All-Pro is a designation awarded to outstanding players at particular positions in professional American football, most commonly in the National Football League (NFL). An All-Pro team is an honorary lineup rather than a team assembled to play a game. Several organizations make independent selections, so the meaning of an All-Pro honor depends on the selector, the season, and whether the player was named to a first or second team.
Selecting organizations
There is no single All-Pro ballot administered by the NFL that supersedes all others. The best-known selections include those made by the Associated Press, the Pro Football Writers of America, and The Sporting News. Their teams can overlap substantially without being identical.
Associated Press
The Associated Press (AP) selects first-team and second-team All-Pro players through a national panel of 50 media members who cover the NFL. Its selections are widely used in player biographies, statistical records, and discussions of career achievement.
Beginning with voting for the 2022 season, the AP introduced a ranked system in which voters choose a first-team and a second-team player at each selection slot. A first-team vote receives three points and a second-team vote one point. The resulting totals determine the selections under the AP’s rules. The exact roster categories and voting procedures have changed over time, so comparisons between seasons require attention to the rules then in effect.
Other selectors
The Pro Football Writers of America (PFWA) publishes an All-NFL team as well as separate All-AFC and All-NFC teams. The latter recognize players within the NFL’s two conferences and are not equivalent in scope to an All-NFL selection.
The Sporting News also has a long history of naming All-Pro teams, using selection procedures that have varied over time. Other publications and organizations have issued their own teams, including historical selectors that no longer operate.
A player described simply as an “All-Pro” may therefore have been recognized by one organization but not another. Precise records identify the selector rather than treating every selection as interchangeable.
First team, second team, and positional structure
A first-team All-Pro selection generally identifies a player as one of the leading performers at a designated position across the league. A second-team All-Pro selection recognizes the next tier under a selector’s voting system. The distinction is important: a career total combining both categories conveys different information from a count of first-team selections alone.
The number of players selected depends on the honorary roster’s structure. Teams usually include offensive players, defensive players, and specialists. Some positions have multiple places, and ties can produce additional honorees.
Position labels also affect the results. A selector may distinguish left and right tackles, group defensive linemen into broader categories, or include a separate slot for a defensive back who primarily covers receivers from the slot. Such choices influence which players compete directly against one another.
All-Pro teams consequently do not always reproduce a conventional starting lineup. They are award structures designed to recognize performance across roles, not tactical squads required to function together on the field.
Difference from the Pro Bowl
All-Pro honors are distinct from selection to the Pro Bowl, the NFL’s all-star event.
| Feature | All-Pro | Pro Bowl |
|---|---|---|
| Main purpose | Recognize outstanding seasonal performance by position | Select participants for the league’s all-star event |
| Selection scope | Usually league-wide for an All-NFL team | Generally organized by conference |
| Selectors | Depend on the awarding organization | Fan, player, and coach voting, subject to NFL procedures |
| Participation | No game or event participation required | Participation can be affected by withdrawals and replacements |
A player can be named All-Pro without being selected to the Pro Bowl, or selected to the Pro Bowl without receiving All-Pro recognition. Pro Bowl career totals may also include replacement selections, whereas an All-Pro honor is not a replacement appointment to an event.
The related term All-America generally concerns collegiate athletes rather than NFL players.
Historical development
All-Pro selection developed through newspaper and sports-publication coverage of professional football. Different selectors used different positional arrangements and voting methods, leaving a historical record composed of several overlapping traditions rather than one continuous, uniform award.
The AP began selecting NFL All-Pro teams in 1940. Other selectors’ records extend into earlier periods of professional football.
Historical league boundaries matter as well. Before the NFL–AFL merger took full effect in 1970, honors associated with the NFL and the American Football League could represent separate pools of players. An All-NFL, All-AFL, or combined selection must therefore be understood in its original competitive context.
Significance and limitations
All-Pro selections are commonly used to document peak seasonal performance. They appear in career summaries and discussions of candidates for the Pro Football Hall of Fame, but no particular number of selections automatically determines induction. Some player contracts also attach financial incentives to specified All-Pro recognition.
Selection remains a judgment rather than a purely statistical result. Voters may weigh production, game observation, tactical responsibilities, consistency, and availability differently. Players at positions with readily visible statistics can be evaluated differently from those whose contributions depend heavily on blocking assignments, coverage responsibilities, or team schemes.
Career comparisons must also account for changing roster categories, league size, season length, and selection rules. Terms such as consensus All-Pro and unanimous All-Pro require particular care: consensus may refer to agreement among several selectors, while unanimity may mean that every voter on one panel selected a player. Neither term has a single meaning independent of the source using it.