Mass defect is the amount by which the mass of a bound system is smaller than the sum of the masses of its constituents when separated and at rest. The term is used especially in nuclear physics, where an atomic nucleus has less mass than its constituent protons and neutrons would have as free particles. Through mass–energy equivalence, this difference corresponds to the energy required to separate the system into those constituents. It is not a disappearance of matter or a failure of energy conservation, but a consequence of the lower total energy of a bound state.
Definition and physical basis
For a nucleus containing protons and neutrons, the nuclear mass defect is conventionally defined as
where and are the masses of a free proton and neutron, and is the rest mass of the nucleus. The number is its atomic number, and is its mass number.
The corresponding nuclear binding energy is
where is the speed of light in vacuum. For a nucleus bound relative to complete separation into free nucleons, both and are positive.
The underlying principle comes from special relativity: a system’s rest mass measures its total energy in its center-of-momentum frame. This energy includes constituent rest energies, internal motion, and interactions. Nuclear binding results from the combined contributions of the nuclear interaction, associated with the strong interaction, electromagnetic repulsion between protons, and the quantum behavior of the nucleons.
A bound nucleus has a lower total energy than the same nucleons separated at rest. If free nucleons form that nucleus, the excess energy must be carried away, for example by radiation or other reaction products. Conversely, complete separation requires an input of energy equal to the binding energy.
Nuclear masses and atomic masses
Experimental tables commonly list the masses of neutral atoms, rather than bare nuclei. An atomic mass includes the masses of its electrons and the negative contribution from their electronic binding energy. Consequently, atomic and nuclear masses must not be used interchangeably without accounting for electrons.
A convenient expression using neutral atomic masses is
where is the mass of a neutral hydrogen-1 atom and is the mass of the neutral atom under consideration. The electron rest masses cancel because the reference hydrogen atoms and the final atom contain the same total number of electrons.
This expression neglects the difference between the electronic binding energy of the final atom and that of the reference hydrogen atoms. That correction is usually small compared with nuclear binding energies, but it matters in sufficiently precise calculations.
Nuclear masses are often expressed in the unified atomic mass unit, symbol , defined as one twelfth of the mass of a free, neutral carbon-12 atom at rest and in its ground state. Its energy equivalent is approximately
The megaelectronvolt, or MeV, is one million electronvolts.
Example: helium-4
A helium-4 nucleus contains two protons and two neutrons. Using rounded atomic masses,
and
gives
The corresponding binding energy is approximately
Dividing by four gives about per nucleon. The atomic mass defect in this calculation is approximately of the summed masses of the reference hydrogen atoms and neutrons.
Binding energy and nuclear reactions
Binding energy per nucleon
The total mass defect generally increases with the number of nucleons, so total binding energy alone is not a useful measure for comparing nuclei of very different sizes. Binding energy per nucleon,
provides a more informative comparison.
It rises rapidly among many light nuclei, reaches a broad maximum in the iron–nickel region, and then decreases gradually for heavier nuclei. Nickel-62 has one of the highest binding energies per nucleon. This pattern helps explain why both nuclear fusion of light nuclei and nuclear fission of sufficiently heavy nuclei can release energy: their products can have greater total binding energy than their reactants.
The curve does not by itself determine whether a particular reaction occurs. Reaction pathways, conservation laws, energy barriers, and reaction rates also matter. Nor does high binding energy per nucleon alone establish stability against every possible mode of radioactive decay.
Reaction energy
For a reaction, the energy available from a change in rest mass is expressed by its -value:
All masses must be defined consistently, with electrons and other particles properly accounted for. A positive -value indicates that energy is available for kinetic energy, radiation, or other permitted forms of excitation. A negative -value means that energy must be supplied.
A reaction’s mass difference is not the same quantity as the mass defect of one nucleus. It compares complete initial and final states and, for reactions involving unchanged nucleon totals, can be related to their difference in total binding energy.
Conservation of mass and energy
Mass defect is sometimes described as mass being “converted into energy.” This is useful shorthand, but it can obscure the accounting of the complete system.
If a nucleus forms and an emitted photon escapes, the remaining material system has lost energy and therefore rest mass. If the photon and all reaction products remain inside an ideal isolated container, the total energy—and hence the rest mass of the complete system in its center-of-momentum frame—remains unchanged.
Thus, the sum of individual particle rest masses need not be conserved, while total energy and momentum are conserved. A collection of moving particles or radiation can have a nonzero system mass even when some constituents have zero rest mass.
The everyday principle of conservation of mass remains an excellent approximation for ordinary chemical processes because their energy changes correspond to extremely small mass differences.
Measurement and historical development
Mass defect became quantitatively accessible through precise mass spectrometry. Early twentieth-century measurements, notably those associated with Francis William Aston, established accurate isotopic masses and revealed systematic departures from simple whole-number expectations.
Einstein’s 1905 mass–energy relation supplied the theoretical connection between mass differences and energy. Subsequent measurements of nuclear masses and reaction energies established mass defect as a quantitative foundation of nuclear physics.
Modern mass measurements use techniques including Penning traps and storage rings. Mass data for different isotopes are used to calculate separation energies, test nuclear models, and determine which reactions and decay processes are energetically possible. They are also important in models of stellar nucleosynthesis.
Related but distinct quantities
Mass excess is not nuclear mass defect. It is commonly defined as
It measures an atom’s mass relative to its integer mass number expressed in atomic mass units, rather than relative to free constituent particles. Mass excess may be positive or negative; carbon-12 has zero atomic mass excess by definition.
In analytical mass spectrometry, mass defect can instead mean the difference between a species’ exact mass and its nominal integer mass. This convention is useful in molecular identification and should not be confused with the nuclear binding-energy definition.
The underlying physics also applies beyond nuclei. A bound molecule has a slightly smaller rest mass than its separated constituent atoms when they are compared in specified states. Excitation or heating increases a system’s mass by increasing its internal energy. These changes are far smaller than typical nuclear mass defects because chemical and thermal energies are much smaller than nuclear binding energies.