{
  "id": "civil-service-examinations",
  "title": "Chinese Civil Service Examinations",
  "lang": "en",
  "source_lang": "en",
  "summary": "China’s civil service examinations selected officials through competitive literary testing and shaped government, education, and social status until their abolition in 1905.",
  "category": "society",
  "subcategory": "education",
  "type": "concept",
  "aliases": [
    "Chinese imperial examinations",
    "Imperial Chinese examination system",
    "Keju",
    "Civil examinations of imperial China"
  ],
  "generated_at": "2026-11-05",
  "model": "pro/gpt-6.1-sol",
  "url": "https://aiwiki.page/en/civil-service-examinations/",
  "translations": {
    "zh-Hans": {
      "url": "https://aiwiki.page/zh/civil-service-examinations/",
      "json": "https://aiwiki.page/zh/civil-service-examinations.json"
    }
  },
  "sections": [
    {
      "heading": "",
      "text": "The Chinese civil service examinations were a changing set of state-administered competitions used to identify, rank, and recruit candidates for civil office in imperial China. Known in Chinese as keju, they developed from earlier methods of recommendation and assessment, acquired recognizable institutional form under the Sui and Tang dynasties, and became central to elite recruitment from the Song dynasty onward. Their mature form tested command of the Confucian classics, literary composition, and questions concerning government. The examinations were abolished in 1905, shortly before the end of imperial rule.\n\nTheir significance extended beyond the appointment of officials. They connected education to political authority, established widely recognized credentials, supported a common literary culture, and helped define the social standing of educated men and their families. Competitive success could transform a family’s prospects, but access depended heavily on resources, location, sex, and legal status. Examination achievement was neither a guarantee of office nor the only route into government.\n\nThe system changed substantially over its approximately thirteen-century history. Early examinations coexisted with aristocratic privilege; later dynasties expanded competition while developing elaborate procedures against favoritism and fraud. Its history therefore concerns both administrative recruitment and the wider organization of knowledge, opportunity, and power."
    },
    {
      "heading": "Origins in Recommendation and Early Imperial Recruitment",
      "text": "Before competitive literary examinations became an established institution, Chinese rulers recruited officials through several overlapping mechanisms: hereditary standing, personal recommendation, service in subordinate posts, and assessments of particular skills. Under the Han dynasty, which ruled from 206 BCE to 220 CE with an intervening interruption, regional authorities recommended men under categories such as “filial and incorrupt.” Recommendations expressed the expectation that proper conduct within the household indicated suitability for public responsibility. Candidates might subsequently undergo questioning or written assessment, but nomination and reputation remained essential.\n\nThe establishment of the imperial academy in 124 BCE under Emperor Wu of Han strengthened the relationship between classical scholarship and official careers. Its students studied texts that became central to Confucianism, and some entered government after evaluation. Nevertheless, Han recruitment was not a unified competitive examination ladder. The capacity to secure a recommendation depended on local recognition and relationships with established officials. The academy supplied one important institutional ancestor of later examinations, not a complete early version of them.\n\nDuring the period of political division after the Han, the nine-rank system classified prospective officials through evaluators charged with assessing character and ability. Introduced in the state of Cao Wei in the third century, it increasingly reflected the standing of powerful families. High-status lineages accumulated advantages in appointment, marriage, and cultural training. Written learning mattered, but it operated within an aristocratic political order rather than displacing it.\n\nThe Sui dynasty, which reunited China in 589, is conventionally credited with establishing the foundations of the keju. The year 605 is frequently given as the beginning of the jinshi examination category, although the surviving evidence does not support treating a single decree as the creation of the entire later system. The transition was gradual: recruitment by specified subjects, direct application, written testing, and centralized assessment developed through successive changes.\n\nUnder the Tang dynasty, founded in 618, examinations became a regular and prestigious avenue into official life. Candidates could arrive through government schools or local sponsorship, and different examination categories tested different accomplishments. The mingjing category emphasized mastery of the classics, while the jinshi category increasingly rewarded literary skill. Passing still did not automatically produce an appointment; further evaluation and access to influential patrons could matter greatly. The early system thus introduced a competitive principle without eliminating inherited privilege or personal connections."
    },
    {
      "heading": "Expansion and Institutional Change from Tang to Qing",
      "text": "Tang examination graduates constituted a prestigious group, but they did not monopolize official recruitment. Members of powerful families continued to benefit from inherited status and the protection privilege, through which an official’s rank could facilitate appointments for relatives. Candidates also circulated their writings among prominent men before examinations. Such literary self-presentation made reputation visible to examiners and patrons, but it differed sharply from the later ideal of judging an anonymous script.\n\nA major transformation occurred under the Song dynasty, established in 960. The imperial government expanded examination recruitment and made successful candidates increasingly important within the civil administration. Palace examinations became a regular final stage under imperial authority. Practices such as concealing candidates’ names and recopying scripts reduced opportunities to recognize handwriting or favor known applicants. These measures developed over time rather than appearing as a complete package at the dynasty’s foundation.\n\nThe Song also witnessed repeated disputes about what examinations should measure. Literary composition, classical interpretation, and practical policy knowledge competed for emphasis. During the reforms associated with Wang Anshi in the late eleventh century, classical exposition and policy discussion received greater weight, while officially sponsored interpretations sought to guide learning. Changes in examination content were therefore part of larger disagreements about government: selecting officials also meant deciding what kinds of knowledge the state should authorize.\n\nThe Yuan dynasty, founded by the Mongols, did not immediately restore a regular empire-wide examination system after conquering the Southern Song in 1279. A restoration was ordered in 1313, with examinations held in 1315. Candidates were divided into legally defined groups, including Mongols, semu peoples, northern Chinese, and southern Chinese, with separate quotas and differing requirements. The arrangement combined classical recruitment with the dynasty’s hierarchy of political and ethnic status. Examinations supplied only part of the Yuan official establishment.\n\nThe Ming dynasty, founded in 1368, and the Qing dynasty, established in 1644, consolidated the best-known examination structure. After an early Ming interruption, regular examinations resumed in 1384. Provincial, metropolitan, and palace competitions became linked in a recurrent sequence, while local qualification examinations regulated access to that sequence. The Qing retained this framework but accommodated banner institutions, regional quotas, and additional appointment routes. Across these dynasties, continuity in titles and ritual concealed changes in eligibility, curriculum, administration, and the relationship between examination success and actual employment."
    },
    {
      "heading": "Degrees, Examination Stages, and Routes to Office",
      "text": "In the mature Ming–Qing system, an aspiring candidate generally began with a sequence of local qualifying examinations. These included county and prefectural assessments followed by an examination supervised by the provincial educational commissioner. Successful entrants acquired the status commonly called shengyuan, or xiucai. This was a recognized scholarly qualification, not a modern university degree. Candidates described as tongsheng, often translated as “apprentice students,” could be adults or elderly men; the term indicated their position in the qualification structure rather than their age.\n\nThe shengyuan population was itself differentiated. Some held stipendiary places, while others occupied categories without equivalent support. Their standing was subject to periodic assessment and disciplinary supervision. Qualification brought social recognition and specified privileges, but it did not ordinarily confer a salaried civil appointment. Many holders worked as teachers, tutors, writers, or local intermediaries while continuing to seek higher success.\n\nThe next major competition was the provincial examination, normally held every three years in the autumn. Successful candidates became juren, a title often rendered “recommended men.” Provincial success opened eligibility for the metropolitan examination and could also provide access to certain official posts. The highest-ranked provincial candidate was called jieyuan. Because the number of successful candidates was fixed by quota, provincial examinations were contests for a limited set of places, not simply tests with a universal passing standard.\n\nThe metropolitan examination normally followed in the spring of the next year. Successful candidates, called gongshi, proceeded to the palace examination, which determined their ranking as jinshi, conventionally translated as “presented scholars.” In the mature system the palace stage generally ranked rather than eliminated those who had already passed the metropolitan competition. The top three received the celebrated titles zhuangyuan, bangyan, and tanhua. Their exceptional visibility should not obscure the much larger population of graduates ranked below them.\n\nThese stages were not an automatic conveyor belt into office. Appointment depended on rank, vacancies, further selection, administrative rules, and sometimes substantial waiting periods. Some outstanding graduates entered the Hanlin Academy, an institution associated with drafting, scholarship, and preparation for high office. Others entered ministries or territorial administration.\n\nParallel routes remained important. These included the protection privilege, recommendations, institutional study, and the purchase of degrees or appointment eligibility under regulated contribution schemes. Military examinations formed a separate system, testing combinations of physical accomplishment, archery, horsemanship, and military knowledge. The familiar civil degree ladder was therefore the most prestigious part of a broader recruitment order, not its entirety."
    },
    {
      "heading": "The Curriculum and the Skills Being Tested",
      "text": "The examinations tested a learned tradition rather than a single unchanging syllabus. Tang candidates in the jinshi category demonstrated literary accomplishment through forms that included poetry and rhapsodic prose, alongside other written exercises. Other categories placed greater emphasis on memorized passages and interpretation of classical texts. Later reforms repeatedly altered the relative weight of literary elegance, textual learning, and discussion of government problems.\n\nFrom the Yuan period onward, the Four Books assumed a particularly authoritative position. This collection comprised the Analects, Mencius, Great Learning, and Doctrine of the Mean. The commentaries of Zhu Xi, the twelfth-century thinker closely associated with Neo-Confucianism, became an official interpretive foundation. The Five Classics—the Book of Changes, Book of Documents, Book of Poetry, Record of Rites, and Spring and Autumn Annals—also remained central, although requirements concerning their study varied.\n\nPreparation required command of literary Chinese, familiarity with extensive textual traditions, and the ability to compose under severe constraints. Memorization was essential, but successful composition demanded more than verbatim recall. Candidates had to identify the implications of a passage, organize an argument, employ appropriate diction, and avoid interpretations that violated accepted moral or textual assumptions. Knowledge could be tested through a very short quotation whose meaning depended on recognizing its original context.\n\nThe eight-legged essay, or baguwen, became the characteristic classical essay form of the Ming and Qing examinations. Its mature conventions required a prescribed sequence of sections and carefully balanced parallel passages. Writers were expected to expound a classical statement in a voice consistent with authoritative teaching rather than present unrestricted personal opinion. The form rewarded disciplined organization and verbal control, while also encouraging specialized coaching and imitation. Its exact requirements and word limits changed over time.\n\nOther examination components included policy questions, administrative discussions, and, in certain periods, regulated verse. Policy questions could concern fiscal administration, historical precedents, military affairs, or the selection of officials. Their presence complicates the claim that the system tested nothing except literary ornament. Conversely, discussing government through classical and historical models was not equivalent to demonstrating practical competence in every duty of office.\n\nThe curriculum produced a shared ethical and literary vocabulary across a large territory. It did not constitute comprehensive professional training in engineering, medicine, accounting, or judicial procedure. Officials often learned such matters after appointment, relying on handbooks, experienced subordinates, and clerical personnel. The examinations primarily certified a form of cultivated judgment that the state considered suitable for governing."
    },
    {
      "heading": "Examination Compounds, Marking, and the Prevention of Fraud",
      "text": "Large examinations required substantial physical and administrative infrastructure. Provincial examination compounds, known as gongyuan, contained rows of narrow individual cells, together with gates, watchtowers, administrative buildings, kitchens, and spaces for examiners. The Jiangnan examination compound at Nanjing was among the largest. In the mature system, candidates at major examinations commonly completed three sessions, each occupying several days under confinement. They brought permitted supplies and worked, ate, and rested within extremely restricted spaces.\n\nEntry procedures attempted to verify identity and exclude unauthorized materials. Candidates were registered and searched, and documents established their eligibility and place of registration. Officials sought to prevent impersonation, concealed notes, collusion, and the transmission of answers. Surviving miniature texts and garments covered in tiny writing illustrate the ingenuity devoted to evasion, although such objects cannot establish how common successful cheating actually was.\n\nAdministrative separation was equally important. Examiners could be confined before questions became public and isolated from outside communication until marking was complete. Scripts passed through different offices responsible for registration, concealment of names, transcription, comparison, and evaluation. In major examinations, copying a candidate’s work into standardized handwriting made recognition more difficult. The copied version could be checked against the original to reduce transcription errors. These procedures embodied an early institutional concern with separating an applicant’s social identity from assessment of the submitted work.\n\nThe system nevertheless retained points of vulnerability. A candidate might use distinctive wording to signal identity, while intermediaries could attempt to influence staff or examiners. Fraud could also involve false registration in a province with more favorable competition. The authorities imposed severe penalties, and examination scandals sometimes became major political events. The Shuntian examination scandal of 1858, involving the metropolitan region around Beijing, led to high-level prosecutions and the execution of the chief examiner Bai Jun.\n\nRanking remained an exercise of judgment rather than mechanical scoring. Examiners differed in literary taste, interpretation, and tolerance for unconventional arguments. Quotas meant that an acceptable essay could fail when stronger or more favorably assessed competitors occupied all available places. Repeated attempts therefore exposed candidates to changing questions, examiners, and circumstances.\n\nThe elaborate anti-fraud apparatus should be understood as a response to this combination of high stakes and discretionary evaluation. It could reduce direct favoritism without eliminating uncertainty, corruption, or the unequal preparation that preceded entry into the examination compound."
    },
    {
      "heading": "Access, Family Resources, and Social Mobility",
      "text": "The examinations offered a consequential avenue of advancement, but they were not open to everyone on equal terms. Women were excluded from the regular state civil examination ladder. Eligibility rules also restricted people assigned to certain legally stigmatized occupations or statuses, although the categories and the treatment of their descendants changed over time. Clerks, servants, and other groups could face specific barriers. Legal qualification therefore preceded academic competition.\n\nFor eligible men, preparation depended heavily on family resources. Learning literary Chinese and mastering the examination curriculum required years that could otherwise have been spent earning income. Books, tuition, travel, accommodation, and repeated examination attempts imposed additional costs. Poor candidates sometimes received help from relatives, patrons, charitable institutions, or lineage funds, but such support was unevenly distributed. The image of the impoverished student rising through talent described a real possibility rather than a typical starting position for all competitors.\n\nRegional differences also mattered. Commercially prosperous areas could sustain dense networks of schools, tutors, publishers, and educated households. Parts of the lower Yangzi region became particularly important centers of examination learning. Territorial quotas prevented the most educationally advantaged regions from simply taking every available place, but they also made success depend partly on registered origin. Competition was structured geographically as well as intellectually.\n\nHistorians distinguish mobility into degree-holding status from mobility into office. A family without a recent high official might still possess land, commercial wealth, a lower degree, or educated relatives. Conversely, descendants of prominent officials did not retain high office automatically. Examination competition could interrupt inherited political advantage while preserving broader advantages in education and wealth. Claims about mobility consequently depend on how “elite” and “non-elite” are defined, which generations are counted, and whether evidence includes maternal and collateral relatives.\n\nSuccess could alter a household’s position in the social structure through prestige, marriage opportunities, patronage, and access to administration. Kinship networks might pool resources in the hope that one successful candidate would benefit a wider group. The rewards were therefore collective as well as individual.\n\nMost candidates never reached the highest ranks. The system generated a large population whose learning exceeded their official opportunities: teachers, examination coaches, secretaries, literary specialists, and lower degree holders active in local affairs. These men were not simply unsuccessful future officials. They helped sustain education and local leadership, making the social effects of the examinations much broader than the careers of those who entered government."
    },
    {
      "heading": "Officials, Local Elites, and Imperial Authority",
      "text": "Examination recruitment helped imperial rulers create a civil bureaucracy whose members shared recognized qualifications without possessing an unconditional hereditary right to office. Especially from the Song onward, this supported the political prominence of scholar-officials. The system did not produce an administration independent of the ruler: the court determined examination regulations, authorized successful lists, controlled appointments, and could dismiss or punish officials. Competitive selection operated within monarchy.\n\nThe palace examination expressed this relationship ceremonially. Candidates who had already demonstrated scholarly ability received their final ranking under the emperor’s authority. This helped represent graduates as beneficiaries of the sovereign rather than merely clients of an examiner or regional patron. At the same time, shared examination years and teacher–student relationships generated networks among officials. Impersonal procedures and personal association therefore developed together rather than excluding one another.\n\nAn examination graduate appointed as a county magistrate encountered responsibilities far wider than essay writing. These could include collecting taxes, hearing legal cases, maintaining order, supervising relief, promoting education, and overseeing public works. The central government appointed relatively few ranked officials in relation to the population they governed. Magistrates consequently depended on clerks, runners, legal secretaries, local notables, and other intermediaries with practical knowledge. Classical credentials legitimized the officeholder but did not replace this administrative infrastructure.\n\nThe relationship between degrees and local government was especially important. Degree holders who did not hold office could organize or support schools, charitable granaries, relief efforts, community compacts, and the compilation of local gazetteers. Their authority came partly from recognized learning and partly from property, family connections, and their capacity to negotiate with officials. “Gentry” is often used for this overlapping field of scholarly status and local influence, but it should not be treated as a completely uniform legal class.\n\nThe system also allowed the state to regulate local prestige. Educational officials could discipline students and remove qualifications for misconduct. Territorial quotas incorporated different regions into a common hierarchy of honors. Under the Qing, separate arrangements for banner populations and other constituencies showed that recruitment also served the management of a politically differentiated empire.\n\nExamination recruitment thus strengthened state capacity in specific ways: it supplied officials, standardized elite learning, and connected local ambition to central institutions. It did not eliminate patronage, guarantee competence, or give all social groups equal influence over policy. Its political role lay in organizing service and status within the imperial order."
    },
    {
      "heading": "Schools, Publishing, and the Culture of Examination Life",
      "text": "The examinations created sustained demand for institutions of learning. Government schools existed at several administrative levels, while private tutors, village schools, lineage schools, and academies provided much of the actual preparation. Academies could function as centers of philosophical discussion as well as examination study, and their relationship to the official curriculum varied. Some teachers criticized narrowly instrumental preparation while still training students who hoped to pass.\n\nThe expansion of printing, especially from the Song period onward, made classical texts, commentaries, anthologies, and model essays more widely available. Commercial publishers produced guides tailored to different stages of the examination ladder. Collections of successful essays allowed students to study admired structures and phrasing, while annotated editions helped explain difficult passages. Printed learning reduced some barriers to access but did not eliminate differences in teaching quality or the time available for study.\n\nExamination culture extended into the organization of family life. Households could concentrate resources on a promising son, arrange work around his study, or depend on the earnings of other members during prolonged preparation. Women who could not compete themselves sometimes taught children, managed property, supported scholarly husbands, or produced literary work within educated households. Their contribution to the educational economy was substantial even though official credentials remained male.\n\nSuccess was publicly visible. Announced lists, celebrations, ceremonial arches, and accounts in genealogies and local gazetteers preserved the achievements of graduates. Names of successful candidates could become enduring family assets. Ritual observances also placed examination study within a moral and sacred landscape: candidates honored Confucius and sought assistance from figures associated with literary success, including Wenchang and Kuixing. These practices linked disciplined study with hopes about fate and recognition.\n\nThe frustrations of examination life generated an equally rich literary record. Pu Songling, who repeatedly failed to obtain the provincial degree, incorporated scholars, examinations, and supernatural reversals into Strange Tales from a Chinese Studio. Wu Jingzi’s eighteenth-century novel The Scholars satirized status-seeking, pretension, and the distortions created by the pursuit of credentials. Such works are evidence of contemporary criticism, though their fictional situations cannot be read as statistical descriptions of candidate experience.\n\nExamination culture therefore encompassed more than official doctrine. It included commercial calculation, family sacrifice, religious practice, literary creativity, and skepticism about worldly achievement. The same institution that promoted a standardized curriculum also generated varied responses to ambition, failure, and the relationship between learning and moral worth."
    },
    {
      "heading": "Nineteenth-Century Reform and Abolition in 1905",
      "text": "Criticism of examination learning long preceded the nineteenth century. Scholars such as Gu Yanwu in the seventeenth century objected to educational habits that detached literary performance from historical understanding and practical responsibility. Other critics attacked formulaic composition, the pursuit of rank, or the gap between credentials and governing ability. These arguments generally sought to reform learning and official recruitment rather than abolish classical education altogether.\n\nDuring the nineteenth century, military defeats, internal rebellions, fiscal pressures, and changing international relations intensified demands for different kinds of expertise. New institutions taught foreign languages, military technology, mathematics, and other subjects outside the conventional examination syllabus. The establishment of the Tongwen Guan in Beijing in 1862 illustrated the growth of specialized training alongside the inherited scholarly order. Yet the continued prestige of examination degrees made it difficult for new schools to compete for students and recognition.\n\nThe defeat of Qing China by Japan in the war of 1894–1895 gave additional force to proposals for educational and administrative reform. In 1898, reform measures associated with the Hundred Days’ Reform sought changes in examination content, including the displacement of the eight-legged essay. Much of that reform program was reversed after the political crisis later that year. Following the Boxer crisis of 1900, however, the Qing court adopted a broader reform agenda.\n\nIn 1901 the court again abolished the eight-legged essay as an examination requirement and revised the emphasis toward policy discussion and other forms of writing. Reformers also sought to coordinate the examination ladder with an expanding modern school system. New school graduates could receive forms of recognized status, creating a transitional arrangement in which older credentials and newer educational qualifications overlapped.\n\nThe final jinshi examinations were held in 1904. On 2 September 1905, the Qing court ordered the abolition of the civil examinations, ending the regular system before another cycle began. Officials supporting abolition argued that gradual reduction would not remove the powerful incentive to devote years to the old examination route. Ending it was intended to redirect students toward new schools and modern forms of training.\n\nAbolition did not instantly remove the influence of degree holders or erase classical learning. Existing graduates continued to serve in administration, education, commerce, and public affairs. Nevertheless, the decision severed the institutional connection that had linked classical competitive examination to official recruitment and social recognition. The educational reforms that followed increasingly organized advancement through schools, study abroad, and credentials associated with modern higher education."
    },
    {
      "heading": "East Asian Adaptations and Modern Interpretations",
      "text": "China’s examinations formed part of a wider East Asian history of classical learning and official selection. Neighboring states adopted, modified, or rejected particular features according to their own political institutions. These were not identical branches of a single administration. Shared texts and examination forms could support quite different relationships among monarchs, aristocracies, schools, and officeholders.\n\nIn Korea, the gwageo examinations were instituted under Goryeo in 958 and continued, with substantial changes, under the Joseon dynasty. Literary examinations existed alongside military and technical competitions. Although classical competence was central, access was strongly shaped by social standing and the dominance of the yangban elite. Korea’s system ended in the reforms of 1894. In Vietnam, court examinations began under the Lý dynasty in 1075 and developed their own institutions and elite traditions. The last imperial examination was held in 1919 under the Nguyễn dynasty. Japan adopted examinations within its early imperial institutions but did not sustain a comparably dominant competitive recruitment ladder; aristocratic and later warrior arrangements limited their role.\n\nEuropean observers encountered Chinese examinations through missionary writings, travel accounts, and diplomatic reporting. Some praised a system that appeared to reward learning rather than birth. Others criticized its literary curriculum or questioned its practical results. Such accounts contributed to European discussion of government by trained officials, but they often simplified Chinese institutions to serve arguments about politics at home.\n\nThe emergence of competitive civil service recruitment in nineteenth-century Britain is sometimes described as a direct borrowing from China. Chinese precedents did appear in public debate, but a simple line of institutional descent is misleading. British reform also arose from domestic patronage controversies, administrative needs, and experience in British India. The Northcote–Trevelyan Report of 1854 advocated recruitment by open competition and promotion by merit; it did not reproduce the Chinese curriculum, degree hierarchy, or relationship between monarch and scholar-official.\n\nModern scholarship likewise distinguishes several questions that earlier accounts often combined. One concerns whether examinations reduced hereditary control of office. Another concerns whether families with wealth and educational traditions dominated preparation. A third asks whether the tested skills predicted administrative performance. Evidence supporting competitive access at one level does not settle the others. Max Weber, for example, treated the Chinese educated official as an important comparative case while distinguishing classical cultural cultivation from modern specialized professional training.\n\nHistorical research now draws on examination records, family histories, local gazetteers, surviving scripts, printed manuals, and the careers of both successful and unsuccessful candidates. These materials allow study of regional opportunity, intergenerational advantage, examiner judgment, and the experience of repeated failure. Their survival is uneven: the records of celebrated graduates are generally much fuller than those of candidates who left no degree, office, or published work."
    }
  ],
  "links": [
    "china",
    "education",
    "confucianism",
    "song-dynasty",
    "yuan-dynasty",
    "ming-dynasty",
    "qing-dynasty",
    "juren",
    "jinshi",
    "poetry",
    "zhu-xi",
    "neo-confucianism",
    "eight-legged-essay",
    "family",
    "social-structure",
    "kinship",
    "taxation",
    "local-government",
    "state-capacity",
    "printing",
    "genealogy",
    "novel",
    "japan",
    "higher-education",
    "max-weber"
  ],
  "sources": [],
  "license": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"
}