{
  "id": "meditations-on-first-philosophy",
  "title": "Meditations on First Philosophy",
  "lang": "en",
  "source_lang": "en",
  "summary": "René Descartes’s 1641 work reconstructs knowledge through radical doubt, arguments for God’s existence, and a distinction between mind and body.",
  "category": "philosophy",
  "subcategory": "metaphysics-epistemology",
  "type": "work",
  "aliases": [
    "Meditations",
    "Meditations on First Philosophy in Which the Existence of God and the Distinction Between the Human Soul and the Body Are Demonstrated",
    "Metaphysical Meditations"
  ],
  "generated_at": "2026-11-03",
  "model": "pro/gpt-6.1-sol",
  "url": "https://aiwiki.page/en/meditations-on-first-philosophy/",
  "translations": {
    "zh-Hans": {
      "url": "https://aiwiki.page/zh/meditations-on-first-philosophy/",
      "json": "https://aiwiki.page/zh/meditations-on-first-philosophy.json"
    }
  },
  "sections": [
    {
      "heading": "",
      "text": "Meditations on First Philosophy is a philosophical work by René Descartes, first published in Latin in Paris in 1641. Organized into six first-person meditations, it attempts to establish secure foundations for knowledge by setting aside beliefs susceptible to doubt and examining what, if anything, remains certain. Its principal subjects are the existence and nature of the thinking self, the existence of God, the source of error, the nature of material things, and the distinction and union between mind and body.\n\nThe work occupies a central place in epistemology, metaphysics, and philosophy of mind. Its importance lies not simply in individual arguments but in their ordered presentation: the reader is asked to undergo a transformation in habits of judgment, moving from reliance on the senses toward intellectual understanding and then recovering a qualified confidence in the material world. The published book also includes objections by contemporary philosophers and theologians and Descartes’s replies, making it both a sustained meditation and a record of philosophical controversy."
    },
    {
      "heading": "Composition, publication, and the meditative form",
      "text": "Descartes developed the Meditations after years of work on mathematics, natural philosophy, and philosophical method. His *Discourse on the Method*, published anonymously in French in 1637 alongside three scientific essays, had already presented the thinking self, God, and the distinction between soul and body in compressed form. The Meditations offered a more sustained treatment intended for readers accustomed to learned philosophical argument. Although Descartes had lived principally in the Dutch Republic since 1628, he arranged for the Latin work to appear in Paris, where scholarly and theological networks could bring it to a wider European audience.\n\nThe first edition’s title announced demonstrations of God’s existence and the immortality of the soul. The second Latin edition, published in Amsterdam in 1642, instead advertised the distinction between the human soul and the body. That change corresponds to an important limitation acknowledged in the synopsis: establishing that mind and body are distinct does not by itself provide a complete demonstration of personal immortality. Such a demonstration would require further premises about the persistence of substances and the conditions under which they can cease to exist. A French translation appeared in 1647, with the meditations translated by the duc de Luynes and the objections and replies by Claude Clerselier; Descartes reviewed the translation.\n\nThe book begins with a dedicatory letter to the theological faculty of Paris, followed by a preface and synopsis. Descartes presents the existence of God and the soul as matters that can be investigated through natural reason rather than established solely by religious authority. His dedication sought a favorable reception within the intellectual world of the Catholic Church, but its presence did not amount to an institutional endorsement of his arguments. The relationship between philosophical demonstration and theological doctrine remained a significant feature of the work’s reception.\n\nThe six meditations are presented as successive exercises rather than as a conventional textbook divided into propositions and proofs. Their narrated sequence creates pauses in which the meditator must relinquish familiar assumptions before advancing. This literary form has affinities with religious practices of meditation, but the immediate task is philosophical examination rather than devotion. Its first-person voice should not be read as a simple autobiographical record: the speaker is also a role constructed for readers to inhabit. Descartes later distinguished this order of discovery from a synthetic arrangement in which definitions, axioms, and conclusions are displayed geometrically. Following the movement of attention is therefore part of understanding the argument."
    },
    {
      "heading": "The First Meditation: the progressive extension of doubt",
      "text": "The First Meditation begins with the recognition that many beliefs accepted since childhood have proved false. Descartes does not propose to examine every belief individually. Instead, he targets the foundations on which large classes of belief depend. If those foundations can be doubted, judgments built upon them can be suspended together. This is methodological rather than ordinary practical doubt: the question is not whether a belief is probably true or reasonable in daily life, but whether it can serve as an absolutely secure starting point. Descartes’s procedure thus gives philosophical skepticism an instrumental role within a project intended ultimately to overcome it.\n\nThe first target is sensory belief. Objects seen at a distance or under poor conditions can be misperceived, showing that the senses are not invariably trustworthy. Yet occasional perceptual mistakes do not seem to undermine ordinary judgments that one is sitting by a fire, wearing clothes, or holding a sheet of paper. The dream argument extends doubt to these apparently immediate experiences. Dreams can represent familiar situations with convincing vividness, and no invariably reliable sign initially appears to distinguish waking from dreaming. Consequently, an experience’s apparent immediacy cannot by itself establish the existence of the external things it presents.\n\nDreaming nevertheless seems to leave some general elements intact. Even imaginary scenes may be composed from basic features such as shape, magnitude, number, place, and time. The sciences of complex existing things therefore appear more vulnerable than arithmetic and geometry: whether awake or asleep, two and three seem to make five. Descartes then introduces a more radical possibility. If an all-powerful creator made the meditator, could that creator have constituted the mind so that it goes wrong even in apparently evident calculations? Invoking a benevolent God does not immediately settle the issue, since ordinary errors already occur.\n\nThe meditation concludes by imagining a supremely powerful and cunning deceiver rather than accepting the theological suggestion that God deceives. This figure functions as a thought experiment that keeps doubt active against the pressure of ingrained habit. The meditator resolves to treat external things, bodily organs, and familiar appearances as potentially deceptive. This is not an assertion that a deceiver exists or that every former belief is false. It is a deliberate suspension of assent: whatever can be called into doubt is provisionally withheld from the foundation of knowledge. The resulting uncertainty is meant to expose a truth whose justification does not depend on the assumptions under examination."
    },
    {
      "heading": "The Second Meditation: existence, thought, and the wax",
      "text": "The Second Meditation discovers a limit to the deceiver hypothesis. Even if a powerful deceiver misleads the meditator about everything else, deception requires that the meditator exist. The proposition “I am, I exist” is necessarily true whenever it is thought or expressed by the person entertaining it. Unlike the familiar formulation “I think, therefore I am”, which appears in other Cartesian writings, the Meditations emphasizes the immediate certainty of existence in the act of thinking. The point is not that a previously established general rule about thinkers is applied to a particular case. The attempt to doubt one’s existence itself manifests the activity that defeats that doubt.\n\nThis certainty initially establishes less than an ordinary account of a human being. The meditator cannot yet claim to possess a body, because bodily existence remains subject to the doubts of the First Meditation. Nor can inherited definitions, such as a human being’s being a rational animal, supply the foundation without introducing further questions. What survives is a “thinking thing,” or res cogitans. Descartes includes doubting, understanding, affirming, denying, willing, refusing, imagining, and sensing among its activities. Even when no external object corresponds to a sensory experience, the occurrence of that apparent sensing remains a mode of thought.\n\nThe distinction between a mental occurrence and its presumed external cause is crucial. The meditator might be wrong that there is a light to see or a sound to hear, but not, in the same way, that it seems to be seeing or hearing. Nevertheless, the scope of the resulting self-knowledge remains disputed. The text speaks of a thing that thinks, not merely of an impersonal episode of thinking. Critics have asked whether the certainty of thought’s occurrence also establishes an enduring subject or substance. Descartes’s subsequent arguments develop a fuller account of the self, but the initial discovery does not yet prove everything later claimed about the mind.\n\nThe wax example examines how bodies themselves are known. A piece of beeswax initially has a particular smell, color, texture, shape, and sound when struck. Near a fire these qualities change, yet it is judged to remain the same wax. Its nature cannot therefore be identified with that original collection of sensory qualities. Nor can imagination survey all the indefinitely many shapes it could assume. The intellect understands it as something extended, flexible, and changeable.\n\nThe example does not yet demonstrate that wax exists independently of the mind. It shows that even an apparently straightforward judgment about a body involves intellectual apprehension rather than sensation alone. Moreover, each judgment concerning the wax also discloses the judging mind. In this epistemic sense, Descartes argues, the mind is better known than the body."
    },
    {
      "heading": "The Third Meditation: ideas, causal adequacy, and God",
      "text": "The Third Meditation examines the contents of thought and asks whether any of them establish the existence of something beyond the thinking self. Descartes distinguishes ideas, considered as representations, from acts such as willing and judging. An idea taken simply as an occurrence in the mind is not false merely because nothing outside the mind resembles it. Error arises especially when judgment treats an idea as corresponding to an external object without adequate grounds. Descartes also distinguishes ideas that appear innate, those that seem adventitious or externally acquired, and those apparently invented. At this stage, these classifications describe apparent origins rather than conclusions already secured against doubt.\n\nHis principal proof of God proceeds through a theory of causation and degrees of reality. An idea has “formal reality” as an actual mental mode, while its “objective reality” consists in the reality it represents. “Objective” here does not mean impartial or mind-independent in the modern everyday sense. An idea of a substance represents more reality than an idea of a mode, and the idea of an infinite substance represents more than that of a finite substance. The governing causal principle is that a total efficient cause must contain at least as much reality as its effect, either formally or eminently—that is, in the same form or in a higher manner.\n\nThe meditator finds an idea of an infinite, independent, supremely intelligent and powerful being. Descartes argues that a finite, imperfect self cannot be the adequate ultimate source of this idea’s objective reality. He rejects the proposal that infinity is simply manufactured by negating the finite: awareness of deficiency and doubt already presupposes some conception of perfection against which limitation is recognized. The causal source adequate to the idea must therefore actually possess the perfection represented. Descartes identifies this source as God. The argument depends on substantive metaphysical commitments about causation and representation, not merely on the psychological observation that people possess religious concepts.\n\nA related argument asks what sustains the meditator’s existence from moment to moment. Descartes holds that preservation requires the same power as creation, since existence at one time does not by itself explain existence at another. The finite self lacks the power to give itself all the perfections of which it has an idea; its continued existence ultimately depends on a being possessing those perfections. An indefinitely extended sequence of dependent causes does not remove the need for an adequate sustaining source.\n\nBecause deception expresses a defect, a supremely perfect God cannot be a deceiver. This conclusion is intended to secure the reliability of clear and distinct understanding against the radical uncertainty introduced in the First Meditation. Whether the argument can establish that guarantee without presupposing it becomes one of the work’s central controversies."
    },
    {
      "heading": "The Fourth Meditation: judgment, freedom, and error",
      "text": "Having argued that the creator is not deceptive, Descartes must explain why human beings nevertheless make mistakes. The Fourth Meditation locates error neither in the mere possession of ideas nor in a defect deliberately built into the intellect, but in the interaction of understanding and will. The intellect presents objects for consideration; the will affirms, denies, pursues, avoids, or withholds judgment. Human understanding is finite and often obscure. The will, by contrast, is experienced as unrestricted in the range of matters on which it can attempt to pronounce. Error occurs when judgment extends beyond what the intellect clearly and distinctly apprehends.\n\nThis account connects epistemic justification with free will. When a proposition is insufficiently understood, the meditator can suspend assent rather than decide without grounds. A mistaken judgment is therefore explained as a misuse of a faculty that is not itself defective. Descartes describes error as a privation: it is the absence of a correctness that should have been present in the judging act, rather than a positive entity requiring God to create falsehood. Finitude alone is not an error. A limited intellect can operate properly so long as the will does not affirm what the intellect fails to disclose adequately.\n\nDescartes also challenges the view that freedom is greatest when reasons for competing choices are evenly balanced. Indifference arising from ignorance is, in this account, the lowest grade of freedom. Clear apprehension of what is true or good inclines the will strongly without thereby making its act externally coerced. The more clearly the truth is understood, the more freely assent can occur. This makes Cartesian freedom different from an account that identifies freedom exclusively with an unmotivated capacity to choose either alternative. His broader writings complicate the question of alternative possibilities, but the Meditations places special emphasis on spontaneity guided by understanding.\n\nThe explanation includes a qualification about the limits of human theological judgment. A finite person cannot expect to comprehend every purpose of an infinite creator or to assess the perfection of the whole universe from the condition of one part. Descartes does not offer a detailed explanation of why every particular error is permitted. Instead, he argues that the occurrence of error is compatible with a nondeceptive creator because the faculties involved can be used correctly.\n\nThe remedy stated within the argument is correspondingly precise: assent should remain within the limits of clear and distinct perception. Unlike sensory uncertainty, which concerns whether experience represents external things faithfully, the problem here concerns the act by which a thinker commits to a proposition. The Fourth Meditation thereby explains how certainty and human fallibility can coexist."
    },
    {
      "heading": "The Fifth Meditation: essences and the ontological argument",
      "text": "The Fifth Meditation first considers what can be known about material things before their existence is established. Descartes identifies extension in length, breadth, and depth, together with shape, position, motion, and duration, as intelligible features of corporeal nature. Geometrical objects have determinate properties that are not freely alterable by the thinker. A triangle, for example, has a nature whose consequences can be demonstrated even if no triangle exists outside thought. Discovering such consequences differs from inventing a fictional creature whose attributes can be assigned at will. Descartes describes these mathematical natures as true and immutable.\n\nThis discussion concerns the distinction between essence and existence. Knowing what a triangle is does not prove that triangular objects actually exist. Descartes nevertheless argues that the case of a supremely perfect being is exceptional. In the ontological argument developed here, necessary existence belongs inseparably to God’s essence. Just as certain geometrical properties cannot be detached from the nature of a triangle, existence cannot be removed from the conception of a being possessing every perfection. God is therefore not merely an object that could exist if instantiated; necessary existence is claimed to belong to what God is.\n\nDescartes anticipates the objection that thought cannot impose necessity on reality. Conceiving a mountain together with a valley does not establish that either exists. His response is that the mountain–valley connection establishes only that the two are inseparable if they exist, whereas the idea of God contains existence itself as inseparable from supreme perfection. The necessity, on his account, is not invented by the thinker but discovered in the object’s nature. This is why the argument cannot simply be reproduced for any imaginary object: the necessary existence at issue is supposed to belong specifically to an infinite and supremely perfect being.\n\nThe argument resembles earlier reasoning associated with Anselm of Canterbury, although Descartes embeds it in his own account of clear and distinct perception. Its critics question whether existence is a perfection that can enter an essence in this way, whether the relevant divine concept is coherent, and whether conceptual inseparability entails actual existence. Later, Immanuel Kant would argue that existence is not a real predicate adding a determination to a concept, a criticism that became central to discussion of this family of proofs.\n\nThe Fifth Meditation also relates knowledge of God to stable mathematical certainty. A person may grasp a demonstration while attending to it, yet later become uncertain when recalling its conclusion without its supporting steps. Descartes presents divine nondeception as securing confidence that properly apprehended truths remain true, allowing knowledge to persist beyond the moment of immediate intellectual attention."
    },
    {
      "heading": "The Sixth Meditation: bodies, real distinction, and embodiment",
      "text": "The Sixth Meditation considers the existence of material things and the relation between the mind and the body. Descartes first distinguishes imagination from pure understanding. A triangle can be both understood and pictured, whereas a thousand-sided polygon can be understood without a comparably distinct mental image of all its sides. Imagination therefore appears to involve something beyond the mind’s purely intellectual activity. Descartes treats this difference as suggesting a connection with a body, but not as a sufficient demonstration of bodily existence. The decisive argument must account for sensory experience and the apparent passivity with which it is received.\n\nSensory ideas arise without the meditator’s choosing them and sometimes against its wishes. Descartes reasons that an active source must produce these experiences. They cannot, in the relevant respect, originate from the self considered simply as a thinking thing, since they occur without its awareness or control of their production. God could conceivably cause such ideas directly, but the meditator has a strong natural inclination to regard them as coming from bodies. If that inclination were systematically misleading and no corrective capacity had been supplied, divine nondeception would be compromised. Descartes therefore concludes that material things exist, while denying that every sensory quality resembles a property in the object exactly as experienced.\n\nThe argument for mind–body dualism rests on the clear and distinct conceivability of mind and body apart. The mind is understood as thinking and nonextended; body is understood as extended and nonthinking. Because God can create separately what can be clearly and distinctly understood separately, mind and body are really distinct. A further contrast reinforces this conclusion: bodies are divisible into parts, whereas the mind, considered as a subject of thought, is not apprehended as spatially divisible. These arguments establish possible separate existence, not the claim that human minds ordinarily operate without bodies.\n\nIndeed, Descartes explicitly denies that the mind is merely lodged in the body like a sailor in a ship. Hunger, thirst, and pain disclose an intimate union. Bodily injury is not simply registered as a detached intellectual report; it is felt as suffering by the embodied person. This aspect of the text makes the mind–body problem more complex than a simple opposition between two independent substances.\n\nSensory error is explained partly through bodily mechanisms. The same pattern of motion reaching the brain can arise from different points along a nerve pathway, so a sensation normally associated with injury in one location may occur without that injury. The system can be beneficial overall without being infallible in every unusual circumstance. Finally, waking experience is distinguished from dreams through its coherent connection with memory and the wider course of life. The recovered material world is thus warranted through coordinated judgment, not through unconditional trust in every appearance."
    },
    {
      "heading": "Clear and distinct perception and the Cartesian circle",
      "text": "The relation between intellectual evidence and divine assurance generates the objection known as the Cartesian circle. Descartes appears to argue that whatever is clearly and distinctly perceived is true because a perfect God would not deceive. Yet his proofs of God employ principles that he takes to be clearly and distinctly perceived, including the causal adequacy principle. If those principles are trustworthy only after God has been proved, the proof seems to presuppose the very guarantee it is meant to establish. The issue concerns the order of justification, not merely the order in which topics appear in the book.\n\nOne response distinguishes the certainty of a presently attended intuition from the general reliability of the cognitive faculty. While clearly attending to a proposition, the meditator cannot genuinely withhold assent from it. The existence of God is then needed not to produce that immediate certainty but to remove a higher-order doubt about whether clear perception might nevertheless be systematically defective. On this interpretation, the argument begins with intellectual acts that carry their own present assurance and subsequently establishes a general principle permitting stable knowledge. The distinction is between a particular act’s self-evidence and a comprehensive account of why such acts are truth-conducive.\n\nAnother response emphasizes memory. A proof may be evident while its steps are being inspected, but many demonstrations cannot remain wholly before the mind at once. Once attention shifts, the meditator remembers having understood the argument without directly contemplating every inference. Descartes’s replies repeatedly connect divine assurance with the security of such remembered demonstrations. This reading gives the proof of God a role in preserving scientific knowledge across time rather than in validating each immediate intuition. The difficulty is whether the proof of God itself can be completed without relying on the very memory whose trustworthiness is allegedly still in question.\n\nInterpretations also differ over the status of the radical doubt. Some regard the possibility of a deceiving creator as a genuine challenge to every rational judgment except the cogito. Others treat it as a provisional anxiety that cannot actually overturn a fully clear act of understanding. These alternatives affect whether the divine proof must meet an independent skeptical standard or merely explain the certainty already encountered in intellectual experience.\n\nThe controversy exposes a structural problem in foundationalism: a theory seeking ultimate grounds must explain how its starting points are warranted without requiring a further ground of the same kind. Descartes’s approach makes exceptionally strong demands on certainty. Whether that ambition can be met without circularity remains a major reason the Meditations continues to receive close argumentative analysis."
    },
    {
      "heading": "The objections and replies as part of the work",
      "text": "The Meditations was circulated before publication through Marin Mersenne, who solicited criticisms from scholars in Descartes’s intellectual network. Six sets of objections accompanied the first edition, and a seventh set appeared with the second edition in 1642. The resulting exchanges are not merely later commentary: they belong to the work’s original public presentation and clarify how Descartes intended key claims to be understood. The objectors did not share a single standpoint. They included theologians, scholastic philosophers, a materialist critic, and an advocate of a more empirically oriented philosophy.\n\nAntoine Arnauld, author of the Fourth Objections, formulated influential challenges concerning circularity and the mind–body distinction. He questioned whether a thinker might clearly conceive itself without a body while nevertheless failing to recognize a bodily feature essential to its nature. A person’s incomplete knowledge of an object does not ordinarily establish that unrecognized properties are separable from it. Descartes answered by distinguishing a merely inadequate description from a clear and distinct conception sufficient to apprehend a complete thing. The dispute therefore turns on what completeness of understanding requires, not simply on whether minds and bodies appear different.\n\nThomas Hobbes, in the Third Objections, challenged the transition from thinking to an immaterial thinking substance. Recognizing an activity, he argued, does not settle the nature of the thing that performs it; the subject of thought might be corporeal. Descartes replied that his initial identification of the self as thinking did not yet contain the completed argument for immateriality. Their disagreement also involved language and universals: Hobbes’s account of reasoning gave a larger role to names, whereas Descartes insisted that intellectual understanding could not be reduced to verbal operations or bodily images.\n\nPierre Gassendi, in the Fifth Objections, questioned the extremity of the method of doubt, the alleged innateness and causal origin of the idea of God, and the account of the mind’s knowledge of itself. His criticisms pressed Descartes on whether the thinking self had been adequately described and whether concepts attributed to pure intellect could instead arise from experience and abstraction. Descartes’s replies defended the distinction between imagining something and understanding it, a distinction essential to his accounts of infinity, mathematical objects, and mind.\n\nOther objections examined the causal proofs, theological implications, and logical form of the demonstrations. In the Second Replies, Descartes supplied a geometrical presentation using definitions, postulates, axioms, and propositions. He nevertheless maintained that this synthetic arrangement was not the best way to lead readers away from sensory prejudice. The combination of meditative argument and formal restatement allows the published work to be read both as an exercise in intellectual reorientation and as a set of claims exposed to public criticism."
    },
    {
      "heading": "Philosophical reception and enduring interpretive divisions",
      "text": "The Meditations helped establish a distinctive starting point for early modern philosophy: the demand to justify claims about reality through an examination of the knowing subject. It became a principal text associated with rationalism, especially because of its treatment of innate ideas, intellectual intuition, and mathematical demonstration. Yet the work is not simply a rejection of experience. The Sixth Meditation restores sensory knowledge within limits, and Descartes’s natural philosophy depended on engagement with observable phenomena. The characteristic claim is that the most secure account of nature must be grounded in intelligible principles rather than accepted directly from sensory appearance.\n\nLater seventeenth-century philosophers transformed rather than merely repeated its arguments. Baruch Spinoza rejected a plurality of independent substances in favor of one substance, with thought and extension understood as attributes. Nicolas Malebranche developed an occasionalist account in which God, rather than created mind or matter, is the genuine efficient cause of events. Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz offered a different account of substance and coordination through pre-established harmony. These positions responded, among other things, to difficulties about how thinking and extended substances could be causally related. Outside the Meditations itself, Princess Elisabeth of Bohemia’s correspondence with Descartes in 1643 pressed the question of how an immaterial mind could determine bodily motion.\n\nPhilosophers associated with empiricism challenged different parts of the Cartesian inheritance. John Locke rejected innate principles and developed an account of ideas grounded in sensation and reflection. David Hume questioned whether introspection reveals the kind of continuing mental substance Descartes describes. Kant subsequently argued that the unity expressed by “I think” does not justify theoretical knowledge of the self as a simple, enduring substance. In the *Critique of Pure Reason*, this issue becomes part of the critique of rational psychology, alongside his examination of traditional proofs of God.\n\nThe work also shaped approaches that opposed its apparent isolation of the subject. Edmund Husserl explicitly revisited Descartes in his Cartesian Meditations, while transforming the inquiry through phenomenology. Twentieth-century philosophy examined whether doubt can be separated from ordinary linguistic practices, whether knowledge requires certainty, and whether mental life can be understood independently of embodiment and social relations. Contemporary skeptical scenarios such as the brain in a vat reproduce the structural question of whether internally indistinguishable experiences can establish an external world, even when they omit Descartes’s theological framework.\n\nA continuing interpretive division concerns how to read the six meditations together. One approach reconstructs them as a sequence of independently assessable demonstrations; another emphasizes the discipline of attention through which the reader acquires new intellectual habits. Related disagreements concern whether the final standpoint defeats skepticism on its own terms, replaces the skeptic’s standards, or depends on metaphysical premises that skepticism need not grant. The text’s arguments remain inseparable from this question about the kind of philosophical transformation its ordered exercises are intended to produce."
    }
  ],
  "links": [
    "rene-descartes",
    "knowledge",
    "epistemology",
    "metaphysics",
    "philosophy-of-mind",
    "discourse-on-the-method",
    "catholic-church",
    "meditation",
    "philosophical-skepticism",
    "thought-experiment",
    "cogito-ergo-sum",
    "causation",
    "epistemic-justification",
    "free-will",
    "immanuel-kant",
    "mind-body-dualism",
    "mind-body-problem",
    "foundationalism",
    "thomas-hobbes",
    "rationalism",
    "baruch-spinoza",
    "empiricism",
    "john-locke",
    "david-hume",
    "critique-of-pure-reason",
    "phenomenology",
    "brain-in-a-vat"
  ],
  "sources": [],
  "license": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"
}