Formal charge is an electron-counting quantity assigned to an atom in a Lewis structure, calculated by treating the electrons in each bond as equally shared between the bonded atoms. It compares the number of electrons assigned to that atom with the number of valence electrons in the corresponding neutral, isolated atom. Formal charge helps describe the distribution of electrons in a structural representation, evaluate alternative Lewis structures, and track changes during reactions. It is not generally the actual electric charge localized on an atom.
Definition and calculation
The formal charge of an atom is
where:
- is the number of valence electrons in the neutral, isolated atom;
- is the number of nonbonding electrons assigned to the atom, including lone-pair electrons and any unpaired electrons;
- is the total number of bonding electrons in all bonds involving the atom.
The result is conventionally written as an integer, such as , , or , with the elementary charge understood as the charge unit.
In an ordinary Lewis structure, a single bond contains two electrons, a double bond four, and a triple bond six. The equation can therefore also be written
where is the bond order of each bond attached to the atom in that particular structure. A double bond contributes two to this sum, not one.
The equal division of bonding electrons is a bookkeeping convention: it applies regardless of the electronegativities of the atoms. All nonbonding electrons, by contrast, are assigned entirely to the atom on which they are drawn.
For example, the oxygen atom in water has six valence electrons, four nonbonding electrons, and four bonding electrons:
Each hydrogen atom also has formal charge zero.
Relationship to total molecular or ionic charge
The sum of all atomic formal charges equals the net charge of the molecule or ion:
where is expressed in elementary-charge units. Each bonding electron is assigned once overall because it is divided equally between its two bonded atoms.
Consequently:
- A neutral species has a formal-charge sum of zero, although individual atoms may carry nonzero formal charges.
- A singly charged cation has a formal-charge sum of .
- A doubly charged anion has a formal-charge sum of .
This identity is a useful check on a proposed structure. A correct total is necessary, but it does not by itself establish that the bonding arrangement or electron count is chemically appropriate.
Examples
| Species and Lewis representation | Atom considered | Calculation | Formal charge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Water, | O: two single bonds, two lone pairs | ||
| [[ammonia | Ammonia]], | N: three single bonds, one lone pair | |
| Ammonium, | N: four single bonds, no lone pair | ||
| Hydroxide, | O: one single bond, three lone pairs | ||
| [[carbon-dioxide | Carbon dioxide]], | C: two double bonds | |
| Carbon monoxide, , with one lone pair on each atom | C | ||
| The same carbon monoxide structure | O |
Carbon monoxide illustrates an important limitation of simple preferences about charge placement. Its usual octet-satisfying Lewis structure places negative formal charge on carbon and positive formal charge on oxygen, even though oxygen is more electronegative. Formal-charge guidelines must therefore be considered alongside electron-shell requirements and other bonding evidence.
For common closed-shell structures in organic chemistry, several patterns are especially useful:
- Carbon with four bonds and no lone pair has formal charge zero.
- Carbon with three single bonds and no nonbonding electrons has formal charge .
- Carbon with three single bonds and one lone pair has formal charge .
- Nitrogen with three bonds and one lone pair is formally neutral; nitrogen with four single bonds is formally .
- Oxygen with two bonds and two lone pairs is formally neutral; oxygen with one bond and three lone pairs is formally .
These patterns depend on the complete electron arrangement. The number of bonds alone is not sufficient to determine formal charge, particularly for species containing unpaired electrons.
Choosing between Lewis structures
Formal charges help compare possible Lewis structures for a fixed arrangement of atomic nuclei. Common guidelines favor structures that:
- Satisfy the usual valence-shell requirements, especially the octet rule for second-period elements such as carbon, nitrogen, and oxygen.
- Avoid unnecessarily large formal-charge magnitudes.
- Avoid unnecessary separation of positive and negative formal charges.
- Place negative formal charge preferentially on more electronegative atoms when otherwise comparable structures are available.
These are qualitative guidelines, not a universal optimization rule. Minimizing formal charges does not automatically produce the best structure. A representation with fewer charges may leave an important atom with an incomplete octet, while some chemically important structures necessarily contain charge separation.
Formal-charge minimization also cannot, on its own, determine the bonding in compounds commonly drawn with expanded valence shells. Alternative Lewis conventions may use multiple bonds or charge-separated single bonds. Modern descriptions of such bonding require more than an electron-counting diagram, including molecular orbital theory.
Formal charge and resonance
In resonance, two or more Lewis structures describe the same arrangement of nuclei but differ in electron placement. The formal charge on a particular atom can change between these contributing structures, although the total charge remains constant.
For nitrate, , each of the three familiar equivalent contributors contains:
- one nitrogen atom with formal charge ;
- two singly bonded oxygen atoms, each with formal charge ;
- one doubly bonded oxygen atom with formal charge zero.
The sum is . Moving the double bond among the three oxygen positions produces the equivalent contributors.
The actual ion does not switch between these drawings. Its electronic structure is delocalized. Averaging the formal charges of equivalent oxygen positions gives per oxygen, but that arithmetic average is not a measurement of an oxygen atom’s physical charge. The integer formal charges belong to the individual Lewis contributors.
Distinction from oxidation state and partial charge
Formal charge, oxidation state, and partial charge use different ways of describing electrons.
Oxidation state
An oxidation state assigns electrons in heteronuclear bonds to the more electronegative partner, following an ionic approximation and established assignment rules. Formal charge divides those electrons equally.
In water:
- Oxygen has formal charge but oxidation state .
- Each hydrogen has formal charge but oxidation state .
Oxidation states are especially useful for tracking oxidation–reduction reactions. Formal charges are especially useful for describing Lewis structures and electron-pair changes. A change in formal charge need not indicate a redox process.
Partial charge
A partial atomic charge describes an unequal distribution of electron density within a molecule. It is commonly represented using and , or by a numerical value obtained from a specified computational partitioning scheme.
In water, oxygen is partially negative and hydrogen partially positive, even though all atoms have formal charge zero. Unlike formal charge, calculated partial charges generally need not be integers and can differ between methods.
There is no unique, method-independent way to divide a molecule’s continuous electron density into individual atomic charges. Formal charge therefore should not be interpreted as a direct quantitative measure of bond polarity or local electrostatic potential.
Role in reaction mechanisms and coordinate bonds
Formal charges are widely used in reaction mechanisms to check electron accounting as bonds form or break. Curved arrows show electron movement; formal charges are recalculated from the resulting bonding and nonbonding arrangements.
For example, when ammonia accepts a proton in an acid–base reaction, nitrogen’s lone pair becomes a bonding pair:
Nitrogen changes from formal charge zero to . The total charge remains throughout.
This example also illustrates coordinate bonding: both electrons of the newly formed bond originally come from nitrogen. Once the bond is included in the product’s Lewis structure, however, formal-charge calculation divides its electrons equally, just as for any other covalent bond. The electrons’ origin does not create a separate formal-charge rule.
Formal charge remains a property of a chosen structural representation. By itself, it does not establish reaction rate, thermodynamic stability, the location of all chemical reactivity, or the physical distribution of charge.