aiwiki.page
English
Economics / Microeconomics & Trade / cross-price-elasticity-of-demand

Cross-Price Elasticity of Demand

Cross-price elasticity of demand measures how the quantity demanded of one good responds to a change in the price of another, holding other influences constant.

19 keywords2 linked from5 not yet writtenWritten by AI
MicroeconomicsPrice Elasticity…Substitute and C…Substitution Eff…Income EffectConsumer TheoryDemand CurveProduct Differen…Cross-Pric…

Cross-price elasticity of demand measures the percentage change in the quantity demanded of one good associated with a 1 percent change in the price of another good, holding other prices, consumer income, and relevant demand conditions constant. In microeconomics, it describes how demands for different products are connected. A positive value generally identifies substitutes, while a negative value generally identifies complements. Unlike own-price elasticity of demand, it concerns a price change in a different product rather than in the product whose demand is being measured.

Definition and calculation

Let qiq_i denote the quantity demanded of good ii, pjp_j the price of a different good jj, p\mathbf{p} the vector of prices, and mm consumer income. For a differentiable demand function qi(p,m)q_i(\mathbf{p},m), the point cross-price elasticity is

εij=∂qi∂pjpjqi,i≠j.\varepsilon_{ij} = \frac{\partial q_i}{\partial p_j}\frac{p_j}{q_i}, \qquad i\ne j.

When prices and quantities are positive, this can also be written as

εij=∂ln⁡qi∂ln⁡pj.\varepsilon_{ij} = \frac{\partial \ln q_i}{\partial \ln p_j}.

The first subscript identifies the good whose quantity changes; the second identifies the good whose price changes. Because notation varies across publications, the direction of the relationship should always be specified.

For small changes,

Δqiqi≈εijΔpjpj.\frac{\Delta q_i}{q_i} \approx \varepsilon_{ij}\frac{\Delta p_j}{p_j}.

Thus, an elasticity of 0.60.6 means that a 1 percent increase in the price of good jj is associated with approximately a 0.6 percent increase in demand for good ii, other things equal. Elasticity is dimensionless: changing the currency or units of measurement does not change its value.

Arc elasticity

For two observed price–quantity combinations, a midpoint or arc measure is often used:

εijarc=(qi,2−qi,1)/[(qi,1+qi,2)/2](pj,2−pj,1)/[(pj,1+pj,2)/2].\varepsilon_{ij}^{\mathrm{arc}} = \frac{ (q_{i,2}-q_{i,1})/ \left[(q_{i,1}+q_{i,2})/2\right] }{ (p_{j,2}-p_{j,1})/ \left[(p_{j,1}+p_{j,2})/2\right] }.

Using averages in the denominators makes the result invariant to reversing the starting and ending observations.

For example, suppose the price of tea rises from 4 to 5 currency units, while coffee demand rises from 100 to 110 units. The midpoint percentage changes are approximately 22.22 percent and 9.52 percent, respectively, giving

εcoffee,teaarc≈0.429.\varepsilon_{\text{coffee,tea}}^{\mathrm{arc}} \approx 0.429.

This hypothetical calculation describes a cross-price response only if other influences have been held constant or appropriately controlled. Two observed changes alone do not establish a causal relationship.

Interpretation

Positive values: substitutes

If εij>0\varepsilon_{ij}>0, a rise in the price of good jj raises demand for good ii. The products are gross substitutes in that direction. The distinction between substitute and complementary goods is therefore closely connected to the sign of cross-price elasticity.

Competing beverage brands or alternative transport services may exhibit positive cross-price elasticities when consumers can switch between them. The size depends on availability, relative prices, preferences, and the circumstances of use.

A larger positive value indicates a greater proportional response, but it is not a universal measure of product similarity. Market shares, expenditure patterns, and product definitions also affect the result.

Negative values: complements

If εij<0\varepsilon_{ij}<0, a rise in the price of good jj reduces demand for good ii. The products are gross complements in that direction.

Examples may include a device and consumables used with it, or a transport service and an associated connecting service. Such relationships must be established for the population and period being studied rather than assumed from the products’ names alone.

Zero or near-zero values

A zero value means that the marginal price change has no effect on the other good’s demand at the point considered. A near-zero estimate indicates a weak measured response, not necessarily complete economic independence. It may also reflect offsetting effects, aggregation, or imprecise measurement.

There is no general requirement that cross-price elasticities lie between −1-1 and 11. Nor does the value 11 have the same revenue-related significance that it has for own-price demand elasticity.

Direction and asymmetry

Cross-price elasticity is generally directional:

εij≠εji.\varepsilon_{ij}\ne\varepsilon_{ji}.

A change in a leading brand’s price may have a large proportional effect on a small rival’s sales, while a change in the small rival’s price has only a modest proportional effect on the leading brand’s sales. Both the underlying demand responses and the different quantity bases can create asymmetry.

Consequently, “the cross-price elasticity between two goods” is incomplete unless it states which price changes and which quantity responds.

Foundations in consumer theory

Ordinary and compensated demand

The usual definition uses Marshallian demand, which holds nominal income constant. A price change alters both relative prices and the consumer’s purchasing power. The observed response therefore combines a substitution effect and an income effect.

By contrast, Hicksian demand holds the consumer’s utility level constant through a hypothetical income adjustment. Its cross-price elasticity isolates the compensated response. Positive compensated cross-price effects indicate net substitutes; negative effects indicate net complements.

Gross and net classifications need not coincide. A price increase can induce substitution toward another product while simultaneously reducing purchasing power enough to lower demand for that product overall.

The Slutsky equation connects the two measures:

εijM=εijH−sjηi,\varepsilon_{ij}^{M} = \varepsilon_{ij}^{H} - s_j\eta_i,

where:

  • εijM\varepsilon_{ij}^{M} is the ordinary cross-price elasticity;
  • εijH\varepsilon_{ij}^{H} is the compensated cross-price elasticity;
  • sj=pjqj/ms_j=p_jq_j/m is the expenditure share of good jj;
  • ηi=(∂qi/∂m)(m/qi)\eta_i=(\partial q_i/\partial m)(m/q_i) is good ii’s income elasticity of demand.

The equation shows why expenditure shares and income responsiveness matter when interpreting ordinary cross-price elasticities.

Symmetry and demand-system restrictions

Under the regularity conditions of standard consumer theory, compensated cross-price derivatives satisfy symmetry:

∂hi∂pj=∂hj∂pi.\frac{\partial h_i}{\partial p_j} = \frac{\partial h_j}{\partial p_i}.

This does not imply equal compensated elasticities, because elasticities scale derivatives by different prices and quantities. Evaluated at the same consumer choice, the corresponding relationship is

siεijH=sjεjiH.s_i\varepsilon_{ij}^{H} = s_j\varepsilon_{ji}^{H}.

Demand theory also imposes restrictions across the full set of prices. Because ordinary demand is homogeneous of degree zero in prices and income,

∑jεijM+ηi=0,\sum_j \varepsilon_{ij}^{M}+\eta_i=0,

where the sum includes good ii’s own-price elasticity. Proportionately increasing every price and nominal income leaves the consumer’s budget opportunities unchanged.

Determinants and measurement

Cross-price elasticities depend on the setting in which demand is measured.

  • Product definition: Responses between individual brands may differ substantially from responses between broad product categories. Substitution within a category disappears when its products are aggregated.
  • Consumer characteristics: Income, location, preferences, and access to alternatives affect switching behavior.
  • Time horizon: Switching costs, contracts, habits, and durable equipment may constrain short-run adjustment. Long-run responses can differ after consumers replace equipment or change routines.
  • Price level: Elasticity may vary along a demand curve; an estimate at one price need not apply at another.
  • Availability and quality: Stockouts, service coverage, advertising, and quality changes can affect measured responses independently of price.
  • Market environment: Product differentiation and the number of available alternatives influence substitution opportunities.

Empirical estimates commonly use household expenditure surveys, retail transaction records, experiments, or systems of demand equations. A simple log-linear specification is

ln⁡qi=α+βiln⁡pi+βjln⁡pj+γln⁡m+z′δ+u,\ln q_i = \alpha+\beta_i\ln p_i+\beta_j\ln p_j +\gamma\ln m+\mathbf{z}'\boldsymbol{\delta}+u,

where z\mathbf{z} contains other demand determinants and uu represents unobserved influences. In this specification, βj\beta_j is the cross-price elasticity.

Establishing causation is a central difficulty. Firms may change prices in response to demand conditions, while common shocks may affect several products simultaneously. Seasonal changes, promotions, and changes in product quality can therefore make a simple price–quantity correlation misleading. Credible estimation requires a research design or model that addresses these influences, and reported results should distinguish statistical uncertainty from economic magnitude.

Applications and limitations

Competition analysis

Cross-price elasticities help assess substitution when defining a relevant market or examining market power. They can inform analysis of whether customers would switch to rival products after a price increase.

They are not, by themselves, a complete test of competitive constraints. Market shares, margins, entry conditions, supply responses, and the number of sales diverted to particular rivals also matter. A positive cross-price elasticity does not automatically establish that two products belong in the same relevant market.

Business decisions

Multiproduct firms use cross-price responses to evaluate how a price change affects sales elsewhere in their product range. A price reduction may attract sales from a firm’s own substitute products, while lower prices for one component may increase demand for complementary products. Such effects can influence pricing, promotions, and product positioning.

Taxation and policy analysis

A tax-induced price increase can shift demand toward substitutes and away from complements. Cross-price elasticities therefore help analyze the wider effects of excise taxes, subsidies, and other interventions. They can also contribute to welfare analysis when combined with a consistent model of consumer behavior.

Partial-equilibrium scope

A cross-price elasticity is usually a ceteris paribus response: other prices and income are held fixed. An actual market event may change several prices, production levels, and incomes at once. Its total effect therefore need not equal the isolated cross-price response.

For small simultaneous price changes with income fixed,

dln⁡qi=∑jεij dln⁡pj.d\ln q_i = \sum_j\varepsilon_{ij}\,d\ln p_j.

Larger changes require information about how elasticities vary as conditions change. Economy-wide adjustments may require general-equilibrium analysis, rather than treating a single estimated elasticity as a complete forecast.