The Carolingian dynasty was a family of Frankish rulers that rose from aristocratic and palace offices to replace the Merovingian dynasty as kings in 751. Under Charlemagne, it brought much of western and central Europe under one ruler and acquired the imperial title in 800. Carolingians subsequently ruled several kingdoms created from this empire, retaining kingship in East Francia until 911 and, with interruptions, in West Francia until 987. The dynasty’s name derives from the Latin Carolus, or Charles, especially as associated with Charles Martel and Charlemagne.
Carolingian power combined military expansion, landed wealth, cooperation with aristocratic families, and a close relationship with the Christian Church. Its rulers promoted religious reform, written government, and the preservation and production of books. Their empire was not a modern territorial state: authority depended on royal households, assemblies, bishops, abbots, counts, and negotiated relationships across regions with different laws and traditions.
The dynasty’s history encompasses both the construction of an imperial order and its transformation into several competing kingdoms. Its importance lies not simply in anticipating later European states, but in reshaping political legitimacy, ecclesiastical organization, learned culture, and the institutions through which power operated during the early Middle Ages.
Aristocratic origins and the rise of the palace mayors
The Carolingians emerged from the aristocracy of Austrasia, the northeastern portion of the Frankish world, with important connections in the Meuse, Moselle, and Rhine regions. Their ancestry conventionally joins two seventh-century families: the descendants of Pippin of Landen, a mayor of the palace, and those of Arnulf, bishop of Metz. The marriage of Pippin’s daughter Begga to Arnulf’s son Ansegisel linked these lineages. Their son Pippin of Herstal became the principal architect of the family’s lasting predominance. Later genealogies elaborated prestigious ancestry, but these early connections are more securely established than claims extending the dynasty into remote antiquity.
Under the Merovingians, the mayor of the palace originally managed aspects of the royal household but increasingly coordinated aristocratic politics and government. This development was uneven and contested. Pippin of Landen’s son Grimoald attempted to secure royal power for his own family in the seventh century, but his enterprise failed. Carolingian ascendancy was therefore neither a straightforward constitutional evolution nor an uninterrupted family success. It depended on the accumulation of estates, marriage alliances, ecclesiastical patronage, and victories over rival aristocratic groups.
Pippin of Herstal defeated the Neustrian forces at Tertry in 687, establishing a dominant position across much of the Frankish kingdom. He nevertheless governed through existing Merovingian kings rather than replacing them. After his death in 714, a succession struggle threatened his family’s position. His son Charles Martel eventually overcame competitors, including forces associated with Pippin’s widow Plectrude and rival Neustrian leaders. Charles’s campaigns restored and extended the family’s authority, while his patronage secured supporters among both secular magnates and churchmen.
Charles’s victory over an army from al-Andalus near Poitiers or Tours in 732 became especially prominent in later historical memory. It strengthened his prestige, but his consolidation of Frankish power also depended on campaigns in Aquitaine, Burgundy, Provence, and the eastern borderlands. After the death of the Merovingian king Theuderic IV in 737, Charles ruled without appointing another king, although he did not take the royal title himself. When he died in 741, his sons Carloman and Pippin divided responsibilities. Their subsequent restoration of a Merovingian king, Childeric III, in 743 demonstrates that the older dynasty’s legitimacy still had political value.
The royal takeover and the alliance with Rome
The transition from palace government to Carolingian kingship occurred under Pippin III, commonly called Pippin the Short. His brother Carloman withdrew into religious life in 747, leaving Pippin in a stronger position to seek the crown. Frankish sources describe an approach to Pope Zachary asking whether the person who exercised royal power should also possess the royal title. The reported papal response endorsed the alignment of title with effective authority. Although the precise exchanges are known through narratives favorable to the new dynasty, the appeal illustrates the importance of ecclesiastical approval in legitimizing the change.
In 751, an assembly of leading Franks accepted Pippin as king, and Childeric III was deposed and confined to a monastery. Pippin received anointing, a ritual that linked kingship with biblical models of divinely sanctioned rule. A second, particularly consequential ceremony followed in 754, when Pope Stephen II traveled across the Alps and anointed Pippin and his sons Charles and Carloman at Saint-Denis. By including the next generation, the ceremony reinforced the family’s claim that royal authority belonged to the Carolingian lineage rather than merely to Pippin personally.
The alliance answered distinct needs. Pippin gained religious recognition for a contested dynastic replacement. The papacy sought protection against the Lombard kingdom, whose expansion threatened Rome and former Byzantine territories in Italy. The Byzantine Empire remained a major power, but its capacity to defend the pope’s immediate interests in Italy had weakened. Frankish intervention offered a practical alternative. The partnership did not make either party wholly subordinate to the other; popes and Frankish rulers continued to pursue their own territorial, religious, and political priorities.
Pippin campaigned against the Lombard king Aistulf in 754 and 756. The ensuing transfers of territories and rights to Saint Peter and the Roman Church formed a crucial stage in the development of the Papal States. The arrangements known collectively as the Donation of Pippin were implemented through warfare and negotiation rather than a single uncomplicated act of territorial creation. Their significance lay in establishing a durable Frankish commitment to papal temporal interests.
Pippin also expanded royal power within the Frankish sphere. His forces captured Narbonne in 759, ending Muslim rule there, and prolonged campaigns against Duke Waifar brought Aquitaine under firmer control before Pippin’s death in 768. His reign therefore combined dynastic innovation with territorial consolidation. The new monarchy inherited Merovingian institutions and Frankish political customs while adding an especially visible language of sacred kingship and Roman ecclesiastical partnership.
Charlemagne’s conquests and the imperial coronation
After Pippin’s death in 768, his kingdom was divided between his sons Charles and Carloman. Their relationship was tense, but Carloman’s death in 771 allowed Charles to reunite the inheritance. Charlemagne then pursued decades of campaigning that greatly expanded the territories under Carolingian rule. In 774 he defeated the Lombard king Desiderius, took Pavia, and assumed the title king of the Lombards. Rather than simply abolishing the conquered kingdom’s identity, he incorporated its crown into a composite monarchy whose regions retained distinctive institutions and aristocracies.
The Saxon Wars, conventionally dated 772–804, were the longest and among the most violent of his campaigns. Frankish armies attacked political and religious centers, imposed tribute and oaths, established churches, and repeatedly confronted resistance. Saxon opposition included the leadership of Widukind, who accepted baptism in 785. Coercive legislation prescribed severe penalties for attacks on Christian institutions and resistance to conversion. Frankish annals report the execution of 4,500 Saxons at Verden in 782; the figure and the event’s circumstances have been debated, but the campaign’s use of punitive violence is clear. Deportations and resettlements accompanied the eventual incorporation of Saxony.
Expansion elsewhere followed different patterns. Charlemagne removed Duke Tassilo III of Bavaria in 788, bringing Bavaria more directly under royal control. Campaigns against the Avars from 791 and the capture of major Avar centers in 795–796 broke their power in the middle Danube region. South of the Pyrenees, the Frankish expedition of 778 failed to secure Zaragoza, and its retreat suffered an attack at Roncevaux. Later conquest established a more durable frontier zone around Barcelona, captured in 801 by forces led by Charlemagne’s son Louis. These frontier arrangements relied on counts, local alliances, fortified centers, and repeated military intervention.
On 25 December 800, Pope Leo III crowned Charlemagne emperor in Rome. The ceremony followed Charlemagne’s intervention in a crisis involving accusations against Leo and attacks on the pope. It revived an imperial title in the West, where no emperor had ruled since the fifth century, but it did not restore the ancient Roman Empire in its previous institutional form. It also raised difficult questions about relations with the emperor at Constantinople. Byzantine recognition of Charlemagne’s imperial status came in 812, without resolving every issue of title and precedence.
The coronation gave a new expression to power already created through conquest and alliance. Charlemagne presented imperial authority as a responsibility for Christian order, justice, and ecclesiastical protection. His empire nevertheless remained geographically uneven: royal influence was strongest where estates, loyal elites, communications, and military resources could support it.
Kingship, administration, and the exercise of authority
Carolingian government centered on the ruler and a mobile court rather than a fixed capital with specialized ministries. Kings traveled between palaces and estates, received petitioners, celebrated major religious festivals, and presided over assemblies. Aachen became particularly important during Charlemagne’s later reign because of its palace complex and chapel, but it did not eliminate itinerant government. The household brought together relatives, clerics, military companions, and officials whose personal access to the ruler could be as important as their formal responsibilities.
Counts exercised authority in local districts, leading military contingents, overseeing judicial proceedings, and protecting royal interests. Bishops and abbots likewise performed public tasks alongside their religious duties. In frontier regions, rulers sometimes entrusted commanders with responsibilities extending beyond a single county. None of these arrangements created a uniform hierarchy operating identically throughout the empire. Royal power depended on officeholders who possessed their own family connections and landed resources, making government a continuing negotiation between central demands and regional interests.
The missi dominici, or royal envoys, were one means of supervising this system. Under Charlemagne, particularly from 802, pairs or groups of envoys were assigned to inspect districts, hear complaints, convey commands, and administer oaths. A pairing of ecclesiastical and secular personnel could combine different forms of authority. The envoys were not an independent professional civil service: they were themselves drawn from the governing elite. Their effectiveness depended on cooperation, knowledge of local conditions, and the ruler’s ability to support their interventions.
Royal instructions often took the form of capitularies, texts divided into chapters addressing matters such as military service, ecclesiastical discipline, judicial conduct, or estate management. Some supplemented existing legal traditions; others recorded decisions or instructions associated with assemblies. Their survival in manuscripts does not establish that every provision was implemented consistently. Written orders operated alongside oral communication, public ceremony, oaths, and customary procedure. Peoples within the empire continued to use different laws, including Frankish, Lombard, Bavarian, and Saxon legal traditions.
The army similarly reflected a combination of obligation and resources. Landholders and their dependents furnished service, equipment, transport, or material support, while magnates organized substantial followings. Capitularies attempted to distribute burdens and prevent poorer free men from being overwhelmed by repeated campaigning. Mounted troops were important, but Carolingian warfare also required infantry, siege operations, supply arrangements, and river transport. Explanations that attribute the dynasty’s success simply to cavalry technology or to a fully developed system of feudalism obscure the diversity of its military and political institutions.
Ecclesiastical reform and the Christian political order
The Carolingians treated the reform of Christianity as part of government. Correct worship, clerical education, moral discipline, and the protection of churches were understood to affect the welfare of the entire Christian people. This did not produce a modern separation between religious and secular authority. Kings convened councils, issued religious instructions, influenced appointments, and expected bishops and abbots to assist in governing. Ecclesiastical leaders, in turn, articulated standards by which rulers could be advised, criticized, and sometimes publicly judged.
Reform began before the royal takeover. Carloman and Pippin supported councils in the 740s associated with Boniface and other churchmen seeking to improve discipline and ecclesiastical organization. Under Charlemagne, the Admonitio generalis of 789 set out an extensive program encompassing clerical conduct, teaching, religious practice, and the responsibilities of officials. Its provisions connected correct belief and worship with practical measures such as establishing instruction in monasteries and episcopal centers. The concern was not universal schooling in a modern sense, but the availability of competent personnel able to perform and explain Christian duties.
Liturgical reform sought greater agreement with Roman practice, although implementation produced adaptations rather than complete uniformity. The copying and correction of biblical and liturgical texts supported this program. Monasteries were especially important because they combined prayer, landed resources, book production, education, and royal patronage. Under Louis the Pious, councils at Aachen in 816–817 promoted more consistent monastic observance according to the Rule of Benedict, with Benedict of Aniane playing a leading role. Communities of canons also received regulations suited to their distinct form of religious life.
The dynasty participated in theological controversies extending beyond its own territories. Frankish scholars opposed Adoptionist teachings associated with some Iberian bishops, and the Council of Frankfurt in 794 condemned those positions. Disputes concerning sacred images revealed imperfect communication with Byzantium: the Frankish response to the Second Council of Nicaea of 787 was shaped partly by problems in the Latin rendering and interpretation of Greek proceedings. The Carolingian court also supported the Western use of the Filioque in the creed, while Pope Leo III distinguished approval of the theology from acceptance of the addition to the creed’s text.
Christianization could involve persuasion, patronage, institution-building, and coercion. In conquered Saxony, baptism and church establishment accompanied military subjugation; elsewhere, missionary work depended heavily on local rulers and aristocratic support. Churches benefited from royal protection and land grants, but their wealth also attracted political intervention. Ecclesiastical reform consequently strengthened both religious institutions and royal authority while creating standards of Christian rulership that could be turned against kings who were judged to have failed.
Learning, manuscripts, and artistic production
The movement commonly called the Carolingian Renaissance was a sustained revival and reorganization of learning, especially from the later eighth through the ninth century. It arose from practical religious and governmental needs: clergy had to read accurately, religious texts required correction, and rulers needed educated advisers and reliable written communication. The label should not imply a secular cultural rebirth identical to the later Renaissance. Carolingian scholars worked within Christian institutions, drawing on late antique and earlier medieval traditions rather than recovering classical culture after its complete disappearance.
Charlemagne attracted scholars from several regions. Alcuin of York, who joined the court in the early 780s and later became abbot of Saint-Martin at Tours, helped organize teaching and textual correction. Paul the Deacon brought Lombard historical and grammatical learning; Theodulf of Orléans contributed poetry, theology, and biblical scholarship; Peter of Pisa taught grammar. In the next generation, figures such as Hrabanus Maurus at Fulda and John Scottus Eriugena at the court of Charles the Bald demonstrate the movement’s continued development beyond Charlemagne’s lifetime.
Instruction drew upon grammar, rhetoric, dialectic, arithmetic, geometry, music, and astronomy, the disciplines later conventionally grouped as the seven liberal arts. Mastery of Latin was central, since it connected Scripture, liturgy, administration, and learned exchange across regions whose spoken languages differed. Schools attached to monasteries, cathedrals, and courts trained selected pupils rather than the population as a whole. Learned production included biblical commentaries, letters, poetry, computistical works for calculating the calendar, historical narratives, and treatises on political and religious questions.
One of the movement’s most durable achievements was the spread of Carolingian minuscule, a legible script with clear letter forms and increasingly regular separation of words. It developed through the work of multiple writing centers rather than a single royal decree. Scriptoria copied Christian authors and classical Latin works, sometimes preserving texts through manuscripts that became crucial ancestors of later copies. The survival of ancient literature owes much to this activity, although copying was selective and substantial losses continued. Manuscript comparison, script, and physical construction now provide evidence studied through paleography and codicology.
Artistic patronage joined classical, Christian, insular, and regional traditions. The palace chapel at Aachen drew on late antique and Byzantine architectural models while serving a specifically Carolingian court. The Godescalc Evangelistary, produced in 781–783, exemplifies prestigious manuscript commissions; the Utrecht Psalter, made in the ninth century, illustrates a markedly different, energetic style of biblical illustration. Ivory carving, metalwork, decorated bindings, and monumental church building expressed elite devotion and status. Production flourished at several courts and religious centers, so Carolingian culture cannot be reduced to one palace workshop or one uniform artistic style.
Land, labor, exchange, and social hierarchy
The material foundation of Carolingian power was overwhelmingly agrarian. Royal families, aristocrats, bishops, and monasteries controlled estates that provided food, rents, labor, animals, and military resources. Yet rural organization differed substantially between regions. Large estates documented in northern Francia cannot be treated as a complete model for Italy, Aquitaine, Bavaria, or every frontier zone. The surviving evidence is especially rich for ecclesiastical landholders, whose archives preserved records more consistently than those of many lay families.
Some estates were organized around a lord’s demesne, worked partly through labor owed by dependent households, alongside tenant holdings providing rents and services. This organization is central to the history of manorialism. The polyptych associated with Abbot Irminon of Saint-Germain-des-Prés, compiled in the early ninth century, records holdings, obligations, and rural households in unusual detail. Such surveys reveal careful management, but they also reflect the interests and categories of estate administrators. They do not provide an unmediated account of how peasants experienced work, negotiated obligations, or used resources beyond the estate.
Rural populations included free landholders, tenants of varying legal condition, and enslaved people. Legal freedom did not necessarily imply economic independence, while unfree status encompassed diverse practical circumstances. The later medieval institutions usually grouped under serfdom developed from changing combinations of dependence rather than one uniform Carolingian settlement. People could face rents in produce or money, labor services, transport duties, and demands connected with public obligations. Warfare and political instability might intensify dependence, but rulers also issued measures intended to protect free people from unlawful coercion by powerful neighbors.
Royal wealth was not supported by a comprehensive fiscal system comparable to that of the ancient Roman state. Estates, tribute, judicial revenues, tolls, gifts, and military booty all mattered. The Capitulare de villis, whose precise date and immediate administrative setting remain debated, prescribed detailed management of royal properties, including livestock, workshops, supplies, and accounts. Its range illustrates the ruler’s interest in productive resources rather than demonstrating that every royal estate followed a standardized plan.
Trade remained significant within this rural economy. River routes and ports connected inland production to the North Sea and Mediterranean worlds; centers such as Dorestad handled long-distance exchange. Charlemagne’s late eighth-century monetary reforms established a more standardized silver denier, with accounting relationships of 12 deniers to a solidus and 20 solidi to a pound. The solidus and pound principally served as units of account rather than circulating gold coins in this system. Coin finds, toll records, and archaeological evidence reveal exchange networks whose scale varied considerably across the empire. Slavery also remained part of both production and commerce, alongside transactions in textiles, wine, salt, metal goods, and other commodities.
Louis the Pious, civil war, and the division of the empire
Charlemagne’s plans for succession changed as his sons died. A division arranged in 806 envisaged separate inheritances, but the deaths of Pippin of Italy in 810 and Charles the Younger in 811 left Louis the Pious as the principal surviving legitimate son. Charlemagne associated Louis with the imperial title at Aachen in 813. When Charlemagne died in January 814, Louis inherited the central imperial position, while Bernard, Pippin’s son, continued as king in Italy. Louis brought experience from ruling Aquitaine, but inherited an empire whose unity depended on managing powerful regional interests and the claims of his own family.
The Ordinatio imperii of 817 attempted to reconcile imperial unity with provision for Louis’s sons. Lothar was designated co-emperor and given a superior position, while Pippin received Aquitaine and Louis, later called the German, Bavaria. Bernard of Italy resisted the implications of the settlement, submitted, and was punished by blinding in 818; he died shortly afterward. Louis the Pious’s public penance at Attigny in 822, which included acknowledgment of wrongdoing toward Bernard and others, expressed a conception of rulership accountable to Christian moral judgment.
The birth of Charles, later Charles the Bald, in 823 to Louis’s second wife Judith complicated the arrangements. Providing an inheritance for him threatened the expectations of older sons and their supporters. Rebellions in 830 and 833 were not merely domestic quarrels: aristocrats and ecclesiastics joined shifting coalitions over offices, patronage, regional power, and the proper ordering of the Christian empire. In 833, Louis lost support during a confrontation near Colmar, traditionally associated with the “Field of Lies,” and underwent a public deposition and penance. He recovered power in 834, showing that ritual humiliation did not irreversibly end royal authority.
After Louis died in 840, conflict continued among Lothar, Louis the German, and Charles the Bald. Lothar’s claim to superior imperial authority encountered resistance from his brothers. The battle of Fontenoy in 841 was followed by the Strasbourg Oaths of 842, in which Louis and Charles affirmed their alliance. Their oaths are notable for the early Romance and Germanic vernacular forms preserved within Nithard’s narrative, but they were acts of political coalition, not declarations of modern national identity.
The Treaty of Verdun in 843 divided the empire into three major kingdoms. Charles received West Francia, Louis East Francia, and Lothar a middle kingdom extending from the North Sea through the Rhineland and Burgundy into Italy, together with the imperial title. The settlement did not instantly create France and Germany. It established a durable framework for competing Carolingian kingdoms while leaving shared aristocratic networks, ecclesiastical interests, and ideas of Frankish political community intact.
Regional kingdoms and the end of Carolingian kingship
After 843, Carolingian politics remained dynamic rather than proceeding through a single continuous collapse. Kings fought one another, negotiated inheritances, reorganized frontiers, and maintained ambitious courts. Charles the Bald consolidated West Frankish power despite recurrent opposition and became emperor in 875. Louis the German developed a durable East Frankish kingship. Lothar I’s middle kingdom was divided among his sons in 855, producing further political units, including the northern kingdom later known as Lotharingia. Subsequent agreements, notably at Meerssen in 870 and Ribemont in 880, redistributed much of this contested territory.
External warfare placed considerable demands on royal resources. Scandinavian raiders, conventionally called Vikings, attacked coastal and riverine centers, while some groups established more permanent footholds. Muslim forces and regional powers contested parts of Italy and the Mediterranean; eastern frontiers faced changing pressures that later included Magyar attacks. These conflicts did not affect every kingdom equally. Fortification, negotiated payments, military mobilization, and local resistance could all form part of a response. The siege of Paris in 885–886 helped enhance the standing of Count Odo, whose subsequent royal election illustrates how successful regional leadership could challenge dynastic entitlement.
Charles the Fat briefly brought most of the former empire under one ruler in 884, although important territories and local powers remained outside effective control. His deposition in 887 and death in 888 marked the end of this reunification. Several rulers then emerged in different kingdoms, not all Carolingians. Arnulf of Carinthia, a Carolingian descended from Louis the German, became king in East Francia and emperor in 896. His son Louis the Child died in 911 without an heir, ending Carolingian kingship in the eastern kingdom. The election of Conrad I demonstrated that aristocratic consent could sustain kingship outside the dynasty.
West Francia retained Carolingian rulers for longer, but their succession was interrupted. Odo ruled from 888 to 898; Charles the Simple secured broader recognition after Odo’s death. Charles’s reign included the settlement with the Scandinavian leader Rollo in 911 that became foundational to Normandy. He was later displaced and imprisoned. After the reigns of Robert I and Ralph, Carolingian rule returned with Louis IV in 936, followed by Lothar in 954 and Louis V in 986. These kings exercised real authority, although their resources and freedom of action were constrained by powerful regional families and neighboring rulers.
Louis V died childless in 987. Hugh Capet’s election inaugurated the Capetian dynasty, while the Carolingian claimant Charles of Lower Lorraine failed to secure the throne and was captured in 991. The end of Carolingian kingship did not mean the disappearance of all descendants. Female-line descent connected the family to numerous later aristocratic and royal houses. Its political termination was therefore a change in access to royal office, not a complete biological extinction.
Historical evidence and later interpretations
Knowledge of the Carolingians rests on unusually substantial but uneven evidence. Annals, biographies, letters, legal texts, charters, liturgical books, poetry, and material remains illuminate different aspects of the dynasty. The Royal Frankish Annals provide a central narrative for the expansion of royal power, but their selection of events and revisions reflect court interests. Einhard’s Life of Charlemagne, written after the emperor’s death, combines personal knowledge with literary models drawn especially from Suetonius. Its descriptions of habits, family, warfare, and appearance are invaluable without being politically neutral or uniformly eyewitness testimony.
Evidence for the divided kingdoms includes the Annals of Saint-Bertin and the Annals of Fulda, whose changing authors and settings influenced their treatment of rulers and conflicts. Nithard’s history supplies an informed but partisan account of the struggles among Louis the Pious’s sons. Dhuoda’s handbook for her son William, written in the 840s, offers a rare surviving extended work by an aristocratic woman and illuminates family loyalty, Christian instruction, and political insecurity. Charters document grants, disputes, privileges, and relationships, although their formulas and preservation histories require scrutiny.
Manuscripts and objects often qualify narratives produced around rulers. Estate surveys reveal economic organization; coinage provides evidence for authority and exchange; excavated settlements, cemeteries, workshops, and fortifications expose regional patterns that written sources may overlook. Documentary survival is concentrated in religious institutions, producing a persistent imbalance toward ecclesiastical property and literate elites. Peasants, enslaved people, women outside a small privileged circle, and communities on imperial frontiers are consequently less directly represented. Their histories require combining different forms of evidence rather than treating court narratives as a complete social record.
Later rulers appropriated Carolingian prestige in different ways. The Ottonian emperors cultivated connections with Charlemagne, and Otto I’s imperial coronation in 962 helped establish the political order later known as the Holy Roman Empire. West Frankish and French traditions likewise incorporated Charlemagne into royal memory. Medieval epic transformed him into an idealized Christian emperor whose literary wars could differ sharply from eighth- and ninth-century events. Modern French and German national histories often treated the dynasty as part of their respective national origins, although the Carolingians ruled a multilingual world that preceded those national categories.
Modern historiography has also reconsidered older explanations centered on inevitable “feudal anarchy” or the mechanical disintegration of a unified state. Aristocratic power, regional identities, political negotiation, and ecclesiastical institutions could sustain government as well as limit kings. The language of reform and unity sometimes expressed aspirations more than administrative realities, while divided kingdoms could remain effective political communities. Analysis therefore distinguishes the fate of the ruling family from the longer survival of the practices, texts, religious institutions, and regional relationships developed under Carolingian patronage.