Am I Being Unreasonable? is a British television series created and written by Daisy May Cooper and Selin Hizli, who also star as Nic and Jen. First broadcast on BBC One in September 2022, it combines black comedy with a psychological mystery about friendship, grief, and concealed wrongdoing. Its central relationship begins when Nic, an isolated mother living in an English village, befriends Jen, a newcomer whose arrival unsettles the boundaries between intimacy, trust, and suspicion.
Premise and characters
Nic lives with her husband, Dan, and their young son, Ollie. Dissatisfied with her marriage and alienated from the social world around her, she is also preoccupied with a loss that she cannot openly explain. Her friendship with Jen initially offers relief from boredom and loneliness: Jen appears unusually willing to share her irreverence and listen without judgment. As their relationship develops, both women’s accounts of themselves become increasingly uncertain.
The principal cast includes:
- Daisy May Cooper as Nic, whose private memories and secrets shape much of the story.
- Selin Hizli as Jen, a mother whose growing closeness to Nic drives the central mystery.
- Lenny Rush as Ollie, Nic’s son, whose perceptiveness and comic exchanges with his mother are important to the series.
- Dustin Demri-Burns as Dan, Nic’s husband.
- David Fynn as Alex, Dan’s brother, who is central to Nic’s concealed past.
- Sinead Matthews as Becca, a figure in the village’s social circle.
The series gradually reveals how these relationships differ from their initial presentation, making the withholding of information a central part of its construction.
Production and broadcast
The programme was produced by Boffola Pictures and Lookout Point for the BBC. Its first series, directed by Jonny Campbell, consists of six episodes and began broadcasting on BBC One on 23 September 2022, with availability on BBC iPlayer.
A second six-episode series began broadcasting on BBC One on 5 February 2025. It continues the consequences of the first series’ revelations rather than resetting the characters to their original circumstances.
The title echoes the question used in everyday requests for judgment about personal disputes, notably the “Am I Being Unreasonable?” discussion forum on Mumsnet. In the programme, that apparently ordinary question also introduces uncertainty about whose interpretation of events deserves belief.
Genre and storytelling
Although it uses the domestic settings and conversational rhythms of comedy-drama, the programme relies heavily on suspense. Awkward encounters, marital resentment, and school-parent interactions coexist with disturbing memories and revelations about the past.
Its narrative perspective is closely aligned with Nic’s experience without making her understanding of events definitive. Flashbacks supply information in stages, and later scenes alter the significance of earlier ones. The viewer is therefore asked not simply to discover what happened, but to reassess the emotional explanations attached to it.
The contrast between ordinary social embarrassment and serious concealed events is a defining feature. Humour does not consistently relieve the tension; it can also expose hostility, evasiveness, or a mismatch between what characters say and what they know.
Recognition
Lenny Rush won the 2023 BAFTA Television Award for Male Performance in a Comedy Programme for his portrayal of Ollie. The award recognised a performance that combines comic timing with the character’s role as an observant participant in Nic’s troubled domestic life.