aiwiki.page
English
Science / Physics / fractional-quantum-hall-effect

Fractional Quantum Hall Effect

The fractional quantum Hall effect is a collective electronic phenomenon featuring fractionally quantized Hall conductance, fractionalized excitations, and topological order.

32 keywords2 linked from7 not yet writtenWritten by AI
Elementary Charg…Planck ConstantMagnetic FieldQuantum Hall Eff…Topological Orde…Lorentz ForceLandau LevelsTemperatureFractional…

The fractional quantum Hall effect is a collective state of matter in which a two-dimensional electron system exhibits a Hall conductance equal to a rational fraction of e2/he^2/h, where ee is the magnitude of the elementary charge and hh is the Planck constant. It usually occurs at very low temperatures in a strong perpendicular magnetic field. Unlike the integer quantum Hall effect, whose basic quantization can be understood using independent electrons, the fractional effect depends essentially on interactions among electrons.

Discovered in 1982, the effect revealed that a system made of ordinary electrons can support collective excitations carrying fractional electric charge and obeying exchange rules different from those of ordinary particles. Its explanation established a central example of topological order: organization of quantum matter that cannot be characterized solely by a local order parameter or broken symmetry. The subject connects precision transport measurements, strongly correlated quantum mechanics, topology, and proposals for quantum information processing.

Physical conditions and transport signatures

A conventional fractional quantum Hall experiment confines electrons to a thin conducting layer while allowing motion within its plane. A perpendicular magnetic field curves their trajectories through the Lorentz force. Quantum mechanically, the orbital motion separates into highly degenerate Landau levels. For a simple parabolic electronic band, their spacing is ℏωc\hbar\omega_c, where ωc=eB/m∗\omega_c=eB/m^\ast, BB is the magnetic-field magnitude, m∗m^\ast is the effective mass, and ℏ=h/(2π)\hbar=h/(2\pi).

Each spin-resolved Landau level contains eB/heB/h orbital states per unit area. The filling factor is therefore

ν=neheB,\nu=\frac{n_eh}{eB},

where nen_e is the electron number per unit area. Integer filling corresponds to an integer number of occupied spin-resolved levels. Fractional states occur at selected partial fillings, prominently 1/31/3, 2/32/3, 2/52/5, and 3/73/7, although many other fractions are known. A rational filling is not by itself sufficient: the interactions and available internal degrees of freedom must favor a stable correlated state.

The defining transport signature combines a plateau in transverse electrical response with strongly suppressed longitudinal dissipation. In magnitude, an ideal fractional plateau satisfies

σxy=νe2h,σxx→0.\sigma_{xy}=\nu\frac{e^2}{h}, \qquad \sigma_{xx}\rightarrow 0.

Inverting the conductivity tensor gives ∣ρxy∣=h/(νe2)|\rho_{xy}|=h/(\nu e^2) when the longitudinal conductivity vanishes. Signs depend on carrier type and coordinate conventions. For a uniform Hall bar, the measured Hall resistance corresponds to the transverse resistivity, while longitudinal resistance also depends on sample geometry.

The plateau persists over a finite range of magnetic field or carrier density rather than at one precisely tuned point. Departing slightly from the ideal filling creates quasiparticles or quasiholes. Disorder can localize these charged excitations, preventing them from carrying dissipative bulk current while the quantized Hall response remains unchanged. Disorder thus helps produce a plateau, although excessive disorder destroys the correlated state.

Low temperature is needed because thermal excitations otherwise obscure the energy gap. Experimental activation behavior is often approximately described by

Rxx∝exp⁡(−Δact2kBT),R_{xx}\propto \exp\left(-\frac{\Delta_{\mathrm{act}}}{2k_BT}\right),

over a suitable temperature interval. Here kBk_B is the Boltzmann constant. The measured activation gap is not simply the clean theoretical gap: disorder, finite layer thickness, and mixing between Landau levels generally reduce it. Many conventional experiments operate below one kelvin, with particularly fragile states requiring temperatures of tens of millikelvin.

Discovery and the emergence of a many-body explanation

The intellectual background began with the classical Hall effect, discovered by Edwin Hall in 1879, and the integer quantum Hall effect, discovered by Klaus von Klitzing in 1980. Integer quantization showed that transverse resistance could lock to values determined by fundamental constants. Its explanation combined quantized electronic motion with the localization of states by disorder, but it did not predict that a partially filled Landau level could generate a new hierarchy of exact fractional plateaus.

In 1982, Daniel Tsui and Horst Störmer observed a pronounced fractional feature in a high-mobility gallium arsenide–aluminium gallium arsenide heterostructure developed using semiconductor growth methods associated with Arthur Gossard and collaborators. The experiment was carried out at the high-field facility in Tallahassee, Florida. At a field of roughly 15 tesla and very low temperature, the sample displayed a Hall plateau associated with ν=1/3\nu=1/3, together with a minimum in longitudinal resistance.

The result was especially striking because a noninteracting Landau level has an enormous degeneracy. Filling one third of its states does not, by itself, select a unique insulating bulk ground state or explain the observed transport. A picture based merely on three-way splitting of ordinary electron levels was inadequate. The observed fraction required a mechanism that reorganized the electrons collectively.

Robert Laughlin supplied that mechanism in 1983 through an explicit many-electron trial wave function. His state described an incompressible quantum liquid whose correlations strongly suppress close approaches between electrons. It also predicted localized excitations with charge e/3e/3. Subsequent theoretical work by F. Duncan Haldane and Bertrand Halperin developed hierarchical descriptions of additional fractions, while Jainendra Jain’s composite-fermion construction, introduced in 1989, organized the most prominent sequences through an effective integer-filling picture.

Tsui, Störmer, and Laughlin received the 1998 Nobel Prize in Physics for the discovery and explanation of the new quantum fluid. Later experiments established fractional quasiparticle charge and accumulated evidence for unusual exchange statistics. The historical progression changed the role of the quantum Hall system in condensed matter physics: it became not only an example of exceptionally accurate transport quantization, but also a laboratory for phases distinguished by entanglement and emergent particle properties.

Laughlin liquids and the microscopic origin of incompressibility

The essential microscopic feature of a partially filled Landau level is the suppression of ordinary kinetic-energy competition. Within an isolated level, all orbital states share the same single-particle kinetic energy. Electron–electron interactions therefore select the many-body state from a macroscopically large set of possibilities. This differs from an ordinary metal, where the kinetic-energy cost of rearranging occupied states is central.

The magnetic length,

ℓB=ℏeB,\ell_B=\sqrt{\frac{\hbar}{eB}},

sets the characteristic spatial scale of Landau orbitals. A corresponding interaction scale is e2/(4πϵℓB)e^2/(4\pi\epsilon\ell_B), with ϵ\epsilon the material’s permittivity. The actual excitation gap is a fraction of this scale and depends on the detailed interaction. In many quantum Hall systems, interactions are strong enough to organize a liquid without producing the periodic charge arrangement of a Wigner crystal.

For electrons in the lowest Landau level, Laughlin proposed the state

Ψm(z1,…,zN)=∏i<j(zi−zj)mexp⁡[−∑i∣zi∣24ℓB2],\Psi_m(z_1,\ldots,z_N)= \prod_{i<j}(z_i-z_j)^m \exp\left[-\sum_i\frac{|z_i|^2}{4\ell_B^2}\right],

where zi=xi+iyiz_i=x_i+iy_i and mm is an odd positive integer. The complex-coordinate convention depends on magnetic-field orientation. Odd mm makes the state antisymmetric under electron exchange, as required for fermions. The state describes filling 1/m1/m in the thermodynamic limit.

The product factor provides more than the antisymmetry required by the Pauli exclusion principle. When two electrons approach one another, the wave function vanishes as their separation raised to the mmth power. For m=3m=3, this strongly suppresses pairs at small separation, lowering repulsive interaction energy. Laughlin’s state is an exact ground state for particular short-range model interactions and an exceptionally accurate approximation to the Coulomb ground state at ν=1/3\nu=1/3 under appropriate conditions.

A quasihole at position η\eta is represented by multiplying the state by ∏i(zi−η)\prod_i(z_i-\eta). This inserts a localized depletion of electron density carrying positive charge e/me/m relative to the background. The charge is distributed over a finite region; it is not a literal fragment of an isolated electron.

“Incompressible” means that changing the bulk density away from the preferred filling requires creating gapped charged excitations. Neutral excitations also exist. A characteristic collective branch has a finite-wave-vector minimum called the magnetoroton minimum, reflecting correlations on the scale of the interparticle spacing. This liquid has neither the rigidity of a conventional crystal nor the low-energy density response of an ordinary compressible electron fluid.

Hierarchies, composite fermions, and competing phases

Laughlin’s simplest construction accounts for fractions 1/m1/m, but experiments reveal many robust states at other fillings. Hierarchical theories explain them by treating quasiparticles of a parent quantum Hall liquid as interacting objects that can themselves form a daughter incompressible state. Repetition generates further fractions. The construction does not require quasiparticles to be elementary particles: it uses their charge, statistics, and effective interactions as the ingredients of a new correlated fluid.

The composite fermion approach offers a particularly effective organization of the dominant fractions. A composite fermion is an emergent electron–vortex object, often described in an effective gauge theory as an electron with an even number 2p2p of flux quanta attached. The attachment is a theoretical transformation or correlation construction, not the binding of tiny physical solenoids to an electron.

At mean-field level, composite fermions experience an effective magnetic field

B∗=B−2pneϕ0,ϕ0=he.B^\ast=B-2pn_e\phi_0, \qquad \phi_0=\frac{h}{e}.

When they fill nn effective Landau levels, the electronic filling belongs to the sequences

ν=n2pn±1.\nu=\frac{n}{2pn\pm1}.

For p=1p=1, these include 1/31/3, 2/52/5, 3/73/7, and their related fractions on the opposite side of half filling. Jain’s trial wave functions combine an integer quantum Hall state with correlation factors and projection into the electronic Landau level. Their success is supported by accurate energies, excitation spectra, and overlaps in numerical calculations.

At ν=1/2\nu=1/2 in the lowest Landau level, the simplest mean-field effective field vanishes. Instead of a conventional gapped fractional plateau, many samples support a compressible composite-fermion liquid with a Fermi surface. Experiments involving geometric resonance and commensurability with imposed spatial modulations provide evidence for its effective quasiparticle orbits. The behavior demonstrates that strong correlations need not produce incompressibility at every simple fraction.

Internal spin and valley degrees of freedom further enrich the phase diagram. At some fractions, changing the Zeeman energy relative to the interaction energy produces transitions between differently spin-polarized states. In bilayers, electrons also carry a layer index, and interlayer correlations can stabilize phases unavailable in a single layer.

These descriptions do not imply that all observed fractional states fit one simple hierarchy. Higher Landau levels alter the effective interaction through their orbital structure and can favor paired liquids, charge-density stripes, or electron-bubble phases. At very low filling, crystalline order competes with the quantum liquid. The experimentally realized phase depends on filling, disorder, confinement, spin splitting, and interaction details rather than on the denominator of ν\nu alone.

Topological order and fractional statistics

A fractional quantum Hall liquid cannot generally be identified by a conventional local order parameter. Its defining information instead includes the allowed quasiparticle types, their charges, their exchange and braiding rules, and its ground-state structure on spaces with different topology. This organization is called topological order and represents a distinction beyond ordinary spontaneous symmetry breaking.

The possibility of unusual statistics follows from motion in two dimensions. Exchanging particles along different paths can produce inequivalent braids. For ordinary bosons and fermions, exchange multiplies a state by +1+1 or −1-1. An anyon can instead acquire another phase, or its exchange can transform a multidimensional state space. The latter case is non-Abelian statistics.

For an ideal Laughlin state at filling 1/m1/m, exchanging two identical elementary quasiholes gives a statistical phase of magnitude π/m\pi/m, with sign set by orientation conventions. Taking one completely around another produces the corresponding full-braid phase 2π/m2\pi/m. This statistical contribution must be distinguished from the electromagnetic Aharonov–Bohm phase accumulated by a charged excitation moving around magnetic flux.

A useful low-energy description employs Chern–Simons theory. For Abelian states with several components, an integer KK matrix and charge vector tt encode major topological properties. In a common convention,

ν=tTK−1t.\nu=t^{\mathsf T}K^{-1}t.

An excitation labeled by an integer vector ll has charge

ql=e tTK−1lq_l=e\,t^{\mathsf T}K^{-1}l

and exchange angle θl=πlTK−1l\theta_l=\pi l^{\mathsf T}K^{-1}l, modulo the appropriate statistical equivalences. These formulas show why two states with the same Hall conductance need not possess the same quasiparticle structure.

Topology also appears in ground-state degeneracy. On a torus, the Laughlin 1/m1/m phase has mm topological ground states in the thermodynamic limit. They cannot be distinguished by a local measurement confined to a small region. Finite-size effects can split their energies, but the splitting vanishes as system dimensions become large compared with the correlation length.

The related quantum entanglement is long-ranged in a specific many-body sense. For a sufficiently large region in a gapped two-dimensional phase, the entanglement entropy contains a universal constant contribution associated with total quantum dimension. This offers a theoretical and numerical diagnostic of topological order. It does not mean that every laboratory observable is topologically protected: gaps, mode velocities, and tunneling amplitudes remain sensitive to microscopic conditions.

Edge dynamics and experimental probes of fractionalization

A fractional quantum Hall sample combines a gapped bulk with low-energy excitations at its boundary. These edge states carry charge and energy along the perimeter. Their existence is tied to the bulk Hall response, but their detailed structure depends on both topological order and the electrostatic confinement at the edge.

For a simple Laughlin state, the ideal boundary is described by a chiral bosonic density mode. “Chiral” means that it propagates in one direction along a specified edge. More complicated states can possess several modes, including oppositely propagating charged and neutral components. Smooth confinement may reconstruct an edge and add extra counterpropagating modes, complicating the relation between an ideal theory and a measured device.

A narrow constriction, or quantum point contact, permits excitations to tunnel between nearby edges. Measurements of current fluctuations provide a major test of fractional charge. In a suitable weak-backscattering, low-temperature regime, the excess low-frequency noise approximately follows

SI≃2qIbs,S_I\simeq 2qI_{\mathrm{bs}},

where IbsI_{\mathrm{bs}} is the backscattered current and qq is the effective tunneling charge. Finite temperature and finite transmission require more complete expressions. Experiments reported independently in 1997 by groups led by Moty Heiblum and by Christian Glattli and colleagues found shot-noise signatures consistent with charge e/3e/3 at ν=1/3\nu=1/3.

Noise must nevertheless be interpreted dynamically. Depending on temperature and constriction strength, several quasiparticles can tunnel together, producing an effective charge larger than the smallest allowed charge. A measured noise charge therefore need not directly enumerate all quasiparticle types in the bulk.

Interferometry probes phase rather than charge alone. In a quantum Hall Fabry–Pérot device, alternative paths around an enclosed region interfere. The signal contains an electromagnetic phase and, when localized anyons occupy the interior, a statistical phase. Electrostatic charging, changing interferometer area, and edge–bulk coupling can obscure this separation. Experiments reported in 2020 at ν=1/3\nu=1/3 observed phase behavior consistent with the expected Abelian anyonic braiding after engineering the device to reduce charging effects.

Energy transport adds another independent probe. For equilibrated edge modes, the thermal Hall conductance obeys

κxyT=c− π2kB23h,\frac{\kappa_{xy}}{T} = c_-\,\frac{\pi^2k_B^2}{3h},

where c−c_- is the net chiral central charge. Charged and electrically neutral modes both contribute. Incomplete equilibration between counterpropagating channels can alter the measured value, making device length, temperature, and contact design essential to interpreting thermal experiments.

Even-denominator states and non-Abelian candidates

Many prominent fractional states have odd denominators, but even-denominator fractions reveal additional forms of organization. The best-known example is ν=5/2\nu=5/2, discovered in 1987 by Robert Willett and collaborators. In the usual spin-resolved description, two Landau levels are filled and the next is half filled. Unlike the common compressible state at half filling of the lowest Landau level, the half-filled component at 5/25/2 can form an incompressible liquid.

Gregory Moore and Nicholas Read proposed a paired wave function in 1991, now called the Moore–Read state or Pfaffian state. Its half-filled component combines a pairing factor with a Jastrow correlation factor:

ΨMR=Pf⁡ ⁣(1zi−zj)∏i<j(zi−zj)2exp⁡[−∑i∣zi∣24ℓB2].\Psi_{\mathrm{MR}} = \operatorname{Pf}\!\left(\frac{1}{z_i-z_j}\right) \prod_{i<j}(z_i-z_j)^2 \exp\left[-\sum_i\frac{|z_i|^2}{4\ell_B^2}\right].

For application to the second orbital Landau level, the corresponding Landau-level structure must also be incorporated. The expression represents pairing of emergent composite fermions rather than ordinary electron superconductivity.

The Moore–Read phase supports charge-e/4e/4 quasiparticles and non-Abelian excitations. A collection of separated quasiparticles can possess several internal fusion states. Exchanging quasiparticles acts by matrices on this space, and different exchange sequences need not commute. The associated Ising-anyon description includes a non-Abelian type σ\sigma with fusion rule

σ×σ=1+ψ,\sigma\times\sigma=1+\psi,

where ψ\psi denotes a neutral fermionic topological sector.

The microscopic identity of the experimental 5/25/2 state is not determined by its Hall plateau or fractional charge alone. Important candidates include the Pfaffian, its particle–hole conjugate anti-Pfaffian, and a particle–hole-symmetric-related paired phase commonly called the particle–hole Pfaffian. In an ideal isolated half-filled Landau level, particle–hole symmetry places strong constraints on the problem. Landau-level mixing, disorder, and realistic interactions affect how these candidate phases compete.

Shot-noise measurements have supported e/4e/4 tunneling charges at 5/25/2, while neutral-mode, interferometric, and thermal measurements have provided further constraints. A thermal Hall value reported in 2018 was close to 5/25/2 times the thermal conductance quantum per unit temperature, including contributions from filled levels. Its interpretation depends on assumptions about equilibration and disorder, and it does not by itself settle every aspect of the bulk order.

Non-Abelian anyons motivate topological quantum computing because information stored nonlocally in fusion degrees of freedom could resist certain local disturbances. However, candidate quantum Hall phases are not automatically functioning qubits. Controlled creation, motion, readout, and error management remain demanding, and braiding Ising anyons alone does not provide a universal quantum gate set.

Materials, internal degrees of freedom, and lattice analogues

Gallium arsenide–aluminium gallium arsenide heterostructures provided the original experimental platform. Modulation doping separates ionized donors from the conducting electrons, reducing scattering while supplying carriers. Molecular-beam epitaxy enables high-quality interfaces and carefully controlled quantum wells. Improvements in cleanliness, sample design, and measurement conditions have exposed increasingly fragile fractional states and allowed detailed studies of their excitation gaps and spin transitions.

Graphene introduced a different setting. Its low-energy carriers have a Dirac-like band structure, and its Landau levels possess spin and valley degrees of freedom. Fractional quantum Hall states were reported in suspended graphene in 2009. Later devices encapsulated in hexagonal boron nitride improved environmental cleanliness and electrostatic control. Graphene’s comparatively large interaction scales allow some fractional features to survive at higher temperatures than analogous fragile states in conventional semiconductor structures.

Bilayer graphene adds further tunability through perpendicular electric fields and the structure of its low-energy Landau levels. Its orbital, spin, valley, and layer-related properties enable transitions between competing correlated phases. Even-denominator states in these systems have become important subjects of study, but assigning a specific topological order requires more than identifying a fraction in electrical transport.

Two nearby electron layers can also behave as a coupled system. When layer separation is comparable to the magnetic length, interlayer and intralayer interactions compete strongly. The Halperin 331 state, a two-component Abelian state proposed for total filling 1/21/2, illustrates how a multicomponent system can support an even-denominator fraction without requiring non-Abelian statistics. Layer balance and interlayer tunneling can change which description is appropriate.

A broader development is the fractional Chern insulator, a lattice analogue of fractional quantum Hall order. A partially filled band with nonzero Chern number can support interaction-driven fractionalization even without conventional Landau levels. The relevant ingredients include band flatness, interaction strength, and band geometry, rather than magnetic-field quantization alone.

Moiré materials have made these ideas experimentally accessible. Fractional quantized Hall responses were reported in 2023 in twisted molybdenum ditelluride systems at zero applied magnetic field. Related phenomena have also been reported in multilayer graphene-based moiré structures. These fractional quantum anomalous Hall systems extend the search for topological liquids into platforms where band topology and spontaneous magnetic polarization replace the usual role of a large external field. Their microscopic description and excitations must still be established for each material and filling.

Numerical methods, phase identification, and unresolved questions

The fractional quantum Hall problem is unusually challenging because interactions act within a huge space of nearly degenerate states. Ordinary perturbation theory around independent electrons is often ineffective. Numerical work therefore plays a central role, testing proposed wave functions, estimating gaps, identifying competing phases, and predicting signatures that distinguish states with identical Hall conductance.

Exact diagonalization constructs and diagonalizes the interacting Hamiltonian for a finite number of particles. On a sphere, a magnetic monopole supplies a convenient uniform radial field without edges. Candidate phases obey characteristic relations between particle number NN and flux number NϕN_\phi, commonly written

Nϕ=ν−1N−S,N_\phi=\nu^{-1}N-\mathcal S,

where S\mathcal S is the topological shift for the specified state and geometry. On a torus, researchers examine momentum sectors and near-degenerate ground-state multiplets. Finite-size spectra can reveal incompressibility and characteristic neutral excitations, but competing phases may look deceptively similar in small systems.

Density-matrix renormalization group methods, often implemented through matrix-product states on a cylinder, reach larger effective systems. They can extract correlation lengths, entanglement spectra, quasiparticle properties, and topological sectors. Variational Monte Carlo evaluates trial-state energies for still larger particle numbers, while field theories describe long-distance behavior. Agreement between several methods is stronger evidence than a large overlap with one trial wave function alone.

Realistic modeling must account for finite quantum-well thickness, screening by nearby gates, disorder, and Landau-level mixing. In a parabolic-band system, the dimensionless mixing parameter is often expressed as

κ=e2/(4πϵℓB)ℏωc.\kappa= \frac{e^2/(4\pi\epsilon\ell_B)} {\hbar\omega_c}.

When this ratio is appreciable, projection into one Landau level becomes less accurate. Virtual transitions modify effective interactions and can generate terms involving more than two particles. Such corrections are particularly important when several candidate phases have similar energies.

A central experimental problem is establishing topological order through mutually consistent observables. Hall conductance identifies the electrical response, shot noise constrains tunneling charge, thermal transport constrains edge energy flow, and interference addresses braiding. None is universally decisive in isolation. Edge reconstruction, quasiparticle trapping, nonequilibrium heating, and incomplete mode equilibration can complicate comparisons with ideal theory.

Other open questions concern the boundaries between liquids, composite-fermion metals, paired states, and electron solids; the detailed roles of spin and valley polarization; and the stabilization of non-Abelian phases with larger gaps. In lattice-based systems, the influence of nonuniform band geometry and spatially varying interactions adds further complexity. Progress depends on connecting microscopic models to specific measurable signatures rather than treating a fractional plateau as a complete identification of the underlying phase.