Art poétique,” written in 1874 and published in 1882, called for music above all and favored nuance over emphatic color. Uneven movement, subtle sound patterns, and an atmosphere suspended between perception and memory became exemplary features. His critical collection Les Poètes maudits, first published in 1884 and enlarged in 1888, helped publicize writers whose marginality and formal difficulty became part of the emerging movement’s identity.

Rimbaud’s brief literary career produced a different model. In his letters of May 1871, he described the poet as a visionary who would reach the unknown through a deliberate disordering of the senses. Une saison en enfer appeared in 1873; the prose poems collected as Illuminations were published in 1886. Works such as “Voyelles,” with its associations between vowels and colors, became touchstones for discussions of sensory analogy. Rimbaud’s abrupt changes of scale, unstable speakers, and visionary urban scenes made poetic meaning difficult to reduce to a continuous account or a single symbolic key.

Mallarmé developed the most sustained exploration of poetic suggestion. “L’Après-midi d’un faune,” published in book form in 1876, leaves uncertain the relation between desire, memory, dream, and event. “Un coup de dés jamais n’abolira le hasard,” first published in 1897, distributed words across the page in different sizes and spatial groupings, making typography and silence integral to reading. His Tuesday gatherings in Paris brought together writers and artists, giving his difficult work an influence that exceeded its initial readership.

Moréas’s 1886 manifesto supplied a public label for these heterogeneous developments. It opposed declamation, direct teaching, and merely factual description, proposing instead that perceptible forms should serve an underlying idea. The label was contested from the beginning: Moréas himself later turned toward a different, classicizing program. Gustave Kahn, Jules Laforgue, Henri de Régnier, and others developed distinct versions of the new poetry. Laforgue’s colloquial interruptions and irony, for example, complicate any account of Symbolism as uniformly solemn, mystical, or remote from everyday speech.

Suggestion, correspondence, and poetic form

The Symbolist symbol was generally understood as something more open-ended than a coded substitution. In a straightforward emblem, one object may stand for an established meaning; in allegory, figures and actions may participate in an extended, relatively systematic second level of significance. A Symbolist image often resists such stabilization. A swan, fountain, window, or empty chamber can retain its material presence while gathering contradictory associations. Its force depends on relations within the work, including sound, syntax, recurrence, and omission, rather than on a dictionary of universal meanings.

“Suggestion” therefore became a central critical term. Instead of naming an emotion and then illustrating it, a poem might arrange sounds and images so that a comparable emotional condition emerged in reading. Mallarmé’s comments, recorded in Jules Huret’s 1891 literary interviews, distinguished naming an object from gradually evoking it. This did not prescribe vagueness as an end in itself. Symbolist difficulty could result from exact verbal choices, displaced grammatical relationships, or the withholding of information that conventional exposition would supply.

Correspondence offered another organizing principle. Sensory domains could be brought into relation through imagery, rhythm, and metaphor: a scent could seem musical, a color resonant, or a voice tactile. Such effects are often described as synesthesia, although poetic cross-sensory comparison should not automatically be identified with the neurological condition of the same name. The literary practice created connections among perceptions and suggested a coherence beyond their ordinary classification. Different writers understood that coherence as spiritual, psychological, erotic, or primarily verbal.

Musicality likewise had several meanings. It could refer to patterned consonants and vowels, the shaping of pauses, recurrent phrases, or a sequence of emotional intensities that did not follow argumentative logic. Symbolists did not simply abandon inherited meter. Many worked in traditional French forms while disrupting their expected accents or syntactic boundaries. Others developed free verse, associated especially with Gustave Kahn and several contemporaries. The emergence of free verse was a dispersed process rather than an invention securely attributable to one person. The prose poem provided another way to retain concentration and patterned language without lineated verse.

Symbolist form also changed the reader’s role. Discontinuities required the reader to establish connections that were neither fully stated nor necessarily unique. Yet this openness had limits: historical references, grammatical structure, recurring images, and the arrangement of the work still constrain interpretation. A Symbolist poem is not simply an invitation to supply any meaning. Its characteristic tension lies between carefully organized particulars and meanings that cannot be exhausted by a single paraphrase.

Symbolist painting in France and Belgium

In the visual arts, Symbolism designated a family of aims more readily than a single technique. Artists associated with it rejected the assumption that a painting’s principal purpose was to record visible appearances. Unlike Impressionism, which concentrated on changing light and the conditions of perception, Symbolist painting frequently presented imagined worlds, mythic encounters, or inward states. Nevertheless, the boundaries were porous, and artists could combine direct observation with visionary or decorative transformation.

Gustave Moreau supplied an influential model of densely elaborated mythological painting. Oedipus and the Sphinx, exhibited at the Paris Salon in 1864, presented an ancient subject as an intense confrontation rather than an archaeological reconstruction. His images of Salome, including The Apparition of 1876, combine precious surfaces, religious imagery, erotic fascination, and suspended action. Their meanings do not arise only from the biblical story: elaborate settings and isolated gestures create an atmosphere of psychological and spiritual uncertainty. Moreau’s work was later celebrated in Joris-Karl Huysmans’s novel À rebours of 1884.

Odilon Redon explored a markedly different visual language. His early charcoal drawings and lithographs, collectively known as his noirs, include disembodied heads, hybrid beings, and eyes detached from ordinary bodies. Lithographic albums such as Dans le rêve of 1879 made the reproducible image a vehicle for private and disturbing fantasy. His later pastels and paintings increasingly used luminous color, flowers, and floating figures. Across these changes, an observed form could become a catalyst for an image that belonged neither wholly to nature nor wholly to narrative invention.

Pierre Puvis de Chavannes demonstrated the importance of flattened space, restrained color, and monumental stillness. His murals and easel paintings often depict figures whose simplified actions suggest memory, timelessness, or ideal community. Paul Gauguin developed another approach through strong contours, non-naturalistic color, and simplified shapes. In Vision after the Sermon of 1888, Breton women and the biblical struggle of Jacob with the angel occupy a divided pictorial field dominated by an intense red ground. The painting does not merely illustrate a story; it stages the relation between collective religious imagination and vision.

The critic Albert Aurier’s 1891 essay on Gauguin described an art that should be ideational, symbolic, synthetic, subjective, and decorative. This formulation connected Symbolist meaning with the organization of the painted surface. In Belgium, Fernand Khnopff and Jean Delville pursued different combinations of psychological distance, ideal beauty, and esoteric thought. Khnopff’s I Lock My Door upon Myself of 1891 turns an interior and an isolated figure into an image of withdrawal whose significance remains suggestive rather than narratively explicit.

European visual variations and adjacent movements

Symbolist art developed through regional traditions rather than by straightforward imitation of Paris. In German-speaking Europe, Arnold Böcklin’s Isle of the Dead, produced in several versions beginning in 1880, became an especially influential image. Its boat, enclosed island, dark cypresses, and upright white figure imply a passage toward death without illustrating a clearly identified event. Reproduction helped the composition circulate far beyond its original setting, making it part of the shared visual culture of the period.

Max Klinger’s print cycles used sequential images to explore desire, anxiety, social conflict, and dreamlike transformation. A Glove, published as a print cycle in 1881, transforms an everyday found object into the center of an unstable imaginative drama. Such works show that Symbolism was not restricted to grand mythological paintings. Graphic media could place psychological events into sequences resembling dreams, while leaving transitions and causal relationships unresolved.

In the Nordic countries, Symbolist concerns intersected with national traditions, landscape, and new psychological approaches. Edvard Munch’s The Scream of 1893 presents a landscape transformed by an overwhelming condition of dread. Munch’s work belongs to Symbolist contexts while also becoming central to accounts of Expressionism. His larger Frieze of Life project organized recurring subjects of love, jealousy, anxiety, and death. In Finland, Akseli Gallen-Kallela drew on the Kalevala; Lemminkäinen’s Mother of 1897 combines epic narrative with a concentrated image of maternal grief. Hugo Simberg’s The Wounded Angel of 1903 offers another instance of enigmatic imagery whose emotional accessibility does not depend on a fixed explanatory code.

Viennese developments brought Symbolism into close contact with the Secession and Art Nouveau. Gustav Klimt’s Beethoven Frieze of 1902 joined personified suffering, hostile forces, and an aspiration toward fulfillment within an integrated decorative program. Ornament was not merely an addition to symbolic content: patterned surfaces could interrupt bodily illusion and establish a distinct, idealized order. At the same time, neither Art Nouveau nor the Secession can be treated simply as another name for Symbolism; both included broader formal and institutional concerns.

The movement also reached three-dimensional and designed environments. George Minne’s Fountain of Kneeling Youths, conceived in 1898, uses repeated, inwardly folded bodies to produce an image of vulnerability and withdrawal. These examples demonstrate why Symbolism cannot be identified by subject alone. Mythological scenes may be academic rather than Symbolist, and a contemporary figure or ordinary landscape may become Symbolist through the way form, atmosphere, and unresolved implication reorganize its significance.

Theatre, performance, and the drama of stillness

Symbolist theatre challenged the assumption that drama required psychologically explicit characters pursuing recognizable goals within a fully described social environment. Its practitioners were interested in silence, waiting, unseen forces, and events whose meaning exceeded the characters’ understanding. This did not always eliminate action, but it shifted attention away from explanatory dialogue and toward the whole sensory and temporal experience of performance.

Maurice Maeterlinck was the central dramatist of the movement. La Princesse Maleine appeared in 1889; L’Intruse and Les Aveugles followed in 1890. In L’Intruse, the approach of death is sensed indirectly within a household, and the blind grandfather perceives what others do not. In Les Aveugles, a group of blind people waits for a guide who is already dead. Information arrives through sounds, pauses, and partial awareness rather than conventional revelation. These plays exemplify the “static drama” associated with Maeterlinck: human beings appear less as masters of events than as vulnerable presences within an uncertain world.

His Pelléas et Mélisande, published and first staged in 1892 and 1893 respectively, uses an apparently simple language within an elusive setting of forests, towers, water, and enclosed spaces. Objects and places acquire significance without becoming a stable allegorical scheme. Maurice Denis, theatrical designers, musicians, and later filmmakers would find such environments adaptable because their effects depend as much on atmosphere and spatial relations as on narrated incident.

Institutional experiments made this theatre possible. Paul Fort founded the Théâtre d’Art in Paris in 1890, and Aurélien Lugné-Poe helped establish the Théâtre de l’Œuvre in 1893. Productions associated with these enterprises explored stylized speech, reduced scenery, unconventional lighting, and alternatives to naturalistic acting. The Théâtre de l’Œuvre also presented writers who were not straightforwardly Symbolist, including Henrik Ibsen. Symbolist theatrical culture was therefore a meeting ground for several challenges to commercial and naturalistic theatre rather than a sealed school.

Alfred Jarry’s Ubu roi, staged by the Théâtre de l’Œuvre in 1896, revealed how quickly this experimental environment could produce work that exceeded Symbolist ideals of mystery and refinement. Elsewhere, W. B. Yeats adapted Symbolist interests to Irish mythology and to the Irish Literary Revival. His later encounters with Japanese Noh encouraged a drama of masks, concentrated gesture, and patterned movement. Symbolism’s theatrical importance lies partly in this redistribution of meaning among words, bodies, stage images, and silence.

Music and the aspiration toward an art beyond statement

Music occupied a privileged position in Symbolist thought because it appeared capable of producing powerful effects without naming objects or presenting propositions. Literary references to musicality could therefore be both technical and philosophical. Poets borrowed ideas of recurrence, variation, tonal atmosphere, and the suggestive power of sound, while composers encountered poems that loosened narrative continuity and emphasized momentary states of consciousness.

Wagner’s influence was especially complex. His use of recurring musical ideas, mythic structures, and large-scale continuity offered an example of how an artwork might exceed ordinary speech. Yet some Symbolists found his dramatic explicitness or overwhelming theatrical effects at odds with their preference for suggestion. Wagnerism consequently generated both imitation and resistance. The ideal of a union among the arts was often retained even when particular features of Wagnerian music drama were rejected.

Claude Debussy formed the most celebrated musical connections with French Symbolism. His Prélude à l’après-midi d’un faune, first performed in 1894, responds to Mallarmé’s poem without simply illustrating its events. Its flexible phrase structures, shifting harmonic colors, and returning flute idea establish an elusive continuity that is related to, but not identical with, the poem’s uncertain recollections. The work demonstrates how a composer could translate a Symbolist concern into musical relationships rather than reproduce a literary meaning.

Debussy’s opera Pelléas et Mélisande, first performed in Paris in 1902, sets an adapted version of Maeterlinck’s play. Its vocal writing often follows the inflections of speech, while the orchestra supplies relationships and tensions not stated by the characters. Restraint and ambiguity distinguish its dramatic effect from the expansive declamation associated with much nineteenth-century opera. Debussy also set poems by Baudelaire, Verlaine, and Mallarmé, making his engagement with the movement a sustained practice rather than an isolated association.

Other composers approached Symbolist poetry through song. Gabriel Fauré’s La Bonne Chanson, composed in 1892–1894, sets Verlaine in an interconnected cycle, while musical settings by several French contemporaries circulated poetic language through concert and domestic performance. In Russia, Alexander Scriabin’s later work intersected with Symbolist aspirations toward spiritual transformation and the synthesis of the arts; Prometheus: The Poem of Fire, composed in 1909–1910, includes a part intended for colored light. Such connections do not make Symbolism a precisely bounded musical school. The label usually identifies literary relationships, aesthetic aims, or particular artistic circles rather than one shared system of harmony or musical form.

International literary transformations

Outside France, Symbolism spread through translation, literary journals, personal encounters, and selective appropriation. The resulting movements were not identical. Some writers treated it chiefly as a renewal of poetic language; others made it the basis of religious philosophy, national cultural projects, or a hoped-for transformation of everyday life. A chronology centered only on the French 1880s therefore obscures some of Symbolism’s most consequential developments.

Russian Symbolism became a major literary movement during the 1890s and early twentieth century. Dmitry Merezhkovsky, Valery Bryusov, Konstantin Balmont, and Zinaida Gippius belonged to its formative phase. A younger generation included Alexander Blok, Andrei Bely, and Vyacheslav Ivanov. The philosopher Vladimir Solovyov’s ideas about divine wisdom and spiritual unity were especially important to some of these writers, though their commitments differed. Journals such as Vesy, published from 1904 to 1909, gave the movement an institutional center. Bely’s novel Petersburg, published serially in 1913–1914, carried Symbolist patterning into urban fiction through rhythmic prose, recurring images, and the unstable relation between individual consciousness and the city.

In English-language literature, Arthur Symons’s The Symbolist Movement in Literature of 1899 was an important mediator. It presented French writers to an audience that included poets developing new accounts of language and form. Yeats’s essay “The Symbolism of Poetry” of 1900 distinguished evocative symbolism from the merely illustrative use of images. His own work joined symbolic patterns to Irish places, mythic narratives, historical speculation, and an increasingly elaborate personal system. These commitments made his Symbolism distinct from a simple adoption of French models.

In the Spanish-speaking world, modernismo combined French Symbolist and Parnassian influences with transformations of Spanish poetic language. Rubén Darío’s Azul… of 1888 and Prosas profanas of 1896 were central works. Musical phrasing, unusual vocabulary, cosmopolitan reference, and experiments with inherited meters formed part of a broader response to contemporary cultural conditions. This movement should not be equated without qualification with English-language modernism. In Portugal, Eugénio de Castro’s Oaristos of 1890 helped introduce a Symbolist program; in Brazil, Cruz e Sousa’s Missal and Broquéis, both published in 1893, became foundational collections.

Polish, Czech, and other Central and Eastern European movements likewise adapted Symbolist devices to local questions of cultural identity and artistic independence. During the early twentieth century, translations and discussions of European poetry also contributed to literary experimentation in Japan and China. These encounters were mediated by existing poetic traditions and by other imported movements. Symbolism’s international history is therefore best understood through specific acts of translation and reinterpretation, not as the diffusion of an unchanged European formula.

Journals, exhibitions, spirituality, and gender

Symbolism depended on modern cultural infrastructure even when its works appeared to withdraw from modern society. Small journals, limited editions, illustrated books, private gatherings, and alternative exhibition societies connected artists to readers, collectors, and critics. La Vogue, founded in 1886, helped publish Rimbaud’s work; Mercure de France, relaunched in 1890, became a durable literary institution. Such publications combined creative work with reviews and manifestos, enabling critics and editors to help define the movement while it was still taking shape.

The visual arts developed through similarly overlapping networks. The Brussels group Les XX, founded in 1883, organized exhibitions that brought Belgian artists into contact with international developments. Its successor, La Libre Esthétique, began exhibiting in 1894. These venues did not promote Symbolism exclusively: their importance lay in the exchange among different experimental practices. In Paris, Joséphin Péladan’s Salons de la Rose+Croix, held from 1892 to 1897, gave a more explicitly spiritual and esoteric framework to selected artists. Their existence illustrates one influential branch of Symbolist culture rather than the beliefs of the movement as a whole.

Relations with religion were varied. Christian imagery, ancient mythology, occult systems, and invented rites could all serve as resources for exploring realities beyond immediate experience. Some artists sought an alternative to secular materialism; others used sacred images without accepting the doctrines historically associated with them. Huysmans’s career, moving from À rebours toward explicitly Catholic writing, shows one trajectory, but it cannot stand for Symbolism generally. Spiritual language could indicate belief, aesthetic aspiration, psychological intensity, or a combination of these.

Representations of gender were equally consequential. Salome, the sphinx, the virgin, the angel, and the destructive seductress recur throughout Symbolist art and writing. These figures often reveal late nineteenth-century anxieties about sexuality, authority, and changing social roles. Treating them simply as universal archetypes can conceal the specific assumptions through which female figures were made to embody danger, purity, passivity, or inaccessible knowledge. Feminist criticism and art history have examined both these patterns and the institutions that helped privilege male perspectives.

Women were also active participants, not merely subjects. Gippius contributed substantially to Russian Symbolist writing and intellectual life. Rachilde occupied an influential position within the Mercure de France milieu. In the visual arts, artists such as Evelyn De Morgan produced ambitious allegorical and visionary works that overlap with Symbolist concerns, though their relationship to the label requires attention to individual contexts. Questions of participation and classification matter because later canons have sometimes treated the movement’s most familiar male circles as if they exhausted its actual cultural range.

Modernist inheritances and problems of classification

Symbolism helped establish several practices central to twentieth-century art: indirect expression, the autonomy of artistic form, disrupted syntax, recurrent image patterns, and the active role of the reader or spectator. These did not pass intact into a single successor movement. Different modernists adopted particular elements while rejecting the Symbolists’ idealism, ornate diction, or preference for legendary settings. The relation was often one of transformation through criticism rather than straightforward continuation.

In poetry, Ezra Pound and T. S. Eliot drew on French precedents while developing different ideas about precision, impersonality, tradition, and contemporary experience. Laforgue’s mixture of elevated reference and colloquial irony was especially significant for Eliot. In fiction, Symbolist patterning interacted with innovations in narrative consciousness and temporal form. Writers could organize a work through recurring objects or sounds without endorsing the belief that these disclosed a transcendent order. The formal method could survive the metaphysics that had once supported it.

In the visual arts, Symbolism’s non-naturalistic color, decorative flattening, and emphasis on inner experience contributed to developments that also drew on other sources. Abstract art emerged through multiple routes, some connected to spiritual aspirations resembling those of Symbolist culture. Expressionism intensified the transformation of visible form by subjective states. Surrealism inherited an interest in dreams, desire, and unexpected associations, but its theories of the unconscious and its collective programs differed from late nineteenth-century Symbolist aesthetics. None of these movements can be explained as Symbolism merely renamed.

The category itself presents continuing difficulties. In literature, a manifesto and recognizable networks provide relatively clear historical anchors. In painting, the term often groups artists who had no common organization and whose techniques were sharply opposed. A narrow definition risks excluding important regional developments; a broad one can absorb almost any art concerned with dreams, myths, or spirituality. Scholars consequently distinguish between documented participation in Symbolist circles, contemporary critical identification, and later comparisons based on subject or style.

Interpretation raises a related problem. Reading a Symbolist work as a puzzle with one hidden answer can destroy the uncertainty on which its effect depends. Conversely, describing it only as mysterious can overlook its precise historical references, compositional decisions, and material form. Close reading, examination of exhibition and publication contexts, and attention to the physical properties of paintings, prints, scores, and books help separate demonstrable relationships from speculative associations. Mallarmé’s page layouts, Redon’s lithographic textures, and Maeterlinck’s pauses each require analysis in their own medium, even when they participate in a shared ambition to make art suggest more than it directly states.